I feel like most of the negative reviewers on here haven't even watched the show, or at least a majority of the available episodes. Lazy ratings are lazy, and comparing this show to 'Harvey Birdman' is definitely the lazy way to go.
In my opinion, 'Birdgirl' absolutely checks the boxes to make it a refreshing change on AS. The stories are entertaining, easy to understand, and light hearted. Pile on a really great voice cast and smart writing, and even the reruns hold up for me after multiple viewings. Personally, I'm glad that 'Birdgirl' keeps its own identity. There are too many other cookie cutter shows out there already, and trying to make this one just a 1:1 gender swap would have been a mistake.
In my opinion, 'Birdgirl' absolutely checks the boxes to make it a refreshing change on AS. The stories are entertaining, easy to understand, and light hearted. Pile on a really great voice cast and smart writing, and even the reruns hold up for me after multiple viewings. Personally, I'm glad that 'Birdgirl' keeps its own identity. There are too many other cookie cutter shows out there already, and trying to make this one just a 1:1 gender swap would have been a mistake.