"Gunsmoke" The Boots (TV Episode 1959) Poster

(TV Series)

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A gunslinger turns to drinking when he loses his nerve
kfo949421 August 2013
This story starts out ten years ago as Zeno Smith, a noted gunfighter, is having a drink at the bar. Enter a young gunslinger, Hank Fergus, that wants to make a name for himself by taking on Zeno. But during the lead up to the gunfight, Zeno loses his nerve and now he is branded not as a gunfighter but a coward. Flash ahead in time and now Zeno lives his life as a drunk with an orphaned kid, Tommy, and having a small job thanks to Mr Jonas at the General Store.

After ten years, Hank Fergus returns to Dodge and finds Zeno. Since Fergus is out of money he tells Zeno to bring him the cash box from the General Store or he will tell Tommy about his past. The cowardly Zeno sees no way out.

John Larch, that usually plays the tough guy, does surprisingly well as the drunk Zeno Smith that has lost his nerve and his way of living. Matt appears rather unfeeling to the 12 year old boy, Tommy, when he tells him (in so many words), 'life is full of hard knock- your a man now'. For some reason that seemed cold words from the Marshal to the young boy. Otherwise this was a good watch that tried mightily to pull at heartstrings.
7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Carpal Tunnel?
darbski29 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Yup, I wonder if it was C.T.S. (Carpal Tunnel Syndrome) that made Ol Zeno quit the game? I also wonder why Tommy didn't have a little job in Jonas' store? A lot of kids would have jobs if they could get them. I will try to answer one question, however. Just because a man is shot, doesn't mean he's gonna drop dead right there. He can hold on for a long time if the bullet just nicks an artery or vein. Also, if a man is determined, he can take his time and get a good aim before he fires; thereby killing his nemesis.

One little point. There have been several men who have worn the same gunbelt in several Gunsmoke episodes. I don't know why, but it's become something I look for. also, I have a personal issue with the exclusive use of the Colt S.A.A.. They weren't the only pistols that were used, and Zeno was supposed to have quit the game BEFORE the "Peacemaker" was available. Anyway, it seems to add up that way. Good episode, though.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Gunfighter Loses his Nerve
dougdoepke19 November 2012
Gunfighter Zeno (Larch) suddenly loses his nerve in a showdown with a leering upstart Fergus (Pierce) and turns to the whiskey bottle for comfort. Trouble is that, in the meantime, he's got a 12-year old boy Tommy (Eyer) to take care of. Mostly Zeno's a hopeless wreck so Tommy doesn't have much chance of getting the boots he wants so badly, that is, until Zeno falls in with Fergus to rob a Dodge City store.

Larch is always a strong screen presence (looking a little like Arness) so watching him go from tough guy gunfighter to alcoholic weakling is quite a transition. Little Eyer specialized in tear-jerking parts and is not out of place here. The story itself is nothing special, but done in the usual effective Gunsmoke style.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Anticlimax
silverpilgrim-568965 August 2021
Another reviewer pointed out that the Meston scripts usually provide unsatisfying endings. This is true, and this episode was no exception.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Drunken Bum & Whiny Kid
Johnny_West29 March 2020
John Larch was a World War II veteran who did not start acting until the age of 38. Here he plays a drunken bum who used to be a gun-fighter until Fergus called him out as a coward. Fergus is played by Wynn Pearce, whose acting credits spanned from 1957 to 1967. He is a pretty obnoxious character, and after some years, he comes back to Dodge without any money. Apparently his career as a gunfighter was not much of a success. Fergus intimidates Larch, and he wants to force Larch to rob the General Store where Larch is working.

Larch is the de-facto caretaker of a young orphan named Tommy, played by the incredibly annoying Richard Eyer. The two of them live in a shack. The orphan kid helps Larch get to work every day, and Larch supports the orphan. Richard Eyer always seemed to be whiny in every role I have seen him. Even when I was a kid, I always wanted to see someone slap his face. In this episode, my wish finally came true. Larch slaps the kid when he is nagging him about drinking too much. That was the highlight of the episode, along with a couple of minutes of Doc Adams, Chester, and Marshal Dillon talking about the day's events.

If Larch had told Marshal Dillon that Fergus wanted him to rob the General Store, Dillon would have handled Fergus, and there could have been a happy ending on Gunsmoke. But when John Meston was writing a story, you can bet nobody will be happy at the end.
14 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Quiet Gunfight
jamdifo15 December 2013
Warning: Spoilers
The episode started promisingly, where Hank Fergus (Wynn Pearce) calls on Zeno (John Larch) because he wants to make a name for himself as a gunman. Nice tense scene, Zeno freezes and Hank looks like a force to reckon with. We find out this happened before Dillon and Kitty were in Dodge at the Longbranch. Unfortunately, this is the best part of the episode.

12 years later, Zeno has become a drunk watching (barely) a 12 yr old orphan boy Tommy (Richard Eyer, still alive today). The rest of the episode is pretty much routine. Hank comes back to town, and I was looking forward to a duel between him and Dillon, but it never happened. I guess Hank felt he made enough of a name for himself because he backs down from Dillon. Why he would miss the chance of becoming a humongous name by killing Dillon I feel is a writer's blunder.

In the end, Zeno and Hank end up killing one another, which amazingly nobody heard the 2 or so gunshots in Dodge. Hank was fast and accurate, so how did a slow middle age drunk Zeno almost outdraw Hank? That's never explained and the ending I didn't care for. Those boots more like kicked me in the behind after watching this episode.
6 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Hank Fergus Is A Bully
StrictlyConfidential28 November 2020
(*Matt Dillon quote*) - "When a gunman loses his nerve he loses everything."

With an unusual first name like Zeno one would hardly expect his last name to be Smith.

10 years ago Zeno Smith was an ace gunfighter then he lost his nerve and became a hopeless drunk.

The character of Tommy is never really explained so it made me wonder what his connection was with Zeno Smith.
1 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed