"The Orville" The Road Not Taken (TV Episode 2019) Poster

(TV Series)

(2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
68 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Nice Time Travel episode.
Elewis119526 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
It wouldn't be STO (Star Trek Orville) without a time travel episode and they pulled it off. Some nice twists, some unexpected moments and a funny bit here and there. Yaphit cameo was great.

It would have been better, I think, to leave it as a cliffhanger, rather than an ending, but with season 3 still up in the air, I don't blame Seth for writing an ending not leaving us with a cliffhanger.

A fun episode, and a fun season. Looking forward to season 3, whether Fox or Netflix.
37 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good plot. WTH IMDb?! Spoiler picture to illustrate the episode?!
Ashitaka13727 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Good plot, but too much deus ex machinas; good to see Alara. The Kaylons are hypocrites, otherwise they wouldn't still be humanoids; i mean they can freakin fly! Or maybe(most definitely) they need a shrink. And WTH IMDb?! You say no spoilers, but you put a picture of Alara to illustrate the episode!!!
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
As good as a time travel story can be
Canati26 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I hate time travel and alternate universe storylines no matter what show/franchise they're part of. They just all ignore the butterfly effect, and go with the cliche of having the same people somehow meet up despite so much being different. So, when this episode mostly avoided that, it had my attention immediately. In fact, it almost seems as the writers were intent on avoiding that exact logical fallacy, putting the team together in a more logical fashion. Mostly. One cameo in particular was rather out of place, but insignificant and frankly welcome regardless.

The episode doesn't avoid all typical time travel cliches, though. For one, this time travel method seems to be one of those that come with an in explicable matter transporter as well, allowing an object to appear in a different part of the galaxy than it travels from. That would be the only way to time travel without a space ship as no location anywhere is static (if you went back in time but not space 1 second, you would be in open space, as Earth moves), but acknowledging that would have been appreciated. Heisenberg compensator, anyone?

I'm also curious as to when exactly time travel Grayson was informed about the Kaylon attack in enough detail that she knew the impact of Finn's relationship and could piece it together 7 years later. That had to be quite the briefing.

The music seemed off at times, though not as much so as Kaylon shooting accuracy. Stormtroopers 2.0 right there.

These logical fallacies (and others I'll leave unmentioned) are however nothing compared to most time travel stories, and overall, I approve. The overall story is good, and it makes sense within the Orville universe. The episode is well-produced, has decent acting, and some humor, without that overshadowing anything.

What I like best however, is the end. If this turns out to be the last episode of Orville ever, it concludes the series in a way that loops the story back on itself. After seeing the final scene, you could start over again with the pilot, and rewatch the series as if it picked up 5 years later - and continue doing that again and again.
31 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What can I say but WOW!!!
chemist7226 April 2019
Fantastic ending to a really great Season 2. Another must see episode.

Had me on the edge of my seat the entire time. Thought I'd never say this , but thank goodness for the commercial breaks. Gave my heart a couple of minutes to recover between scenes. LOL

If FOX cancels this series, I'm going to be really pissed. Lots of things to build on for Season 3, plus the chance to begin new threads and adventures.

My favorite show on TV by far.

Go Seth!
68 out of 78 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Kaylon are almost as bad a shot as Stormtroopers
amandahenderson-932953 March 2020
Great episode, though. Can't wait for next season.
17 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Masterpiece Finale....
maizdinallah26 April 2019
What a formidable episode!!!!!

It's been said that we are the lost generation, for our ancestors explored the Earth, and our descendants will explore the depths of space. But this series made me feel that I am no longer lost. I am an explorer.

The Orville has proven throughout the two seasons an excellent quality content with rational scientific explanations, breathtaking graphics, fabulous story telling, and amazing characters. It deserves to be on TV for many years to come.

I hope this episode is a season finale and not a series finale.

Bravo! 10/10
54 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
They topped "Identity". Amazing.
deepgloat26 April 2019
I did not think it was possible to top the previous high point of the series, the two-parter "Identity". I was delighted to be proven so unambiguously wrong. "The Road Not Taken" was an epic journey and tour de force for "The Orville". If this turns out to be the series finale (and IT HAD BETTER NOT BE), Seth MacFarlane and his talented production team left nothing on the table. Nothing short of brilliant.
40 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
To all the haters...
eyefonefoures8 May 2019
...take it easy the guy never claimed the premise of the series to be original! As a matter of fact the similarities you see are deliberate in most cases.

I'm a die hard fan of The Orville, it's close to what I think Star Trek series should remain.

And down to my comment on THIS episode; my only complaint is that it was over too soon and too abruptly.
26 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect!
AvidWatcher10126 April 2019
Perfect ending to a perfect season. I admit I am a sucker for time travel and alternate timeline tales, but this was outstanding.
39 out of 52 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Best episode of season!
safeJ26 April 2019
This episode appears to "borrow" as much from Star Wars as it does from the Star Trek universe, mainly in the space chase scenes and the great music accompanying these and other parts of the episode. Really quite similar to John Williams' scores for a number of action and sci-fi movies, including the Star Wars sagas. The CGI was 100% better than used in previous episodes this season. The bridge(s) didn't look like cartoons for a change!

I really expected there to be a cliffhanger at the end of this episode, but agree because of the renewal of series unable to foresee, it was felt best to not leave the series hanging in midair. Good blend of humor and other emotions present here. Lot of technical terms used, no doubt mixing pseudoscience with current known scientific principles. Good job Seth, writers and rest of crew.
28 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A beautiful tapestry to end the season.
MrGoog26 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
******SPOILER ALERT******

I shall be telling this with a sigh / Somewhere ages and ages hence: / Two roads diverged in a wood, and I - / I took the one less traveled by, / And that has made all the difference. (from "The Road Not Taken" by Robert Frost)

When you come to a fork in the road, use a spoon. (MrGoog)

The title above would be significant if you recall a special episode of Star Trek - The Next Generation: "Tapestry" (6th Season). In it, Q showed Picard how his life would have been drastically altered by avoiding a fight when he was a young man - he never would have become a Captain, but, instead, would have wasted his career as a low-rank officer with no ambition. Here, David A. Goodman's script shows how a seemingly insignificant alteration of history - Kelly declining a second date with Ed - drastically alters the history of the Planetary Union.

In 2420, we see two men, wearing heavy winter gear, walking through the snowy wilderness of Sarin 4, approaching a Union listening post. At the abandoned post, they find a large item and carry it back to their Union shuttle as the Kaylon pursue. The men are Gordon and Ed.

Here, again, we saw a very abbreviated opening sequence, with no listing of the cast. Maybe Seth MacFarlane wanted us to suspect that the altered timeline erased everyone else. But, again, we saw the cast listing at the start of Act 1.

In this timeline, half of the galaxy has been destroyed by the Kaylon over the past 9 months. Ed and Gordon escape from the Kaylon and activate the item, which is a synthesizer. They replicate a Twinkie and split it. (Twinkies - The Official Snack Of Freedom Fighters.) But they are caught by a scavenger ship, which tractors the shuttle into the bay. However, the freighter's crew aren't scavengers; they are Kelly, John, Talla, Claire, Marcus, and Ty.

Indeed, the memory wipe that Claire performed on Kelly in the previous episode didn't work. Kelly remembers the original timeline and describes it to Ed and Gordon, who have a hard time believing it. They know only the altered timeline, in which the Orville, with a different Captain and First Officer, was hijacked by the Kaylon and used to smash through Earth's defenses. The memory wipe failed because Kelly's brain lacks a protein called beta-secretase (This is real. You can look it up.) Now John hopes to use the Aronov device to send Claire, with a memory wiper and a hypo of the protein, to 2413 to perform a successful memory wipe. Then Kelly would agree to a second date with Ed and the original history would be restored. The bottom line: one date set off a chain reaction of events that affected the galaxy; thus, just two people can make a huge difference.

Kelly, Claire, John, and Ed take the shuttle to a Resistance base to obtain a vial of the protein. They meet Yaphit and the leader of the base: Alara Kitan! (a very pleasant surprise) But the Kaylon find the base. The visitors return to the shuttle and kill a Kaylon in the shuttle. This was fortunate because now they will have Kaylon technology to use in John's plan.

The freighter's quantum drive malfunctions, so John hides the ship in the event horizon of a nearby black hole. Because light can't escape from a black hole, the Kaylon can't find the freighter. Also, the time distortion gives John time to repair the engines while the Kaylon abandon the search. (They were in the event horizon for about 25 seconds, but 2 days passed outside the black hole.) Then the freighter travels to Earth to salvage the Orville.

As John starts to access the Kaylon communication system through the dead Kaylon, the freighter arrives at Earth. The planet has no life of any type, and the continents show the scars of heavy bombardment. The crew take the shuttle, with reinforced deflectors, into the Pacific Ocean and find the Orville, 7 miles below the surface. Another lucky break: the shuttle bay's doors are open. Gordon takes the shuttle into the bay and John activates the pressurization, clearing out the water. The crew go to the Bridge, where Talla gets to open a proverbial Jar Of Pickles: the Bridge's Security doors. They find Bortus, the only survivor from the Orville's crew (the others fled in escape pods).

Bortus survived for the 9 months on minimal atmosphere and combat rations (although, as a Moclan, he could have eaten some chairs and tables). After Kelly tells Bortus about Ed, Bortus is convinced that Ed should command the Orville, although Ed lacks self-confidence; indeed, as we saw, that self-confidence had been instilled by Kelly in the original timeline. With Ed in command, Gordon at the helm, and John repairing the engines, the Orville ascends from the Pacific Ocean and returns to deep space.

John needs the temporal calculations that Isaac had performed on the Aronov device before the Kaylon War, so he uses the dead Kaylon head to access the Kaylon network and pick Isaac's brain. But the Kaylon use the link to locate the Orville. The added complication: John needs exclusive access to the quantum drive to make the time travel work, so the ship can't flee from the Spheres. As 4 Spheres approach, the enormous strain on the quantum drive destroys the Orville.

Kelly wakes up in her apartment in 2413, then vanishes (into 2420), then returns a few seconds later. (Remember: in time travel, you could spend weeks or months in another time, then return only a second after you left.) Then she sees Claire pop in the same way. Claire performs the second memory wipe and vanishes. Then Kelly wakes up just as Ed calls. He asks for a second date. Kelly replies, "I'd love it."

And the rest is history. But I hope this series isn't history after only 2 years. This is the best sci-fi series I've seen since the many pre-Discovery Star Trek series. The Orville deserves a 3rd Season - and more.
27 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Yesterdays Orville
urthpainter5 December 2020
Spectacular, effect heavy conclusion to the 2nd season of the Orville. The story involves time travel, alternate timelines, and different versions of the main characters. The timeline has been altered by events in the previous episode, and the crew, as they now are, must attempt to restore reality as it once was.

Sound familiar? It should to many star trek fans! Yesterdays Enterprise is widely known as a top 5 ST episode, and to some people? Their very favorite - and for good reason! It is a damn near perfect episode that brought a ton of new ideas to prime time television (30 years ago). Not only are the effects and story epic, but the writing, acting and performances also live up to the spectacular nature of this all time ST episode.

So does this Orville episode live up to that legacy? Simply put, No! I have zero problem with imitation. The Orville is a clear lift from ST in basic conception, so to get upset about imitation seems silly. However, despite the epic storyline and amazing effects (that really do drive this episode from beginning to end), the writing and performances do not live up. There are some truly bad one liners that really expose the bad writing, but mostly - it's just very average lines delivered with baseline performances by the stars of this show. In other works - quite a bit of exposition to explain things and keep the episode moving, but zero depth. Its the kind of episode that is pretty good once, but does not ask to be re-watched via depth of dialog/performance. I've seen Yesterdays Enterprise at least 10 times, and enjoyed each viewing.

I really was impressed with the special effects though. All of the starship stuff is really fun to watch, and this episode is an audio visual treat. Considering this is the end of the 2nd season - I'm super satisfied how good this show has been, and think it can build into an excellent 3rd season. Hope so!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
They can handle black hole event horizon, but not 7000m of sea pressure
AlekMitch30 May 2019
It's so full of holes I can't rate it more than 5, but I rated 3 because of all these fake 10/10 reviews I'm seeing.

I have no idea who is giving these reviews but they are lame and I honestly disagree. This is just a bunch of special effects and cliche music with average acting.

It's a season finale episode, so as long as you are ripping of Star Trek formula on going back in time, why not make it a little more interesting?

Star Trek had amazing season finale episodes, From TNG to Voyager (haven't watched TOS) sorry. And we all know The Orville is like a Star Trek with more comedy.

But to make this episode so predictable and boring is disappointing. Let's be honest to ourselves and give it some criticism.
9 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Nice Conclusion
Hitchcoc16 July 2022
I thought as TV Sci Fi went this had it all. The time travel thing. The return of Isaac (sort of). And an alternate universe that can be rectified. Those Kaylons are an interesting bunch. I agree that their human forms are not very utilitarian. Lots of people have said what is wrong with it. I delighted in the closure and the opportunity to continue the story.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good luck in the 3-4-5-6-7th seasons Seth!
mdtsn26 April 2019
What an amazing season finale! Thank you all for making such a beautiful show. All cast, all crew thank you all! I think some of them should take lessons from The Orville about "How to make a space opera"!
29 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The latter half of Season 2 was almost a different show!
ctkoch-453566 April 2020
What just seemed a fun little Star Trek parody suddenly became better than anything Star Trek or Star Wars has done in eons. What changed was going from mostly 1 off episodes that really didn't have much connection with each other, to really going with a linear storyline starting with 'A Happy Refrain'. Suddenly all the rest of the episodes were connected and the show lept into unforeseen quality. Of course lost in that is some of the humor, so frankly a mix of the two is fine for the future. Regardless, the last 8 or 9 episodes of Season 2, were some of the best Sci-Fi in ages. Congrats Seth and thanks!
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Time travel part II
fcharette196926 April 2019
If the previous episode was brilliant, this one is even better. The perfect conclusion to a two-part story arc.

Found the musical score and several of the visuals to be very familiar and taken from a completely different franchise. In no way did it take away from the episode, in fact, I would say that it made it much better. I will you be the judge of that.
19 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Orville meets ...
HaraldSch27 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Star Wars ... Luke and Han would be proud of Gordon steering the ships through asteroid fields and ice canyons.

Seaquest ... Captain Bridger would surely take the Orville as his new submarine.

Battestar Galactica ... Commander Adama would try to find a new Earth for the remaining Humans, in case the Orville crew would not be able to correct the time line.

Best of more than both worlds in this episode. Looking forward to many more great seasons of this outstanding SF series.
13 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Star Trek Orville meets Star Wars
widooerlemans-727289 October 2021
Yes, this episode is Star Wars, not Star Trek. Yes, some Trekkies born without much irony in them will be mad as they will point out the obvious flaws in basic physics and the lack of explanation. Yes, there is a lot of rehashing older timeline and alternate universe episodes as the guys writing the Orville wrote a lot of the earlier episodes too. And yes, I loved every second of it. Crossing my fingers for season 3,4,5.... In Dutch there's an expression: beter goed gejat dan slecht bedacht. Look it up if you want. Clear skies!
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Solid episode, disappointing time travel writing
tony-94326 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Is it just me, or does it seem like so many sci-fi writers can never get the time travel right?

It was a fun episode all in all, but like so many other good sci-fi shows, the insane time travel stuff always gets me down. Still, was kinda cool to see them play around in a more Star Wars-ish universe for a while. I especially liked the detachable robot heads, pretty hard to compete with that.

But, the time travel stuff just killed me... I mean, obviously what we know in reality is mostly theoretical, but quantum mechanics dictates that every possible timeline can/does exist. So when you go back in time, you immediately branch off into a unique timeline from the original, and you don't just disappear. (Think "ivy", not "rope".)

Seriously, I was willing to suspend disbelief and just tell myself we're following the alternate universe where Kelly went back in time and remembers the future, but then the doc just has to go and vanish. What?! Did the protein or whatever she injected Kelly with also disappear? (Would stand to reason, after all, the device on her head disappeared.) Does that mean she can remember again? Why wouldn't she say no the second time around?

Come to think of it, that does leave one interesting possibility for season 3 -- what if Kelly actually still remembered everything from her trip to the future, but with the doc popping back into her timeline and looking so rough, she realized it must be important to set things right, which is why she says yes when Ed calls. Pretty sure that wasn't their intention, but now that I think about it, that would've been a lot cleaner than the ending they wrote.

Seriously though, folks... there isn't "the timeline". It's more like a fractal pattern. You'd think sci-fi writers would get that. Hellloooo, multiverse anyone? Wasn't that a Family Guy episode, Road to the Multiverse? Hrm.
16 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Impressive Finale!
emortland27 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
So, what are you comparing this to? Game of Thrones? I'm inclined to believe GOT has ten times the budget & staff for their finale. The last half dozen episodes of The Orville have been a definite step up, a little less of one-liners and maybe more like this is a good thing here, where can we go it? The Halston Sage cameo was great, Adrianne Palicki is just nailing this role, and season two confirmed The Orville doesn't have to be Family Guy in space, but a clever & funny Star Trek for the streaming generation.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Road Not Taken
bobcobb30126 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I give the show credit for trying something new and fresh and innovative with their season finale, but it felt strange to have the episode now. After all the interesting stories we got this season the finale felt like a waste by not touching on any of them.

Time travel and alternate dimensions has been done much better than this elsewhere too.

Hopefully The Orville gets a third season so it doesn't end on this note.
14 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Let our last meal be a Twinkie
d.rust3 May 2019
I could be mean and dock the show a couple of points for total scientific BS, like the broken up planet near the black hole: there's no way that density of rubble could occur without aggregation. And as for going past the event horizon in a black hole? Totally impossible. But the thing is, it's a TV show and it's entertainment. Damned good entertainment, at that.

It's a "What if?" story inside an entirely "what if?" series where anything can be possible, even the most improbable events could occur, like a guy who had to keep his shirt on while swimming until he was twenty could save the galaxy. And that remarkable event depended on the love between a pair of humans.

Yeah, time travel. It'll bite you on your ass. Step off the path and you might wind up having velociraptors as the top level predators in present day, while you and your monkey woman shudder in darkness. Not having a second date leads the Galaxy to fall to psychotic mechanical constructs eliminating all life.

Brownian motion may save us all, but intelligence can at least keep us on the path.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Disappointing - Sorry contains spoilers..
crag-906533 May 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Star Trek has its share of alternate timelines / universe and now the same can Be said of the Orville. You could guess what was going to happen ten minutes into the episode. Not that I am terribly against changing time stories but to have an end of season cliff hanger that is solved by a jump back in time to fix everything felt cheap and a waste of a season finale.

My problem with episodes that feature a reset button is that as soon as you realise that a reset button is coming, any character development bleeds into meaninglessness. The plot no longer adds to the overall story.

The special effects may be brilliant and there may even be a star wars vibe happening. But for me the final moments of the story become mindless nonsense as I wait for the inevitable reset, when nothing that I just watched actually happens, and I can get back to watching the story progress. But it seems this will have to wait. :)
6 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
They stopped parodying Star Trek...
poolofzenda26 April 2019
....better than Star Trek can do Star Trek.....and are doing Star wars better than Star Wars can do Star Wars.

I'm only half-way though the episode at the time of writing....it was so good I had to stop for a breath.

I'm betting on this episode just getting better....The Orville makes us rich beyond the dreams of Avarice.

Back into the fray I go!!!

* Finished....what can I say? No superlative seems adequate.
33 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed