Kantai Collection: Kan Colle (TV Series 2015–2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
KanColle
Tweekums3 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Set in an alternative world where instead of the Second World War where the seas have been taken over by the Fleet of the Abyss; monster ships that attack ships and aircraft; this series follows those who battle against them… a fleet of young girls who possess the souls of previously lost military ships! While there are many ships in the fleet the story is centred around Fubuki, a destroyer whose competence initially leave a lot to be desired. Over the course of the series, through hard work and determination, she improves to the point where she can play an important role within the fleet. While the characters aren't battling with the Abyss we see their lives as they train, argue and form friendships back at their base.

While this series is fairly enjoyable it feels like a cross between 'Strike Witches' and 'Arpeggio of Blue Steel' without being as good as either. Fubuki isn't a bad character but she isn't really interesting enough to carry the series and the large supporting cast means no character is given enough time to let the viewer grow to care about them. With the exception of the aircraft carriers it was difficult to remember who is who. As far as the enemy goes; they look nicely menacing but they don't come across as all that menacing; they are fighting a war at sea but we don't see them attacking the girls' home towns or anything to make them a huge threat. It isn't all bad though; the action scenes are fairly dynamic and the way the aircraft carrier girls launch their planes with a bow and arrow is pretty cool and rather inventive. Overall this isn't a must see series but it undemanding fun for the most part.

These comments are based on watching the series in Japanese with English subtitles.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
it's good but could be better but it could worse, if you just switch off then you can enjoy it. but stream it instead of buying it.
phillipalexander-311981 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
to the anime, the story is an unknown fleet from the deepest depths of the ocean mankind called them abyssal, the abyssal drove mankind out of the seas, destroying all of our ships and so the fleet girls where made to fight the abyssal, the fleet girls posses the souls of past ww2 Japanese war ships from destroyers to Standard Carriers.

OK characters, a ship new call Fubuki who is a destroyer arrives at the naval district to fight and she joins torpedo squadron three and meets Mutsuki and Yuudachi who will soon be her friends, she also wants to fight along side Akagi from carrier group one, in all honesty the characters are kind of boring and they don't have much of a story to tell but they are still likable, one of my favorite characters is the battleship Kongou because shes funny always try's to see the better side of the situation, specking of her she has 4 sisters and has a thing for the admiral, fubuki is trying to be two things at once, one of them is the person that wins people over with herd work and guts and the other is the chosen one who the admiral wants to marry.

i'm not going to do all the characters because theirs so many but a lot of then are point less they have one or two gimmicks.

next is animation, it does the job, the 3D characters on 2D back grounds you do notice it but it saves money and no bought that they don't have a big budget and the water looks like s**t.

the voice acting is OK but could be better at the time of writing there is no dub and i don't think there will be.

this show's the name "Kantai collection" what the f**k is that i can think of one right now "fleet girls" or "ship girls" or something other than "kantai collection".some of girls/ships are kind of lesbian's and there sisters as well what the f**k.

well if you liked strike witches you'll like this cause its just strike witches on ships.

go watch this you wont regret it, it left me in the void and wanting more and the second season isn't out till 2016 there will also be a movie coming out next year as well.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Bizarre character premise that's reminiscent of "Strike Witches" but further into left field.
dameon_green5 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The "Unknown Enemy attacking Earth" is a tried and true trope, but scantily clad, pale and uncommunicative 14 year old girls seems an odd choice to represent the enemy, but even stranger is what defends humanity. 14 year old girls skating through the water with miniature Battleship turrets / parts hanging off their legs and backs. That is unless the girls are "Carriers" and then they have part of the Aircraft Carrier's deck hanging from their waists (and arms once they "equip").

The enemy "Abyssal" monsters were interesting, some appearing to be giant mutant demonic whales, others warped crabs or other creatures.

Combats seemed really odd as the girls tiny weapons fired disproportionately large shells and arrows fired from the "Carrier Group" turned into squadrons of what appeared to be "Zero's". Additionally the combats were without any real substance, there was no real danger. When the fleet groups were outnumbered massively and under fire they would escape nearly unscathed, but when convenient for the story a lone enemy fighter will "sink" one of the girls with a single shot.

Overall in a very broad brush way the story unfolds along the lines of "Strike Witches", a new addition to the group without combat experience, who's also supposed to be exceptionally powerful, performs poorly at first but makes the decision to work hard and train to become the best all the while being insanely cheerful. Add the typical stumbles, comic relief in the form of horrible performance while training, pair of extra supportive friends, an idol to look up to, random naval terms inserted into every conversation and you have a very silly trope filled series.

If you're a fan of the "Magical Girls" genre (yes they aren't magical but in every other way it fits) this will likely be enjoyable, but if not I'd suggest a hard pass.

Pros:
  • Interesting monsters.
  • Unique costumes for some of the ship classes.
  • None of the random Ecchi moments of "Strike Witches".
  • Above average and consistent animation.
  • Flashbacks have a very noir feel, cleanly delineating it.
  • English Dubbing.


Cons:
  • Exceptionally predictable.
  • Silly to a fault.
  • Depends to heavily on "Deus Ex Machina" moments.
  • Unexplained and random scantily clad "Bunny Girl"' (Ship groups typically have matching outfits / uniforms).
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed