Comedian Doug Benson gets stoned and makes mind-altered decisions as a high court judge, dealing with small-claims court cases. The first case begins with a dispute between two friends, involving a car that got towed after the owner loaned it out.
A young woman inadvertently breaks her friend's TV when she throws a remote at him in anger, but then claims that he is the one at fault. Judge Doug calls upon guest bailiff Gerald "Slink" Johnson for help in reaching a verdict.
Judge Doug must decide whether an ex-boyfriend is owed money for investing in his ex-girlfriend's music career. Guest bailiff Reggie Watts helps him come to a verdict.
Todd Glass serves as the guest bailiff while Judge Doug hears a case about a lackluster blues singer who claims he's owed payment for a past performance.