Remedial Reading Comprehension (1970) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
This Is A Film About You
ackstasis21 February 2009
My first encounter with Owen Land was an unmitigated disaster. How anybody could find enjoyment or enlightenment in 'Film in Which There Appear Edge Lettering, Sprocket Holes, Dirt Particles, Etc. (1966)' is a mystery I'll ponder for years to come, but I'm a forgiving man. I decided to give Land (also known as George Landow) a second opportunity to prove himself, and the good news is that 'Remedial Reading Comprehension (1970)' is an improvement on his last effort. This five-minute experimental film (and few filmmakers fit the "experimental" label so snugly) has the upper-hand on the basis that something actually happens in it. However, I still didn't get it, and I didn't particularly like it, either. Owen Land appears to be operating on some outlandish wavelength that I'm incapable on receiving. But then again, this film is supposed to be about Me, not it's Maker, so I don't know…

'Remedial Reading Comprehension' opens with a girl apparently dreaming about university lectures (given that I'll be returning to uni in a week, I can certainly sympathise). One student in the theatre is asleep, but the others chat enthusiastically as they take their seats. Then the film cuts to the silhouette of what appears to be a running women, though the image of a running man is superimposed over the silhouette (and he has long hair, so maybe he is the silhouette, as well). Following this train of thought, we then learn of the benefits of white rice over brown rice. Certainly the most interesting element of the film is a reading comprehension lesson, in which phrases from a page are ever-so-briefly illuminated, but, on the whole, much too fast for us to recognise the words that we are seeing. Perhaps a little bit intriguing, but I'm not going to rack my brain to try and make sense of it all.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Artificiality of Film
Tornado_Sam11 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I don't entirely understand the concept of "Remedial Reading Comprehension" or how exactly Owen Land uses these pieces of found footage to make his point, but for those who didn't enjoy his "Film in Which There Appear Edge Lettering, Sprocket Holes, Dirt Particles, Etc." this one is at least more to look at. Considered one of the most important films in the structuralist movement, Land's five-minute short uses a combination of four different pieces of footage: what appears to be a color clip from a sound documentary showing people in a movie theater, a rice commercial, a shot of some text from a manual speed-read, and a twice-appearing scene of himself running while superimposed over a woman's silhouette. Combined together, it has a scrap-book feel with each clip bearing no particular relevance to anything, leaving most audiences looking for some sort of connection to ponder the point.

I thought it was interesting, but sadly in very poor quality. It was hard to really appreciate through the rather blurry print and sad that a better copy is not available. As it is, to understand this one I'll have to admit I had to look at Wikipedia to get an inkling of what Land was trying to accomplish. "Remedial Reading Comprehension", according to scholar Fred Camper, is all about showing the artificiality of film and revealing the illusions of the cinema for what they are. In showing a scene taken from the perspective of a movie screen in a movie theater, we are seeing how film is mere entertainment, a show, an unreal illusion only made real in the heads of the viewers. An interesting compilation and I could see how Land might use these pieces of archive footage to show an idea, but I don't have the mind of the filmmaker and can't fully understand how this moving scrapbook fully illustrates Land's point.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed