"Naked City" Idylls of a Running Back (TV Episode 1962) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
In Dealing with those in this World, always remember; some people lie. They lie when they don't have to; because they're so used to it! And are they ever convincing!
redryan6425 April 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Samuel Clemmons, better known as Mark Twain, had a lot of memorable quotations that he bequeathed to mankind for the duration of Man's Life. One of my favourites is the one in which he says the definition of Golf as: "A Good Walk Ruined."

Another astute quote said: "A Lie can get itself halfway across the World before the Truth can get its shoes on." Indeed the obvious keen and incisive observations by Mr. Twain took notice of what would seem to be a universally held flaw shared by all of us weak and imperfect Mortal Human. That slice of negativity would be doubting what should be some of the most obvious and elementary facts; that are presented to us by some of our closest friends.So it is that we see some mighty powerful contradictions that co-exist and thrive in all of us. This is a situation that is not limited to Official Police Matters and yet it is probably most often encountered by the Cops in what could only be referred to as being Classic Examples. As we shall see, situations like this can have very serious consequences.

OUR STORY……………………We open up our story in the Bronx at the "House That Ruth Built", Yankee Stadium. But we immediately sense that there will be no Baseball Game that bright and sunny day; for everyone is wearing overcoats and some sort of head covering. Once inside the venerable Ball Park, we see that what it was is not (ho-hum, yawn) another Yankee World Series Game; but rather a Professional Football Game.*

Although the teams are never mentioned by name, the stock footage used to create the story's Football Game when inter-cut with scenes of the actors appears to be of a game between the Cleveland Browns and the New York Giants (who did play their home games there prior to the dawning of The Meadowlands in New Jersey).

The story involves the insane infatuation that develops in the mind of one Eleanore Hubber (Sandy Dennis), a little, insignificant nebbish of a Young Lady for Elvin Rhodes (Aldo Rae), a big bruising Pro Football Running Back, deluxe!

It seems that Miss had been introduced to Football by her would be suitor, Harry Vaderci (William Daniels).** The normally quiet, wall-flower of a girl starts taking an interest in the Grid Iron and in Elvin Rhodes in particular. At one particular moment, while Eleanore is getting the Footballer's autograph, he flashes her; but with a fine, broad smile and nothing else. That's all that her feeble, self contained and reclusive mind needed. From that point on, she surmised, she and he were an "item". She did a Jules Verne-like job of inventing every little detail of their "Romance". She even checked into the same hotels on road games and faked evidence of having shared her room with him.

The whole situation hits a crescendo when she goes to his room, unannounced and when she knocks at the door and he opens, she shoots him with a .38 calibre revolver. He survives and she turns herself into Detective Adam Flint; offering a motive of "because I love him!" The story, with all of the various eccentricities to support her charges of an extra-marital affair, seems all too real and totally believable, not only to the Police, but also to Elvin's Mrs., Norma Rhodes (Nancy Wickwire). Det. Flint is too personally involved in the plight of what he perceives as being the poor, little, wronged girl. Flint even helps the flighty Miss Hubber in procuring a Mouthpiece, Barrister Ketton (Joe Silver).

There was just one problem; that being, that other than their brief meeting with many others present in getting his autograph, no one ever saw the two of them together. This 'minor' point eventually caused the whole false set of accusations to unravel. Elvin Rhodes is vindicated and as we fade out, Detective Flint, who was apologetic and had been cautioned by Lt. Mike Parker about getting too personally attached, now makes a telephone call to Mrs. Rhodes on behalf of Elvin and his innocence.

That would seem to leave only one question; for as Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas remarked after his confirmation hearings, featuring Anita Hill, were over; "Now where do I go to get my good reputation back?"

We must mention that there's a certain obvious similarity to the Rubin Malamud 1952 Novel and later film, THE NATURAL (Delphi II/Tri-Star Pictures, 1984). In turn, The Natural was inspired by the real life story of Major League Baseball Player, Eddie Waitkus of the Chicago Cubs, Philadelphia Phillies & Baltimore Orioles; who was shot by a mentally disturbed & stalking female fan at Chicago's Edgewater Beach Hotel in 1949.

Like all NAKED CITY episodes, "Idylls of a Running Back" has a fine cast of supporting actors; basically enlisted from the ranks of the Legitimate Stage, be it Broadway or "off". An interesting addition is a very brief appearance of character Football Player & Team Mate, Pixie Gates. Gates is played by Heavyweight Boxer and Joe Louis look-alike, Coley Wallace. Mr Wallace had the distinction of having portrayed "The Brown Bomber", Heavyweight Champion Joe Louis twice; once in THE JOE LOUIS STORY (Walter P. Chrysler Prod./United Artists, 1953) and again in RAGING BULL (Chartoff-Winkler Prod./United Artists, 1980). Now Schultz, I'm no mathematician, but that's 27 years in between those 2 pictures and Mr. Coley Wallace looks about the same!

NOTE: * This is during the early stages of the Pro Football expansion; what with a newly formed American Football League now in its 3rd Season as rival to the NFL.

NOTE ** The story gives William Daniels' character only the name of Harry; so we thought we'd give him one. Hence, we thought of dubbing him, "Harry Vaderci". Get it, Schultz? Kind of like being in a HONEYMOONERS episode with Kramden & Norton; don't you think? POODLE SCHNITZ!!
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
She didn't want anything to spoil their love
sol-kay7 January 2013
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILER ALERT*** Obviously based on the 1949 shooting of Philadelphia Phillie all star infielders Eddie Watkus the "Naked City" episode "Idylls of a Running Back" has star football half-back and All American hero Elvin Rhodes, Aldo Rey, get blown away by a crazed and love sick fan who just can't get enough of him. It's the unstable and infatuated with love for her idol New York City waitress Elenore Ann Hubber, Sandy Dennis, who did a number on the guy, with three slugs in his gut, when Rhodes answered the bell in his hotel room only to find himself looking down the barrel of a .38 revolver. Elenore for her part made no attempt to hide her crime telling the cop in charge of the Rhodes shooting the deeply in touch with his inner emotions Det. Adam Flint, Paul Burke, that she in fact blew the guy away for very personal reasons. He was leaving poor Elenore for his old lady back in California Norma played by Nancy Wickwire. It's Rhodes whom Elenore claimed promised her that he would divorce Norma in the off season just so he can end up, I'm not quite certain that claimed that Rhodes planned to marry Elenore, in the shack with her!

As for poor and hospitalized Elvin Rhodes his both professional career as a football player as well as marriage is now on the rocks. That with Rhodes not certain if can ever play football again and with now everyone lead by the now, in another feel good cause he got himself into, womens rights advocate Det.Flint who took Elenore's side! That without him as much as looking at the evidence that in fact convicted her and exposed Elenore as a fraud in her so-called love affair with Elvin Rhodes! Rhodes despite his injuries soon takes the law into his own hands and track down Elenore at the dinner she works at and in his attempting to get her to tell the truth and why she blasted him ends up re-injuring himself as it took some half dozen consumer in the dinner to subdue him. The final shoe to drop on poor Elvin Rhodes' already battered head was his once loving wife Norma walking out on him in believing that he's the heel that's depicted in all the newspapers and TV & radio news shows. With all the fake evidence in numerous football game tickets hotel reservations and even a fur coat that Rhodes supposedly gave her, that Elenore gathered on Rhodes to frame him, that his emotionally hurt wife Norma now believes that he was not just playing the field on but off the gridiron as well!

***SPOILERS*** Happily for Rhodes as well as Norma it's Elenore's nerdy and powder puff, if you just sneeze you can knock him out, boyfriend Harry Culverin played by William Daniels who's a total opposite of the hard as nails and battling ram like Rhodes who blew the whistle on her. That by Harry revealing to Det Flint the obsessive fascination she had for Rhodes ever since he took her out on a date to see him play in Yankee Stadium over a year ago! It was Elenore's crazed obsession with her hero Elvin Rhodes that lead her to gun the poor guy down when her boyfriend Harry was going to expose her hot and heavy love affair with Rhodes for what it really was: A high school girl's fantasy for the star football player that she fell madly in love with but knows that she could never have!

P.S For once in his life the over sensitive for all of humanity Det. Adam Flint had to face the stark reality in that he's no different, in him having the most bleeding of liberal bleeding hearts, then the rest of us. Instead of looking at the hard facts in the case which were right in front of him he jumped to conclusions and made a complete jerk of himself. That in Det. Flint instead coming to the aid of a gun down and total innocent man, Elvin Rhodes, he instead ended up at the head of a lynch mob with him providing it the rope to hang the guy! And Det.Flint's apology to Rhodes at the end of the "Naked City" episode did, like he himself admitted, nothing to heal the emotional wounds that he, like the psychical ones by Elenore, caused him!
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed