"Quincy M.E." The Winning Edge (TV Episode 1980) Poster

(TV Series)

(1980)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Decent but preachy.
planktonrules10 May 2013
I noticed that the other reviewer for this particular show hated the episode--mostly because they feel that such anti-drug messages are ineffective and unnecessary. While I can easily understand this, that aspect of the show didn't bother me nearly as much. Now I am not saying I loved the show--just that its anti-drug message didn't bother me--though I do agree that such messages rarely have any impact on behaviors. My problem with the show has much more to do with that I thought it was just not particularly well made or interesting.

The show is about a bunch of girls with hopes of becoming gymnastics champions. To do this, they and their coach are willing to do just about anything--even take drugs to give them the energy and extra 'oomph' to compete. However, one of the girls takes LOTS of the drugs and the amphetamines end up contributing to her death. Naturally, this gets Dr. Quincy involved. And, like so many other episodes, he doesn't just do the autopsy but thinks he is a cop--investigating the case (which sane coroners would NOT do) and trying to determine where the dead girl got her drugs. Not surprisingly, the coach and teammates are very closed-mouthed about it--and, in a very hard to believe twist, some of the girls come up with a plan to take care of the problem.

Overall, this episode is just okay. It does seem a bit preachy and is not especially entertaining or believable. Not terrible but you know the school can just do a lot better.

By the way, at the 44 minute mark, watch the blonde girl fall off the balance beam. It's clearly NOT her and someone with a HUGE and over-sized wig! Ha!
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Terrible episode
rayoflite2426 October 2015
The Winning Edge begins with a bunch of high school girls who are also competitive gymnasts taking amphetamines supplied by their coach to enhance their performances and help them cope with the pressure of an upcoming national competition. One of the gymnasts, Sally Peters (Shawn Hoskins), takes more of the drug than usual and ends up dying during practice while the rest of the team and coach play cover up. Quincy (Jack Klugman) conducts the autopsy and determines that Sally died from the drugs causing an aneurysm in her brain to rupture which makes him determined to find out who supplied her.

I found this to be a pretty bad episode for several reasons. First off, the prior Season 5 episode "Unhappy Hour" dealt with a teen death due to alcohol addiction, and here in the very next episode we have another teen dying as a result of drug abuse. Two episodes in a row of this subject matter teaching the same exact lesson was way over the top in my opinion and overkill. The producers really should have switched around the order or something rather than airing such similar stories back to back. Additionally, there is zero mystery in this episode as we see right in the beginning what happened and who was responsible which made it much less interesting.

I also found the build up to be extremely slow as Sally doesn't die until nearly 20 minutes in. Although it was obvious what was going to happen and where the story was going, it just seemed like it took forever for it to get under way and in the meantime we are forced to endure lots of corny dialogue among high school students and some ridiculous sub-plot about Quincy winning a raffle for a tailor made suit which I did not find nearly as funny as Dr. Asten (John S. Ragin). I guess at least they made an attempt at comic relief here as heaven knows this episode needs something!

Overall, a pretty bad Season 5 entry which I would not recommend viewing unless you are a die hard Quincy fan like me.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Probably the worst episode of the fifth season.
poolandrews3 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: The Winning Edge starts as seventeen year old gymnast Sally Peters (Shawn Hoskins) suddenly dies while performing a routine for her coach Virginia Hart (Caroline Smith). Los Angeles coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) has to perform the autopsy, at first he sees no reason for Sally to have died but the tox screen show's large amounts of drugs in her system which caused high blood pressure & an aneurysm in her brain to burst. Quincy believes that whoever provided Sally with drugs killed her & starts his investigation by talking to the other girls in Sally's gymnastics class, soon he discovers the shocking truth that Hart has been regularly giving her young students dangerous performance enhancing drugs like they were sweets...

Episode 17 from season 5 this Quincy story was directed by Georg Fenady & The Winning Edge probably gets my vote as the single worst episode of Quincy's fifth season. I know performance enhancing drugs are bad but we all have choices right? No-one is forced to take them. I know drugs in general are bad but then any right minded individual knows this anyway & again we have a choice. Yes, that's right The Winning Edge is yet another cautionary tale about the dangers of drugs, this episode certainly doesn't win any points for originality does it? The whole episode feels very routine, Quincy is barely in it & it takes an amusing subplot about a custom made suit to alleviate the boredom. It turns out that Quincy entered a raffled several month earlier & won third prize, to have a suit custom made by Beverly Hills tailor to the stars Pietro & all the general amusement that causes in the office. Basically if you know that using drugs is bad & wrong then you can you can do yourself a favour & skip The Winning Edge easily enough safe in the knowledge that you haven't missed anything.

I must admit this episode worried me a bit, Quincy is seen on his own looking at young schoolgirls in tight fitting leotards performing gymnastics. I am not being being funny but people can jump to the wrong conclusion, I mean a 60 year old guy hanging around scantily clad schoolgirls? I guarantee you right now that people here in the UK have been investigated by the police & social services for less than that. I guess it's the time we live in but an old guy like Quincy hanging around schoolgirls really would arouse suspicion these days. There are various scenes of young girls performing gymnastics so if that sort of thing impresses you (the gymnastics, not the young girls...) then you might like this episode.

The Winning Edge is a rather lacklustre moralistic tale about the dangers of drugs, it sounds throughly routine & predictable because it is throughly routine & predictable. Not my favourite episode by a long way.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed