This is not a claim for purity, for faithful use of the source material or anything like that. My point here is a bit different... Besides the fact that the writers had several books, games and other materials, they simply spent a whole season with new arch and plots... that would be fine by me if their writing was better than the source, or at least equal in quality... but this is not the case.... even worst: the original material has solid character development and the history archs all have a proper closure.... those new arch and plots those writers gave us really doesn't seems to have pra possible proper closure, and clearly were implemented by the price of loose character coherence...
So I repeat: it is not a question of respect or about fidelity in relation to the source material, but about how those changes made by the writers are poor when compared to the source....
I gave 3 stars only because Cavil is clearly.
Review of Family
