"American Experience" John Brown's Holy War (TV Episode 2000) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Very thorough.
planktonrules2 April 2012
I've seen a few other documentaries about John Brown as well as his raid on Harper's Ferry. Of all of them, this seems to be the best and most thorough of them. As usual, "The American Experience" does a fine job--with excellent narration (from Joe Morton), additional voice actors, recreations and photos/pictures. It tells of the entire life of Brown and chronicles his evolution from an ordinary guy to a rabid abolitionist--one who was willing to kill or even foment revolution to end this evil institution. In other words, he isn't just some crazy guy but a guy who became, over time, obsessed and emboldened.

Overall this is a very good documentary. Interestingly, it seemed to be more 'pro-Brown' than many films I've seen. In other words, what he did was described in more positive ways--such as using the phrase 'holy war' to describe his actions and saying that his raid led directly to the Civil War (which I disagree with, but who am I to day). Some other films portray him more as a loony or zealot and that is all.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
life of a violent abolitionist zealot
worleythom1 November 2014
Warning: Spoilers
The film is an interesting portrayal of the life, attitudes, and effects of a man who hoped by violence to overthrow slave-lords' power.

WE ARE TOLD that:

"Slavery can only be destroyed by bloodshed." -- Fredrick Douglass

"The crimes of this guilty land will never be purged away except with blood." -- John Brown

Brown's attack on the arsenal at Harper's Ferry, Virginia, and his murders of pro-slavery fighters in Kansas, fueled paranoia among white Southerners, who armed and formed militias and vigilante groups.

Brown's martyrdom achieved his aim of pushing the country toward civil war in the interest of ending slavery.

Brown's attitude was formed partly from his witnessing a brutal beating of a black boy, when Brown was age 12.

If Brown had been killed by a federal soldier, as he nearly was, instead of captured and executed, he would be largely unknown.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Extremism in Pursuit of Abolition.
rmax3048234 July 2015
Brown was born in the early years of the 19th century in Connecticut, a land of flinty Calivinists. He and his family moved to Pennsylvania and then to the Adirondacks where making a living was extraordinarily difficult due to climate and terrain. He eventually fathered more than a dozen children, some of whom died in childhood, and he treated them with the same severity with which he treated himself. One of his sons kept a notebook account of the number of lashes for each sin -- lying, being lazy at work, impudence, and so forth. In the 1840s, at the time of the Great Awakening, Brown underwent some sort of epiphany in the woods and came to embrace abolition of slavery as his greatest aim in life.

Some of his sons had moved to a small town in Kansas, near Lawrence, and reported to Brown on the activities of the "Border Ruffians" -- pro-slavery southerners who had pushed across the border and abused the local prohibitionists, including the murder of a newspaper editor. Brown joined his sons and organized a bloody raid on the households of pro-slavery families, hauling the men outside and then hacking them to death and shooting them. The Border Ruffians fought back and it cost Brown the lives of two sons. This was the period when the territory was known as "bleeding Kansas." Brown became a hero to the North. He was the hero of plays like "Ossowatomi Brown" in New York. And by this time he was ready to carry the war against slavery to the South. He traveled for two years, visiting wealthy abolitionists and trying to collect enough guns and money to begin the battle, which he saw as a great uprising of slaves led by himself. He may have been wanted for murder in Kansas, but in Massachusetts he was a guest in the house of Ralph Waldo Emerson and had lunch with Thoreau. He had features that looked as if rough-hewn from the trunk of an oak tree. He'd memorized every word of the Bible. At the dinners served by his genteel hosts he would shock them by producing a pistol from one boot and an evil-looking knife from the other. The guy was en fuego. God preserve us from religious zealots.

By the summer of 1859, just before the Civil War, Brown had made his plans to attack the federal arsenal at Harper's Ferry, a tiny Appalachian town located at the confluence of two rivers and surrounded by very tall hills -- impossible to defend. He had recruited only twenty-one men: fugitive slaves, freemen, college students, and three of his own sons. The group took the lightly guarded arsenal. But there was no slave revolt. Instead, townspeople hid in the hills and took pot shots at Brown's men, and soon the Virginia militia arrived and surrounded the building. Brown's numbers were whittle down to five. One of his dying sons lay in agony on the floor, begging Brown to put him out of his misery, but Brown's advice was to "be a man." The arrival of federal troops under Robert E. Lee put an end to the occupation and Brown was captured, wounded but alive.

Following his conviction, he stood up and gave a perceptive and moving speech. A few months later, he went wilfully to the gallows. John Wilkes Booth watched the hanging, filled with hatred. Abraham Lincoln's response was prudent. The nation could not do anything but condemn John Brown even though many Americans agreed with him. Prominent southern newspapers agreed with him too, at least on one point: There will be blood. Less than a year and a half later, the first shot of the Civil War was fired at Fort Sumter in South Carolina. That John Brown remains a controversial figure is, at least to some extent, probably reflected in these reviews.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed