As a drama, this is absorbing and often powerful; an example of good storytelling. But as a musical it doesn't fare that well, because it's plagued by some lame, inane songs. Maybe the songs should have been omitted and the story would have worked better if it had been approached as a straightforward drama. But despite my complaints, I have to recommend the film because Peter O'Toole's superlative performance is truly a sight to see. He takes a rather stereotypical role (the clumsy intellectual), and makes it moving and intense. Perhaps he should have won the Oscar that year. (**1/2)
Review of Goodbye, Mr. Chips
