User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Can A Minister Forgive His Own Sin?
boblipton12 March 2020
Augustus Phillips is a church minister with a sick son. He's told he needs a specialist's care and his local doctor says he thinks he can get the Great Man to do it for only $500. Phillips has only $76 in the bank, so he applies to community pillar Robert Brower to lend him the money. Brower refuses him. Phillips is in despair when he receives a charitable donation of $500 for the church, made out to his own name. Will he fall into temptation? And if he fall, can he earn forgiveness?

It's a simply plotted story, directed for speed and earnestness by Charles Brabin, and pretty restrained on its own terms for Edison, where they were shifting from a stagier style of pantomime that obviated the need for many titles, to the subtler style creeping through cinema. Keep a look out for the ending shot, dramatically side-lit. Brabin liked those, and it's quite lovely.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The suffering he endures is splendidly portrayed
deickemeyer31 July 2017
Here is a film for any audience, especially it is suitable for a church affair, for of a church it is; yet everything in it. will appeal to those who never enter a religious edifice. The scenario is written by the Rev. Sydney Booth. Charles J. Brabin produced it. Augustus Phillips has the role of the minister who, to save the life of his child, uses money given him for church work. The suffering he endures as the result of the workings of his conscience is splendidly portrayed. There are many moments of deep dramatic suspense, as, for instance, when the minister and his wife (Mary Fuller) sit in the reception-room of the hospital waiting the result of the operation; or when the minister, at the close of his services, asks the congregation to remain, and then confesses what he has done. There is a strong appeal to the feelings when a pillar of the church (Robert Brower) takes the floor as the minister retires and tells the assemblage that the fault is his, as he refused to loan the minister the money. On the screen the people in the congregation are making free use of their handkerchiefs. A holiday audience on Broadway at the same time was doing an unusual amount of coughing and clearing of throats. The operation in the hospital is shown with remarkable fidelity. This is a rare picture. - The Moving Picture World, March 8, 1913
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed