"Tales of the Unexpected" Back for Christmas (TV Episode 1980) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Good tale of the unexpected.
poolandrews15 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Tales of the Unexpected: Back for Christmas starts during a farewell party given by James (Richard Johnson) & Hermione Carpenter (Sian Phillips) for their friends mere hours before James & Hermione fly off to America where botanist James has a new job. However the womanising James has plans that don't include Hermione & decides to kill her, after the deed is done he cuts the body up & buries it. It's a perfect plan that surely can't go wrong, can it?

Episode 14 from season 2 this Tales of the Unexpected story originally aired here in the UK during May 1980, the second of five Tales of the Unexpected episodes to be directed by Giles Foster I thought this was a great 25 minute thriller with a twist. The story by John Collier had already been adapted for the anthology TV series Alfred Hitchcock Presents (1956) before it was dramatised by Denis Cannan for this show, this has everything a good Tales of the Unexpected episode should have including a nice build up, decent character's & most importantly an intriguing story with a surprising twist at the end. I liked the ironic ending especially as before he killed her James wife started in motion events which would uncover his crime which just felt right in a what goes around comes around sort of way. At only 25 minutes in length it moves along at a nice pace & is a neat way to pass the time.

During his filmed introduction Dahl doesn't actually mention the story & only that the guy who came up with the story also wrote a book about a chimpanzee who fell in love with & married a teacher! Not that it has any relevance to the story at hand but there you go. Unusually for this show there's a bit of blood on show here as James cuts his wife's body up although there is no graphic gore. This one hasn't dated too badly but just look at those seats on the air-plane, they look like they are covered in hideous 70's shag-pile patterned carpet! The acting is good & I always like watching Richard Johnson (this was his first out of three appearances on Tales of the Unexpected) & whenever I see him I can't help but think about his roles in the Italian gore films Zombie Flesh Eaters (1979), The Great Alligator (1979) & Island of Mutations (1979) all of which he made in '79 & stand out like a sore thumb against the rest of his career which spans over 60 years.

Back for Christmas is a great Tales of the Unexpected episode from a very strong season 2, I liked it, fans of the show should like it & anyone looking for a crime thriller with a twist should like it.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"Here then is another equally outrageous Collier story."
classicsoncall7 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I had previously seen this story adapted slightly differently for an 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents' episode. Both were based on a short story by John Collier, who host Roald Dahl seemed to have a great admiration for in his opening remarks. The wife here, portrayed by Siân Phillips, was a bit more irritating than Isobel Elsom in the Hitchcock story, while husband James (Richard Johnson) was somewhat of a womanizer compared to his counterpart in the earlier version. Nevertheless, the basic plot carries through, with James deciding to do away with his wife before embarking on a planned trip to America for a new job. I have to say, this story was somewhat gory in the telling, with James preparing his wife for burial in his greenhouse by cutting up her body into parts and placing then into plastic garbage bags. It wasn't as messy as I imagine the real thing would be, but there's enough blood to get the idea across. The grave he dug for her didn't seem all that accommodating, but then again, he was going about it piecemeal. I can't really say I prefer one version over the other regarding this episode, as the twist revealed at the end in both brings the distant husband back to a grim reality that he hadn't put together the perfect crime. 'Back for Christmas' would not be one to look forward to.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Classic from the Series.
Sleepin_Dragon12 February 2016
Warning: Spoilers
James and Hermione are seemingly a very happily married couple, wealthy, successful and with a wide circle of friends. Hermione is set to jet off to the States to start a new career, as is James. Underneath the surface though, all is not as it seems, after a leaving Party it becomes clear that James is an adulterer, flirting outrageously with the beautiful Samantha. When everyone has gone the couple argue, and James kills her...but has a body to deal with..

I love Sian Phillips, a tremendous actress, she's in fine form with her incredible red bob, great performance from her. Richard Johnson is fantastic to as her cheating husband James, impressive too from Avril Elgar and Cyril Luckham.

An out and out classic, this is one of the best Tales, it's a true return to form, hugely dramatic in a wonderfully eighties way, it's big and loud. A great story, tension, suspense, uncertainty, wonderfully, acted and a great twist, what more could you want from this show.

9/10
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Orchids can be lethal
mbayley-7683128 January 2024
What is not to love about this marvellous episode? Sian Phillips, Richard Johnson and the voluptuous, gorgeous Lynne Ross, who always makes me think of Gabrielle Drake. A twisted, turning tale of lust, deceit and cunning with added 80s ambiance such as shoulder pads, big hair, an MGB with rubber bumpers and a gorgeous mustard yellow Rover SD1. Marvellous!

A venal corrupt surgeon lusts after his lusty nurse (Ross) and bumps off his elegant yet spiky wife (Phillips) in the most brutal yet surgical way.

Unfortunately for him, retribution is just around the corner in a most unexpected way.

Wonderful.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Dig for victory
andrewroake23 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
You can tell Dahl didn't write this one, considering the wife character is actually sympathetic.

Its strange to me that the early mention of orchids, the giving them away, and Sian Phillips characters distain for them play no actual part in the story. Considering their prominence in the early bit you'd think it would. I was convinced Sian Phillips would smash her husband over the head with a potted orchid, or he'd bury bits of her dismembered corpse in the potted plants and use her decomposing corpse as fertiliser, so they'd rot away naturally in the soil and never be found as evidence. Oh well.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed