"Law & Order" Survivor (TV Episode 1996) Poster

(TV Series)

(1996)

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Arch, fulfilling.
rmax30482315 January 2011
Warning: Spoilers
The writers of this series should have gotten medals. This episode is about people who covet extremely expensive coins, even those that don't exist, in order to use them as collateral, justify bragging rights, or reclaim them as stolen family heirlooms.

It's not as if the writers sat down, got high on java mochas, and swapped ideas. They had to do homework on the subject. And they couldn't simply google "twelve Cleopatra dubloons" or something; they had to find out how coins were collected, stored, and sold on the market. It's the kind of material that, unlike Kekule's benzine molecule, doesn't come to you in a dream.

A man is found with his head bashed in on the floor of his rare coin shop. The detectives dig up various suspects, some of them working against each other. Motives have to do with maintaining one's own private Boeing 747 and with replevening the coin collection of one's father, stolen before the holocaust in Germany.

The usual complications arise. Knowing ahead of time that a suspect, Karen Allen, is claustrophobic, the Assistant Executive Minister of the District Attorney's office or whatever she -- Carey Lowell -- is, and two burly detectives crowd her against the wall in order to obtain permission to search her apartment. Naughty.

It's difficult to tell whether Karen Allen overacts the part of the neurotic or not because, as a neurotic, she's supposed to be overacting. The fourteen years since "Raiders of the Lost Ark" have changed her considerably, to the extent that she's barely recognizable and her voice is now a muted croak. Not her fault in any way, of course. Time changes all of us but it's a little sad when we see its effects in a professional actor or actress.

The award for the most spirited performance goes to Maurizio Benazzo as a sarcastic, gay head waiter in a fancy Soho restaurant. His gestures are flamboyant, the contours of his speech exquisite.
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best episodes
dgsweet10 May 2009
I teach writing. One of my students made a casual, dismissive comment about the quality of writing on TV. I sat him down to watch this episode and he was stunned and humbled. This is series writing at its subtlest and most intricate. A tragedy that begins and ends with bad behavior by banks. A contemporary death that has its roots in the history we never seem to outlive. And, in the middle of this, Karen Allen -- with maybe twenty minutes of screen time -- creating a character of unusual depth and resonance. LAW AND ORDER has had its ups and downs over the years, but when I think of those episodes when it's fulfilled the full potential of its premise, this (which was broadcast without much particular comment or attention) is the first I think of.
36 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
From comedy to tragedy, a masterpiece
L_O_Addict11 September 2013
This episode is brilliantly written and acted.

The first half consists of a series of comic vignettes as the detectives seek to build a case against billionaire businessman Richard Peterson for the murder of his friend and coin dealer. There are several minor characters, each with only a minute or two of screen time. They include the "Italian aristocrat" who serves as the two men's mistress, but is actually from South Carolina; the rich businessman who "gets horny" thinking about coins as he works on his luxury yacht; the haughty restaurateur who refuses to divulge his clients' secret conversations; and the nubile young reporter who tried and failed to invite Peterson back for "coffee". All have memorable interactions with Briscoe and Curtis, Briscoe having a wonderful time flirting with the ladies.

Things turn serious when the focus of the investigation shifts to Judith Sandler, the child of a Holocaust survivor. Her father owned the missing coins, but was unable to recover them from a Swiss bank after the war. Sandler, wonderfully acted by Karen Allen, has an extreme personality: touchy, overwrought, claustrophobic. It soon becomes apparent that she is the real killer, but the evidence against her is suppressed when Ross exploits her claustrophobia in order to get her consent to search her apartment.

While Sandler represents tragedy, Peterson (skilfully acted by Michael Willis) represents comedy: a larger-than-life character who's having so much fun collecting coins and running his business empire that it's hard to dislike him, even when his lies unwittingly set into motion the tragic murder of his friend.

McCoy gets less screen time than usual, but Ross shines. Note especially her first appearance: the camera almost caresses her as she glides into the frame during Peterson's interrogation.

Law and Order had its strong and weak spells over its twenty years, but this episode sums up what could happen when everything came together -- perfect writing, camera-work and acting.
20 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Homicidal finance
TheLittleSongbird1 April 2021
Actually started watching 'Law and Order' from the later episodes of the Briscoe and Green period. Am so glad since then about watching the whole show over-time since, because the early seasons are better, more consistent and where the show was at its best despite disappointments every now and then. They really should not be overlooked, despite being aired less frequently. Have found that to be the case with 'Special Victims Unit' and 'Criminal Intent' as well.

"Survivor" is a good example of why. For me, it is one of the best episodes of Season 7 and a fine example of 'Law and Order' at its best. It has one of the season's most intricate and most interesting cases (tonally and structurally as well as in content), and also contains one of the early seasons' most fascinating and complex supporting characters. "Survivor" is simply fantastic and it is episodes like it that is a good representation of why the early seasons really should be seen.

It is shot with the right amount of intimacy without being claustrophobic and that the editing has become increasingly tighter over-time has been great too. The music doesn't get intrusive or overwrought, even when the episode gets more dramatic. The direction doesn't try to do too much and is understated but never flat or unsure.

The writing is intelligent and although, like the show in general, there is a lot of talk (as always for the 'Law and Order' franchise) it doesn't feel like there is too much or too loose. Tonally, one half is different than the other, starting off comedically but gets more serious. Doing so without being too much of a disconnect or feeling like two different episodes. The story entertains and intrigues throughout, it is an intricate one with many clever and unexpected twists and turns while not falling into incoherence.

While there is a preference with the more serious and grittier second half, the first half is far from routine and is in fact a lot of fun. All the characters are interesting and well written, especially Judith. Ross has settled very well and shines here. Could there have been more of McCoy? Perhaps, but he still has a lot of presence.

All the performances are excellent, Jerry Orbach is great as always, relishing Briscoe's ever cracking one-liners, and Carey Lowell more than holds her own despite it being only her fourth episode. Michael Willis is suitably quirky. Best of all is Karen Allen, her performance is very like Francie Swift in Season 5's "Switch". In that she has a very difficult and emotionally complex role that could easily have been over-acted, but Allen doesn't do so and instead is very hard-hitting.

Concluding, fantastic. 10/10.
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Karen Allen is one outstanding actress.
ColonelPuntridge7 August 2018
Karen Allen absolutely inhabits her role. And it's a very challenging role, because the character is kind of one-dimensional and exaggeratedly dramatic. It must have been very difficult to play this role without over-acting and losing the sense of realism.
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Pesonally touching and informative, dramatized beautifully
kimdel29 January 2022
A line in this episode caught my attention as it applies to not only Holocaust survivor's children, but to any child of someone who had a horrific life and carries that burden with them. "She displaces her anger at what happened to her parents into empathy" when explaining why Karen Allen's character breaks down at every horror she sees, reads about or is told of, because she can so easily identify with it.

This episode is one of the best there is, Karen Allen was not Karen Allen, she was Judith Sandler. The subject was handled well without sanitizing it. Well done and tragic.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The accused shines a harsh light on the prosecution
jn-399432 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I enjoy this episode very much largely because of the incomparably real performance of Karen Allen She is so true to the character that I actually (for the first time in the series) dislike McCoy and Ross who don't realize their own errors until the end- in the meantime use "Gestapo" like tactics- taking advantage of her emotional state due to her upbringing and her claustrophobia to gain access to her apartment! In her last scene Miss Allen is so real I am gasping for air and wanting her to call not just the coin collector but McCoy and Ross b-----ds! And given the extenuating circumstances and seeing the way they plea down other more offensive defendants- her sentence should have been plead down with recommendation for outpatient treatment for her neuroses!
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Two Suspects, two theories
bkoganbing19 September 2015
In this Law And Order story a rare coin dealer is murdered and the police investigation comes up with two suspects with opposing theories of the crime. The first is a quirky billionaire played by Mark Willis for whom these rare coins that were stolen at the time of the murder that the victim was supposed to sell him are just one of the many big kid 'toys' he'd like to acquire.

The second suspect is Karen Allen and she has the intrepid Tovah Feldshuh as her attorney. Allen is the daughter of Holocaust survivors and she believes the coins were once owned by her father who never survived Hitler's hospitality. This woman is really not wrapped too tight and even the DA's consulting psychiatrist Dr. Olivet thinks she's got serious issues.

Only one is guilty, but the other is meted out some justice as well.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Tipical case of prosecutorial misconduct
alessandrocs23 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I agree with most of the reviews Ross does clearly a prosecutorial misconduct taking advantage of Karen Allen wich is wonderful as jack McCoy old story he never learns instead of backing up Ross he should have scould her like Ben stone did in the first series with Paul when he did a unauthorised drug test to the victim in a summer of violence didn't like Adam too to leance with jack and Jamie,just like Abbie in her first year I didn't like the bullying by Ross,Briscoe and Curtis it clear that the judge suppressed the evidence and. I was suprise that Adam got angry at the judge with her decision instead of scoulding jack and Jamie.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sloppy prosecution
dickersonjohng18 October 2020
Peterson's late fees from the library on that stolen coin catalogue would bankrupt anyone
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Sham arrest and psychological abuse
steven-467-69006330 January 2023
Showcases the typical arrest on the sketchiest of "evidence" ever found that appears in most episodes. In this case, some glass was green on visual appearance only, and no chemical composition or spectral light analysis was made to match it to the object it supposedly came from.

This particular episode however, goes even further over the line delving into psychological abuse and bullying by the detectives. After being told by a suspect's boss that she once "got hysterical when she found herself sandwiched between three skinny curators and a wall" they then proceed to use exactly that tactic to force their way into her apartment without a warrant.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed