This episode is SO good!
I've not rated the last few episodes highly at all, I've felt like since Crisis the writing has been all over the place, but THIS episode was so good.
I was initially sad they were not bringing back Peter Gadiot to play Mxyzptlk because he was fantastic, but the characters redemption storyline in this episode makes sense for his character to be played by someone else and appear in a different form (still charming, but lighter). Not only that, but Thomas Lennon's take on Mxyzptlk is simply excellent. Supergirl really got it on point by casting him. As he guides Kara through key moments of the SG timeline in an attempt to fix her relationship with Lena, despite other characters caution, and at times even Karas own hesitance, his portrayal never once leaves you questioning his motives. His humorous and entertaining dialogue throughout helps keep light at times what are dark and intimate moments of Kara's life.
I was absolutely thrilled at the return of Sam, she is one of my favourite characters and I wish they could have kept Odette on the show for longer (though Sam/Reigns character Arc had served its purpose so realistically I understand this wasn't possible). Seeing her as both Sam and Reign was great. Returning as well was Mon-El and Winn, and whilst I did appreciate their cameos I'm glad they didn't give Winn too much screen time because he's had far too much of it lately.
My only criticism is one that is relevant to the whole of season five, and that is a lack of screen time and credible story lines with substance for Nia, Kelly and Alex. This is felt significantly for Alex in this episode given it is the 100th episode. Quite frankly these characters deserve better, but that is a more general statement for the show overall and something I hope Supergirl will fix, and quickly.
Finally, the performances of Melissa and Katie, as per usual, cannot be overstated enough. It is widely acknowledged that both are fantastic in their roles, and when combined are electrifying, but this episode really showcases both of their abilities. The chemistry between them (and I'm not talking about the commonly used ship 'supercorp'), is an absolute gift and at times I'm not sure the show even knows what to do with it. In the 100th, we see an unreal range of heartbreaking and exciting scenarios of Kara attempting to repair her friendship with Lena that only these two could honestly pull off.
I've not rated the last few episodes highly at all, I've felt like since Crisis the writing has been all over the place, but THIS episode was so good.
I was initially sad they were not bringing back Peter Gadiot to play Mxyzptlk because he was fantastic, but the characters redemption storyline in this episode makes sense for his character to be played by someone else and appear in a different form (still charming, but lighter). Not only that, but Thomas Lennon's take on Mxyzptlk is simply excellent. Supergirl really got it on point by casting him. As he guides Kara through key moments of the SG timeline in an attempt to fix her relationship with Lena, despite other characters caution, and at times even Karas own hesitance, his portrayal never once leaves you questioning his motives. His humorous and entertaining dialogue throughout helps keep light at times what are dark and intimate moments of Kara's life.
I was absolutely thrilled at the return of Sam, she is one of my favourite characters and I wish they could have kept Odette on the show for longer (though Sam/Reigns character Arc had served its purpose so realistically I understand this wasn't possible). Seeing her as both Sam and Reign was great. Returning as well was Mon-El and Winn, and whilst I did appreciate their cameos I'm glad they didn't give Winn too much screen time because he's had far too much of it lately.
My only criticism is one that is relevant to the whole of season five, and that is a lack of screen time and credible story lines with substance for Nia, Kelly and Alex. This is felt significantly for Alex in this episode given it is the 100th episode. Quite frankly these characters deserve better, but that is a more general statement for the show overall and something I hope Supergirl will fix, and quickly.
Finally, the performances of Melissa and Katie, as per usual, cannot be overstated enough. It is widely acknowledged that both are fantastic in their roles, and when combined are electrifying, but this episode really showcases both of their abilities. The chemistry between them (and I'm not talking about the commonly used ship 'supercorp'), is an absolute gift and at times I'm not sure the show even knows what to do with it. In the 100th, we see an unreal range of heartbreaking and exciting scenarios of Kara attempting to repair her friendship with Lena that only these two could honestly pull off.