Review of Chato's Land

Chato's Land (1972)
3/10
No Heroes Here
22 May 2002
This Western is beautifully and graphically filmed, and Michael Winner brings his trademark intensity to the project, but his "Lawman" (also 1971) with Burt Lancaster is a much better film.

The problem with this film is that none of the characters have any redeeming qualities, not even Bronson's "Chato." Since this film was made in 1970-71, one may expect the white guys to personify evil and the Indians to personify goodness, but here, the cruelty on both sides is relentless and obsessive. As the movie unfolded, I began rooting against "Chato."

Lancaster's "Lawman" is likewise a flawed character, but in that movie the character development is more thorough, and one can appreciate the very complicated character that Lancaster's "Lawman" is. In this film, Bronson's "Chato" is a savage in a savage land.

This film is a bleak assessment. Perhaps there are ties to Viet Nam that I would see if I viewed it a second time. I can't do that.
7 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed