Nick and Drew take a trip to a local brewery to figure out their bar's beer selection. They each make a unique signature beer and have a keg party at their friend's house to decide which will earn permanent placement at Lachey's.
Nick returns to Cincinnati, where he and Drew are opening a bar together. They must quickly make several key decisions about the bar and decide to embark on a pub crawl as a means of research.
It's all come down to this--the bar is finally ready to open. Or is it? Nick and Drew work through the night to get it ready to open, get the key to the city from the Mayor, and at long last, officially open the doors to Lachey's.