"Luther" Episode #5.4 (TV Episode 2019) Poster

(TV Series)

(2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
37 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Luther knocking on hell's door
Lejink5 January 2019
A great New Year treat for all us Lutherans out there with another life in the day of troubled 'tec John Luther, played of course by Idris Elba. Over four tense, exciting episodes, various people and situations reappear from his troubled and sometimes chaotic past and are replayed in what seemed like a valedictory, loose-ends tied-up way, intertwined at the same time with another separate fetishistic, gruesome murderer, who Luther also has to find a way to stop.

Both story strands were equally engrossing, the former seeing Luther caught in a war between his two oldest nemeses, a conflagration which includes along the way the shocking murders of two of his confederates, one old, one new and a repeat reminder of our first ever arresting sighting of Luther all those years ago, holding an individual up by their arm from a great height in a life or death situation to prevent them falling.

The other strand sees Luther on the trail of a deviant killer, who dons a luminous mask in the act of extreme violence but whose actions ultimately lead a trail to a beyond strange husband and wife team, he a heart surgeon with abnormal tendencies and she a psychoanalyst whose counselling seems more to fan rather than douse the flames of his implacable madness.

As ever with Luther, for all the realistic acting and locations, you could never confuse the plotting or characters with real-life. Luther is a larger-than-life, intuitively brilliant cop, able to make spot-on deductions and identifications from airy nothing. In the end you have to accept this bloody and vengeful alternative reality which Luther walks, surrender to it and just roll with the hefty punches thrown.

As ever Elba bestrides the whole enterprise, taking every setback, physical and mental, squarely on the chin but always going forward following his sometimes warped but essentially well-intentioned instincts to try to right every wrong. Ruth Wilson reprises her twisted Alice character as she openly takes on crime king George Cornelius, played by Patrick Malahide, in a no-holds barred contest only two can play

Like I said, this had the look of last orders please with no easy way these characters can walk around the block again, apart from one important consideration, that our man is still in the game. Still, if this was the last time, it was certainly a tour-de-force and a fitting ending to one of the best cop shows on TV for years.
13 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A welcome return
Tweekums8 January 2019
These comments refer to the whole fifth season, not just the final episode.

This series has two intertwined plots. In one somebody is committing brutal murders; the police quickly have a suspect when a psychiatrist comes forward saying that she fears that one of her patients is the killer. In the second story somebody has kidnapped the son of gangster George Cornelius... who is convinced that Luther is involved.

This four part story marked a welcome return; not just for Idris Elba's DCI Luther but also for Alice who everybody thought was dead. This return could have been a problem but it was dealt with in a matter of fact fashion and worked well. It must be stated that this pretty grim at times with several brutal murders and scenes of torture that will certainly bother some viewers. It does get rather melodramatic towards the end, with even more violence, but it didn't feel out of place and featured one genuinely shocking moment. The cast are impressive; Elba is great as Luther, I can understand why people talk of him as a possible Bond; Ruth Wilson is equally great as Alice, one of my favourite characters in the series. Also particularly notable are Hermione Norris, as the psychiatrist; Wunmi Mosaku as DS Catherine Halliday and Patrick Malahide as George Cornelius. Overall I'd say that this was a really impressive story that fans of Luther are pretty sure to enjoy.
8 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Great ideas but execution lacking...
M1REK19987 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Another season of Luther has passed our screens following a long absence and on the whole I was left with mixed opinions. As usual Elba's performance as the eponymous character failed to disappoint and this season continued to explore key themes that give the show its gritty zest, including Luther's fractured moral compass and his complex relationship with femme fatale Alice. However this season felt as though it was narratively contending with too much which led it to the writing feeling disjointed, predictable and inconsistent with the subsequent effect of these themes lacking the same high calibre of execution as in earlier seasons.

Anyone who has followed the series so far is aware by now that John Luther is the ultimate anti-hero, the Devil's emissary dispatched to Earth in the paradoxical form of a Metropolitan police detective with a mission to punish every manner of evil wrongdoing he encounters. His strict allegiance to the law has always wavered, however, evidenced by how he frequently resorts to a criminal level level by choosing to freely employ unorthodox methods such as coercion, assault and manipulation to emerge victorious over his adversaries. However a change in his employment of these strategises is partially why this season has been a success. Luther has never achieved anything by doing the right thing, yet for the first time this season has seen him trying to do just that (or at least what he considers to be the right thing), witnessed by his decision to abandon Alice and return to his career saving lives or by his insistence to negotiate with arch-nemesis George Cornelius instead of allowing Alice to murder him. Yet whenever he attempts to do the right thing the exact opposite occurs leading circumstances to quickly derail as his every move seems to catalyse an unwanted and often disastrous outcome. We see this through the loss of three main and supporting characters across the span of two episodes. Everything that happens could have been prevented one way or another but played as they happened due to Luther's desperate mission to save lives which ironically caused the loss of many more, including good people he cared about. In the end, when the smoke has cleared, the season ambiguously ends with a broken Luther caught amidst an impossible situation where all his sins and actions have finally caught up to him. This season particularly reminded me of Marvel's The Punisher series and to a greater extent Nolan's The Dark Knight. This is clearly echoed narratively and thematically with Luther placed as London's dark knight, the tortured anti-hero fighting for justice by any means necessary. His relationship with Alice very much mirrors the Batman-Joker dynamic, and even the ending sees our hero lose. All his actions, including the death of Alice and the capture of the muderlus doctor, largely amount to nothing except his own downfall.

While the outlined themes remained a consistently fascinating and crucial aspect of the show, in this season too much was going on what with both the main storyline entangled with Luther's own subplot which led to the former feeling rushed and these themes becoming sidelined and underdeveloped in place of wild action and confusing writing which is never what the show was about. Many events which unfolded consistently lacked appropriate justification. It certainly felt as though the writers grew trigger happy in the latter portion of the series. Killing Alice's character always seemed a sure eventuality but abruptly dismissing both Benny AND Halliday felt like overkill, unnecessarily done so to reiterate a point of which we were already aware, which is that Luther's mission to do good comes at the expense of good peoples' lives. I think it is because of these narrative indescrepencies that caused these themes to feel neglected at times and for this season to lack the same unpredictable dark charm and gritty edge that were so signature to earlier seasons. A return to the clever, character-orientated, slow-paced noirish surrealist-horror heritage of the earlier seasons would no doubt be this shows saving grace, certainly a more favourable alternative to narrative overload and unjustified violence and death.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best series to date ends with a huge episode.
Sleepin_Dragon4 January 2019
I mentioned previously, that I hoped for the perfect series, that's four episodes rated 10, and that is actually the case, absolutely one of the most satisfying things I've seen on TV for years. I've always loved the show, but for me this has been the best series to date, and this episode sums of what's been so good about it, the intensity, the guessing games, the story, characters, and of course Ruth Wilson.

The scenes between Luther and Alice were absolutely mesmerising, I know it's early days in the year, but these two are seriously worthy contenders for awards following their incredible performances, as always it's Wilson that keeps me glued. I thought Dermot Crowley was terrific here too.

One little irritation, was the occurrence that I predicted happening in my review of episode one, a particular death, which didn't need to happen, I won't spoil it for anyone that hasn't seen it, but it's a character I'd have loved to return.

Mind blowing, pulse racing, shocking, engaging, literally any superlatives you can think of, would not be out of place. 10/10
51 out of 76 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Faced with escalating danger, is this the end of the road for Luther?
DVD_Connoisseur4 January 2019
The fifth season of "Luther" is, perhaps, the most satisfying yet.

Despite the seemingly impossible task of locating the psychopathic doctor whose actions are now out of control, Luther is determined to crack this case and save his friends from almost certain death.

With only an hour of screen time, this episode manages to conclude the series in a satisfying way whilst also leaving the viewer in something resembling a state of shock. There are a lot of things to process as the end credits roll.

This is British drama at its best.

10 out of 10.
25 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A truly remarkable episode. Warning: Spoilers
Anyone who knows me understands how much I love this show. This season is possibly my favourite of them all. Episode 3 in particular was amazing but this episode was also amazing. I can't decide whether I hope this is the final episode or not as it is a high note and would end the show with dignity. Although I feel sad about how the show ended for John and Alice. Epic season and excellent intriguing end. I don't know how they could continue after this.
13 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
S5: Driven by sheer force, but the bluster only takes it so far
bob the moo9 March 2019
If you discount the first season, Luther has been consistently solid in what it does and how it does it. The previous (fourth) season was too short, rushed, and unsatisfying, so it was good to see a run of 4 episodes for this season. Within this season it does the stuff you've seen it do before. There is a very weird killer doing very weird killings - Luther is going to get them, but it will be about three and a bit episodes before that happens. Meanwhile Luther is also tied up in some sideplot which he is trying to get ahead of even as it closes in on him. It does this all pretty well in terms of basic mechanics; it enjoys its violence, it enjoys its grim feel, and its characters all slouch and swagger around in a way that implies complexity and darkness. This is how this fifth season goes.

For it to work, it needs you to go with it, so it very much pushes brand recognition. Elba is the main thrust of this and continues to be the reason the show gets made no doubt. He thrusts his hands in his pockets, offers plenty that speaks to a complex, haunted character, and drives into violence with a heart that isn't thee on paper but he makes happen. Luther is far from an interesting character, but Elba is a great presence. The supporting cast are variable and mostly feel disposable, with plenty of them being plot devices. None of it feels particularly grounded in anything, but it ploughs on ahead, providing violence, style, and Elba to carry the viewer along.

Of course this limits it too, but it offers enough strength to just about cover for this, although you do need to ignore the lack of even internal logic, and the heavy reliance on these core values over anything more substantial.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Final Episode?
erz_hall5 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Think this may be the last one, they made a big deal of taking his famous 'Coat' from him for the Last time??
7 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Flawed Heroes and Perfect Villains
canspam-114 January 2019
Season 5 maintained the level of story integrity needed to keep my interest. There was an aspect of the story arc that seemed added to please the longtime fans but it was dealt with in a way that gratified me.

Of the five 'seasons,' this was my third favorite. While some in my family felt other choices should have been made by Luther, I thought he was consistant with his drive to help those in his life while trying to minimize the damage to his 'duty' caused from actions he knows are darker than grey: He wants to protect and do the right thing for individuals and is willing to compromise his professional duty for that goal. A bit like 'The Bureau' in that regard.

I felt one of the villians could have been stronger but the direction it went kept them human without being cliche. The writers seemed boxed into an inevitable ending if they wanted to keep the story's integrity plausable. I was okay with that and I still was left asking, "what's next?" ;)

Technically, from an editor's aspect, this was not the worse Luther season. The story building craft impressed me more than some of the earlier seasons and it came together better for me.
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tex, our hero
alessandrovergoni20 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Why always me? It's not Balotelli but the Tex! He's the real cause and solution for all the murders. What a bad end for the Tex!
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The series has been murdered
Kumarh028 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I was so excited Alice was coming back - The tangible manifestation of Luther's dark side. By far the most exciting character in the first few series. Sadly, the real Alice is nowhere to be seen in season 5. Instead we are served with a powerless, needy and boring version. All the menacing, edgy and seductiveness is missing. The villain, and the potential development of his character, was totally wasted. I actually thought the series was priming Halliday for a spin off series since all of the usual meticulous and inspired observations of Luther were missing. Couldn't grasp why they decided to turn Alice and Luther on each other and why the usual affectionate sentament he has for past lovers was coldly absent in her case?! Killing her off in this manner defies the point of bringing her back in the first place. In poor fashion, the murder case is wrapped up in a rushed and wasteful manner- it should have been the centre-piece. As others have mentioned, killing off another key character in Benny, leaves little reason to continue with this series. What a shame!
43 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wow wow wow
stevie_sloan4 January 2019
This is a must watch tv series and in particular the last episode is full of omfg moments. Amazing
8 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Episode 5.4
Prismark106 January 2019
Luther should had taken Alice's advice. Let her kill George Cornelius.

Luther instead wanted to do the right thing and know finds himself sinking in a metaphorical quicksand.

Meanwhile Jeremy Lake plans a killing spree and it is left to Halliday to try to break his wife as Luther has to free Mark and Alice from the hitman.

I long ago gave up any sense in Luther, you just sit back and enjoy the ride.

You can sense Alice's disappointment when Luther lies to her. There were one or two killings that were senseless in my opinion and wasted good characters.

By the end Luther has nowhere to go and is even stripped of his long coat.

Mention must be made of Dermot Crowley as Schenk. The look of seething anger in his face when he learned of Benny's death was something else.
24 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Worst End ever Spoiler Alert
ciprian-vatamanescu20 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
They ruined the whole series with the last 15 minutes. Even 10 year old would have done better. WHY kill his helper, has nothing to do with series with the plot with the chemistry of thier relationships.

Shame Shame Shame
28 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Oh my days!
MayerMayor29 January 2019
WOW what a great show! I've been an avid Luther fan from Series 1 and have eagerly awaited each subsequent series - even though there've been long gaps in between some of them, and then Series 4 turns up with only two episodes. So annoying!

But Series 5 was worth the wait. Four exciting episodes with so many twists and turns it was a real roller coaster. Love Alice. Love the new DS Halliday, and... oh my, what an ending!! If you haven't watched Luther Series 5 yet, you need to do it. NOW!
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
S5 Review
r96sk26 September 2020
I enjoyed season five of 'Luther'. It isn't perfect, but it delivers the desired amount of entertainment.

Idris Elba remains brilliant as the titular character. I wouldn't say any of the other cast members particularly stand out to an incredible degree, barring one or two who are good. The four episodes are all paced fairly well, sometimes the show - at least over the last few seasons - does move slower than you'd expect; not slow enough that I'd describe them as a drag or anything close to that, I just feel they could pick up the pace ever so slightly. With that said, some events that take place do seem to be included just to add shock value; it can feel a little less well written in those moments, at least compared to what we've been accustomed to across the opening season or two.

Nonetheless, I still enjoyed S5 - I'd probably rank it as my third favourite so far, behind S1/2 but ahead of S3/4; though it's a toss-up between S3 and S5.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tex come back! Wow
francescovergoni20 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
What a final from the texxx! We will really miss him, love till the end. Texshow
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Not the best End
huaweiaremmm5 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Please stop killing Characters, the only good thing about this episode was seeing idris elba
4 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fell Down and Arrested
ZegMaarJus19 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This episode begins with Palmer, he has ubducted Mark and Alice. Jeremy killed Simon on the streets. John arrived at George. John points a gun on George his head. John shot Palmer down, George shot Palmer to death. John saved Alice and Mark. John interviews Vivien. Jeremy knocks down Ilena. Alice shoots on George, she runs away. George gets arrested by Martin. Jeremy killed Ilena. John arrested Jeremy. Alice shot a bullet trough Catherine's head, she died instantly. Alice shot on John. Alice fell down from the theses, she died instantly. John is heavily wounded. Martin arrested John. Amazing Final of Luther Season 5, what a great ending of the show. Spectacular ending scene with Alice, she fell down and died. John gets arrested, end of the show!
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good, but..........
efd-1046724 February 2019
Series 5 was still good but got a bit lost in the woven storylines, less a good mystery solved more an expunging of demons for the main character.

It's good to go deeper with characters but there is a point when you want to simply follow the clues and solve the mystery, not this series, still I hope the series returns.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The worst season
polyzoiskatsaitis9 January 2019
No plot , only key persons deaths without reason! Not even a clever puzzle to solve, all was a huge nothing!
58 out of 70 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
What a waste!
nasloranger24 June 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Let me say I love Idris Elba - I could watch him read the phone book and be happy... As a matter of fact, I wish he had been reading the phone book instead of appearing in this latest series of Luther.

All four episodes were a disjointed, unbelievable mess - but especially this last one! Why did they have to kill off so many people? Not only were 3 main characters eliminated, but the senseless murders of at least a half-dozen innocent victims by the psychopathic killer was over the top! It was figureitively - and literally - a bloodbath!

Did Alice love or hate Luther? Who knows? She just decided to shoot him full of holes because, wellll, she's a psychopathic killer, too, and that's what she does best, I guess.

Of all the streets in London how did Luther know exactly where to find the killer? Who knows? It must have been his "magic powers of elimination", eh?

I just wish they had killed off Luther in the end, too, instead of simply stripping him of his longcoat and taking him off in handcuffs to end the episode/series.

I read that Idris has signed on for a 6th series of Luther, but why bother? Alice is gone - for real this time. Benny is gone, and a promising new partner was quickly, and needlessly, eliminated as well.

I was so disappointed in this hot mess that I've decided not to waste my time on any more future episodes. Nothing the writers create can salvage what they did to Luther - or what was once an interesting story and cast of characters. There was so much they could have done with this series 5, and they really botched it!

Goodbye my sweet Luther. 😢
27 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Utter tripe
harry_lamb7 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Luther started so positively; its mix of intelligent script-writing, shocking scenes, and intricate plot lines were a staple of previous series. However, this entire series has been so poor. The lack of attention to detail, the scrambled and nonsensical plot, and the perverse desire to reduce their cast drastically has ruined the entire series. I really hope that there isn't another single episode of this as I'll feel compelled to watch it, and it will just be a waste of my time.
30 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
No, no, no, no!
HoracioDee24 June 2019
Writers, you do not get to end "Luther" with this sloppy week writing! No one was written to character, except perhaps Benny. That wasn't John Luther and Alice Morgan - it was an abomination. Shame on you for capping a wonderful series with such slop.
41 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Idris Elba is superb, as always, but the disjointed plot.........
newhit-275537 January 2019
Besotted Psychiatrist just chastising lunatic hubby with, "Now stop being a bad boy". Luther's repeated, "I will sort it", with the murder and mayhem continuing. Loony Alice just calling round to say "Hello". A boss missing ALL the twists and turns. Gangster boss who is, "Up his own.......". Luther badly shot up and still able to chase Alice and hold her full weight...Nah, too much OTT!
23 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed