I'm a bit confused by the related storylines between Gift and Within. In Gift, Dockett told Skinner that Scully signed the false reports Mulder turned submitted. Did she simply sign the reports without reading them? I doubt it. Yet, in the episode Within, Scully seemed unaware that Mulder was dying. That wouldnt seem plausible if she was aware of him going to see the disease eater. She believed him to be okay after CSMs surgery. Third, In Gethsemane, Murder stated he wouldn't ever ask Scully to lie except to those who had lied to them. Finally, Mulder would never have lied to Scully for over a year about his dying. He cared to much for her to do that. Points decreased for storyline, but increased for Pileggi being in episode and always giving a strong performance.
Review of The Gift
