For fans of fantasy and sci-fi, this show has potential and I guess we need to see where it goes. Hopefully it will start to take itself more seriously, cast members will actually speak instead of whisper, and each episode won't end with a group of screaming girls (or witches) panicking about the situation they find themselves in, cause that's already gotten old. It's the classic tale of good verses evil, although acting on the evil side is disappointing, always dressed in black and trying way to hard to appear evil. I guess we will need to wait and see although I am not holding my breath. But if the next episode ends with a bunch of screaming girls falling all over themselves screaming and panicking i am switching off.
20 Reviews
Good concept, but...
fdc24 November 2023
Even if it were a soap opera or telenovela, the over-acted melodrama is cloyingly interfering. At times the dialog and interactions put it on par with YA-bordering on juvenile-programming.
It's like a repackaged new age children's series trying to wear mommy's makeup and adding in some PG/R rated themes and hallucinogens in attempt to hook some adult attention.
It might be summarized as an ALLBLACK wannabe version of Charmed, but even less "believable".
If it hadn't been for the uniqueness for the target audience and niche network, I sincerely doubt it could have survived long enough to air the first season without being kicked to the curb. Even the attempts at new age fantasy schlock fall short.
It's like a repackaged new age children's series trying to wear mommy's makeup and adding in some PG/R rated themes and hallucinogens in attempt to hook some adult attention.
It might be summarized as an ALLBLACK wannabe version of Charmed, but even less "believable".
If it hadn't been for the uniqueness for the target audience and niche network, I sincerely doubt it could have survived long enough to air the first season without being kicked to the curb. Even the attempts at new age fantasy schlock fall short.
Jordan is ANNOYING AF
rbmiddleton19795 November 2023
It's cool for the most part. The acting is decent and sometimes over kill as usual. Started off stupid, but it got better. I get it, a bunch of women coming into their powers and trying their best to overcome obstacles and find answers. A newcomer that doesn't know she's a witch (nothing new at all) An eager to jumpstart her powers witch that is childlike and annoying at times. A grounded one. A sexual one. A mature one. Yay you have your coven. A mentor that basically shuns the newcomer until b.s. Starts to happen now the explanation starts when all of this could've been avoided instead of hiding the truth. I despise lazy writing. Anyway I gave it a 5 just because. It's not bad, but like I said...i despise lazy writing.
Made an account just to give the rating
jadyne-bianca8 December 2022
Its giving Sunset Beach BTEC. The production and quality is awful. The concept is great and could have displayed the history and power of Hoodoo and Voodoo showing its art and magical effects but if anything, goes against every fact about African magick and turns it into a show that does it no justice. This is a waste of production. This is like another really bad Tyler Perry production that shouldn't even of had made it to the screen. The special effects were awful, the acting below mediocre and overall just very unnecessary. I hope in future black directors and producers do their research about their concept before going ahead and making the script.
i wish it went a different way
Atlfanfav3588810 December 2022
I honestly see where story wants to go, but unfortunately the actresses aren't able to pull thru and give the story what it needs. Its like watching a bunch of people act like they are acting instead of being that character and a part of the story. Embarrassing.
I also wish certain characters weren't over the type tv tropes. I do like the idea of black women and witches but it has been done better in AHS and Vampire Diaries. Maybe those involved should have watched those shows to learn how to act and pull thru a better performance. No reason to work so hard just for us to watch you working hard at acting.
I also wish certain characters weren't over the type tv tropes. I do like the idea of black women and witches but it has been done better in AHS and Vampire Diaries. Maybe those involved should have watched those shows to learn how to act and pull thru a better performance. No reason to work so hard just for us to watch you working hard at acting.
Potential is there but they don't know it.
jamesparker-579874 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
MADE AN ACCOUNT TO COMMENT..HOPEFULLY THE PRODUCERS WILL STOP THRU AND SEE THE PUBS REACTION. STORYLINE IS SHAKY..COULD'VE GAVE MORE STRENGTH TO DETAILING CAMILLE AND HER MOM'S LIFE..THE SHOW SEEMS TO HAVE SOMETHING AGAINST MEN (THEY SEEM TO ONLY BE REFERENCED AS SYMBOLS)..MONA IS OVER THE TOP MOODY..YES SHE WENT THRU ALOT..BUT THE MOODINESS IS TOO MUCH BEING THAT SHE WAS GIVEN A SECOND CHANCE AND SENT WITH INSTRUCTIONS..TABITHA IS A CENTER PIECE OF THIS SHOW AND I HOPE THAT IT'S JUST A CLIFF HANGER MOVE TO KILL HER SO FAST..THAT WOULD BE WAY TOO DUMB AS SHE SEEMS MUCH TOO POWERFUL TO BE SO EASILY TAKEN DOWN AND BEING OVER A CENTURY OLD WOULD KNOW TO HAVE HAD A PERSONAL PROTECTIVE ENCHANTMENT IN PLACE ALREADY WITH EVERYTHING HAPPENING SUDDENLY..SHARESE IS A DUMB PUPPET..NOW IF SHE COMES FROM A FAMILY OF WITCHES..WHY DIDN'T SHE CALL HER MOTHER OR SOMETHING FOR AN ASSIST..JORDAN IS THE OBVIOUS CLARK KENT OF THE GROUP..AT SOME POINT SHE WILL TAP INTO A GREATER VERSION OF HERSELF AND EVOLVE..THE SHOW HAS POTENTIAL BUT THEY ARE SKATING ON THIN ICE..PLEASE DON'T LET THIS HANDLER BE A PIMP TYPE DUDE WHO NOBODY CAN STOP..AND IF THE COUNCIL IS ANYTHING LIKE THIS WEIRD CADEN..THEN THIS WON'T MAKE A 2ND SEASON.
Kinda cool
jpoetix7718 March 2024
I love all these beautiful and powerful black women witches! The storyline is a bit full and somewhat rushed and underdeveloped but I'm excited to see how it progresses. It has a "Charmesque" quality with the elders and the powerful coven. Their dress code is primarily black on black and they all rock it well. I had been looking for a show about witches and magic that is reflective of me as a black woman and I think I've found it.
Jordan is the exception; she's extremely annoying. I have to hit mute almost every time she opens her mouth. If you took a shot for each of her bouts of hysteria, you'd definitely be drunk.
Jordan is the exception; she's extremely annoying. I have to hit mute almost every time she opens her mouth. If you took a shot for each of her bouts of hysteria, you'd definitely be drunk.
Women and witches - watch and see
snw-4111716 December 2022
First I want to start by saying I waited until I saw a few episodes before I wrote a review. It seems like there's a lot of criticism from people who haven't given the show a chance. Which tells me they never went into it with an open mind. This is something I've never seen before, black female witches on a television streaming service, not Youtube, not some random website but an actual TV service. That's big on its own. The story is well written and the main actors are amazing. A few of the side characters are a little green but not bad, and yes some of the special effects aren't the best. HOWEVER! This is not a MARVEL TV show, you can't expect them to have that kind of budget from a network that's taking a big chance on something that's never been done. If the show is successful they'll probably get more money and that kind of stuff will improve. (Just like the first season of Shadow Hunters, those effects were sad but it was much better as the series went on.)
People should be paying attention to the writing and the acting. There are some great characters and I love the bonding between the women on this show. At its heart, it's a show about black women with some supernatural aspects. Which I love! I'm excited to see where the story takes the characters and how the villains come into play. I really hope it gets a season 2. People should actually watch the show through and not be so quick to judge based on a few minutes or the trailer and come with an open mind not looking for negatives. And remember that people can only do what they can do with the budget they have. If we don't support these kinds of shows you'll never see anything like this again!
People should be paying attention to the writing and the acting. There are some great characters and I love the bonding between the women on this show. At its heart, it's a show about black women with some supernatural aspects. Which I love! I'm excited to see where the story takes the characters and how the villains come into play. I really hope it gets a season 2. People should actually watch the show through and not be so quick to judge based on a few minutes or the trailer and come with an open mind not looking for negatives. And remember that people can only do what they can do with the budget they have. If we don't support these kinds of shows you'll never see anything like this again!
Good premise!
far-919729 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
It's apparent this show didn't have the best budget, because there are just too many technical flaws, and plot holes. Like at the very beginning when Camille's mother is killed, she's on the floor holding her and screams "somebody help!" In an empty house. Secondly we have the scenes where the girls are helping Jordan with her spell, and they are drawing blood for the ritual... but then suddenly their hands are fine afterwards. Also why is there a sound effect when they cut themselves? It doesn't make a sound. Thirdly, Mona's terrible and forced Spanish, like it's never mentioned that she's Afro-Latina in the show, nor does it add anything to the narrative. I just found it in bad taste, because it's literally unintelligible. Also the lore behind what magic they're using isn't quite established... because we see they can cast spells, but yet they also have magic types from birth? Like Jordan is a reader, Angela uses plant magic, Camille has death magic... etc. Yet we don't see them cast spell to activate their magic and it makes you wonder can all witches use different types of magic? Or can they only use their own magic type? These plot holes coupled with questionable filming lower the quality of the show. And it shows towards the end of the show that the writers didn't have a fully thought out script, because in the end they kinda just skipped how Camille's plan was thought out. It made the final action scene really awkward as Claudette and the handler were just in the center of the pentagram kinda looking at each other. Honestly it was probably made up as they went along. Because you have a lot of poor post editing, you can easily tell when they voiced over scenes. Probably to avoid re-shoots. I don't think it's going to get renewed, but I enjoyed Sheries character a lot, until the Claudette part they kinda nerfed her.
I love a good coven!
thomasvalerie-011244 January 2023
The only reason I wouldn't give it a higher rating is due to the clear or quality audio and video! I think the storyline is great! I love Vanessa Bell Calloway and will always give something she is in a chance! I am glad I did! I hope they keep going with this one! It's nice to see women of color in this genre. I also believe that if it stays the filmography will improve. I appreciate that is is not the same as the charmed reboot which I also like but I LOOOOOVE THIS! Don't leave us hanging with only 5 episodes. If you plan on taking it away after just one season at least finish the season! I love Sharice! She's giving "Remy Ma" if she was a witch Vibez!
The show has a good story line but one character spoils the show
lindsayranee27 February 2024
Love the show besides Jordan's character. I had to fast forward through alot of her parts because her character is soooo annoying I couldn't take it. How did they even get through filming this & not see that no one wants to constantly see & hear how she acts? It's not entertaining. If the storyline wasn't so good I would have completely stopped watching it because of that one character. It's that bad.
Love the show besides Jordan's character. I had to fast forward through alot of her parts because her character is soooo annoying I couldn't take it. How did they even get through filming this & not see that no one wants to constantly see & hear how she acts? It's not entertaining. If the storyline wasn't so good I would have completely stopped watching it because of that one character. It's that bad.
Love the show besides Jordan's character. I had to fast forward through alot of her parts because her character is soooo annoying I couldn't take it. How did they even get through filming this & not see that no one wants to constantly see & hear how she acts? It's not entertaining. If the storyline wasn't so good I would have completely stopped watching it because of that one character. It's that bad.
It's got good bones!
sgxrbsjzd14 December 2022
The show really has a strong premise. While the production and some of the acting may be an issue for some, I think the story more than makes up for that. The characters have their own personalities and I'm liking the magic system so far. I think the naysayers should give the show an opportunity to prove itself and grow before they write it off. We're only two episodes in at this point. I'm excited for more and think that if you like supernatural themed shows, this would tickle your fancy. Once the budget comes up, I think they'll really find their footing. I can't wait to see the characters be fleshed out and the storylines fully bloom.
Needs more polish
jadedrealist6 November 2023
The premise is interesting, the special effects are alright, it's got magic, sex, all the good stuff. What it doesn't have is someone pushing the actors to be better. Some of it is pretty bad. Like all the scenes were shot in one take without pulling the best perfomance possible out of the actors, which leaves things feeling a little cheap. Some of the actors are good, but that makes the poorly acted scenes stand out all the more. Now, to be fair I'm only on episode 4, and I'll keep watching just to see if they find their stride, but it's really like each episode is the pilot so far, and they are all still trying to find their chemistry.
I made an account just to leave a rating
gntsmum31 December 2022
This show has so much potential, I really think it deserves a chance! The actresses aren't completely on point however the storyline is intriguing and I am looking forward to seeing where they take it. I do wish that the episodes were longer so they could give more background. It tends to feel a little rushed and like we are missing important parts of the story. I've had to go back and rewatch multiple times only to realize I hadn't missed anything they just didn't explain when they should of. Even given those issues it's still got me coming back every Thursday to watch it. I hope they take the time to correct these issues.
Not bad but needs serious polish
rjones-750726 January 2024
It has a decent story but takes too long to get the story started. It reminds me of a black version of Charmed but more over the top with lesser CGI. The CGI is horrible but if you can get past that the acting is not bad just a bit over the top. The characters are interesting and has decent chemistry which kept my interest. The targeted audience is probably the reason for some of the over the top acting and writing. Some scenes are a bit stupid but it gets better, I feel like more polish is needed. Maybe bringing in producers with more visual experience on magical or occult tv shows/movies would help . I only stayed with it becuz I got interested halfway thru the series. It's only 6 episodes so you can binge in a day. Starting the 2nd season to see if my rating will change to better or worse.
WB + SyFy style magic
slytherin_9024 September 2023
The production quality reminds me of the WB and SyFy channel; we're not talking high quality special effects with this show, or high caliber acting. This isn't to say that either channels haven't produced some great quality productions (Buffy, Firefly, and Stargate SG-1) but, the WB and SyFy definitely have a vibe and to me, Wicked City could be slotted right in without much notice. It's the first season of the show and the chance to find it's footing and work out the kins is well deserved. The concept is fun and another show about magic, mayhem, and personal growth is always welcome.
All in all, it's not Oscar-worthy but still fun. Without the expectation of high art this show can be enjoyed as a b-level show focused on a group of women in Atlanta honing their skills and stepping into their identities as individuals with agency as well as power, and more than what society typically allows women thanks to magic.
The idea of an all Black coven is kinda cool and doesn't often get representation. Black witches have appeared in other shows for sure but, it's interesting to have a shift in perspective and have the full focus on Black women engaging in witchcraft, and styles that aren't historically Black and/or closed practices. The magic is eclectic and more respectful than other shows of been towards cultures and groups. It isn't perfect in this regard but, it's TV.
Giving it an 8/10 because there's room for improvement but plenty of shows weren't perfect right out of the gate. The concept gets high marks and it'll be interesting to see where the show is going. Would also like to see this show on a more mainstream platform versus one so niche. Not only do I not want to deal with another subscription but, non-Black folk would likely be interested in this show, too and it can come off as a bit exclusive where it's currently streaming.
Looking forward to a second season of Wicked City.
All in all, it's not Oscar-worthy but still fun. Without the expectation of high art this show can be enjoyed as a b-level show focused on a group of women in Atlanta honing their skills and stepping into their identities as individuals with agency as well as power, and more than what society typically allows women thanks to magic.
The idea of an all Black coven is kinda cool and doesn't often get representation. Black witches have appeared in other shows for sure but, it's interesting to have a shift in perspective and have the full focus on Black women engaging in witchcraft, and styles that aren't historically Black and/or closed practices. The magic is eclectic and more respectful than other shows of been towards cultures and groups. It isn't perfect in this regard but, it's TV.
Giving it an 8/10 because there's room for improvement but plenty of shows weren't perfect right out of the gate. The concept gets high marks and it'll be interesting to see where the show is going. Would also like to see this show on a more mainstream platform versus one so niche. Not only do I not want to deal with another subscription but, non-Black folk would likely be interested in this show, too and it can come off as a bit exclusive where it's currently streaming.
Looking forward to a second season of Wicked City.
Masterpiece potential
shadairice22 February 2023
This is a great show about urban witches with different abilities a going through daily struggles each learning, making mistakes and growing from them just like everybody else in the world. I love the fact the creators finally putting a show worth watching every min and the fact we are seeing something fresh and new like a Black Witch coven is AMAZING. Finally a Change and a good change!!! I definitely enjoyed every minute as I am of the blood myself who have seen just about every witch show there is and this show is by far my top 3 faves the only thing I recommend is limiting the sexual scene and extreme vulgar language because I would love my children to be able to Watch as well :)
I rate this show a 10 because....
tapharoahelliott9 October 2023
I'm entertained! In later seasons, hopefully they explore more African magic practices and really authenticate the tone. Like another review said, it sort of feels like "actors trying to act". In example: Casting a black actor/actress for a role that's been predominantly portrayed by white actors and the actor tries to add their essence to a character that was written for someone white. It kind of feels like the tone of this show, only because of the type/tone of magic that's being depicted. I'm in love with the idea! I won't be petty over production quality or graphics because I understand the business side. But also like someone else said, I would love to see the story go really deep and give the characters more of an authentic definition. But outside of my honest opinion, I really am entertained and will continue to watch because it's the only series featuring an all black cast of witches (to my knowledge) and I'm supporting. Witchcraft is something typically frowned upon in the black community. So, the series is definitely ground-breaking regardless. And that's all that really matters.
Wicked
beeunique-372158 February 2024
With our support this show has the potential to up their budget. I love that this is for us by us and something totally different from the expectations of the type of movies or tv shows that we are normally featured in. The characters are beautiful and they aren't overly made up meaning they are relatable. This isn't your typical witch show and it's not a knock off of charmed what we are use to watching so don't have that expectation. Have an open mind and give the story line an opportunity to be revealed. I'm speaking into existence that there will be another season and more stories coming out.
THANK YOU WRITERS AND CREW!!
0GlitchWitch03 January 2024
Refreshing, representative, revolutionary!
First of all, every single cast member is absolutely beautiful. They play their characters well-sometimes too well- and adds dynamic to their role. I love how dramatic the story line is and it truly capture my attention. It kind of reminds me of a show on ABC or lifetime but with more representation. I also appreciate how the writers include tarot as a super power for Jordan. Tarot is sometimes overlooked as a skill in the occult and as Jordan learns to love her power it shows the viewers the importance of it and how useful it can be. I'm excited to see how this show grows! :)
First of all, every single cast member is absolutely beautiful. They play their characters well-sometimes too well- and adds dynamic to their role. I love how dramatic the story line is and it truly capture my attention. It kind of reminds me of a show on ABC or lifetime but with more representation. I also appreciate how the writers include tarot as a super power for Jordan. Tarot is sometimes overlooked as a skill in the occult and as Jordan learns to love her power it shows the viewers the importance of it and how useful it can be. I'm excited to see how this show grows! :)
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
