Review of Carnegie Hall

Carnegie Hall (1947)
6/10
good music, shame about the 'plot'
15 January 2001
Although the music segments are second to none (Rubenstein, Heifetz, Pinza, Lily Pons, Rise Stevens, and representing the more 'modern' era Harry James and the great Vaughn Monroe) the story, what little there is, is really dreadful. Nora is a selfish and pathetic person in whom we have little or no interest, her piano-playing son has the personality of a goldfish, and the film is the clunkier for them both. Tip - if you see this on video fast-forward to the musical bits. They are well worth it and amazingly, all still look great after 53 years!
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed