I think maybe the negative criticisms for this series are too harsh, (and I gave Discovery a 1* rating, and bashed the crap out of it, in my review). I do see the points people are making though, and more or less agree with them. But I also have been enjoying some of those same things, about this series.
Anyways, let me just address a few of the things, I've seen other reviews complaining about.
Dark: I do hate the new trend of tv shows being dark, in general. And this definitely suffers from that. Not only the story is dark, but also the visuals.
As far as dark visuals go, that is never good, (i.e. the CW look) and it's not good here either.
As far as a dark story goes, it can go either way. I do kind of like it here (unlike most others). I feel I can relate to Picard's darkness. I'm getting pretty old myself. Things I was once cheery about, just feel me with sadness now, with a sense of loss. Like Picard, I've lost loves ones, more and more each day. I myself used to be so optimistic. But, like Picard, I'm finding less and less to be optimistic about. I think Stewart's acting really captures this. So, I do like this aspect of the story.
Cameos: I absolutely love this aspect of the show. Every episode I've downloaded so far (pirated of course), I just can't wait to see if another old favorite will appear.
Non-episodic format: I do agree with the others here. I dislike it when any show has a non-episodic format. And, unfortunately, this is like that. I think what I dislike about it, with Star Trek, is that with old Star Treks I can watch episodes over and over again. I still watch Voyager and TNG episodes every day. (I have those series downloaded.)But, with a continuous story format, it may be good on the first viewing. You can't wait to progress the story each episode. And it's like that here too. I am anticipating each new episode, caus I want to see what will happen in the story. But as far as rewatching later, (I like to rewatch shows on a random shuffle in my media player) that wont work with this. Once you know the story there's no point to see it again.
Violence: Here I totally disagree with the other reviews. Well maybe not disagree. I do see their point. Star Trek in the past tried to avoid violence, and acts of violence by beloved characters. However, in those past series, that annoyed the f##k out of me. I felt it was brain washing, to try to make us sheep like slaves. Or even worse, they did do alot of violence on almost every episode of past Star Trek series, but then hypocritically denounced violence. In other words, they did just as much violence, if not more, than ST:P, they just didn't show it's effects (i.e. bodys were vaporized instead of stabbed).
Here, I think the violence is the best part, to me at least. When I told my brother about this series he asked, "Is it any good?" I replied, "It's ok. It has alot of pretty extreme violence." He replied, "Well that sounds good." So anyways, I really like the violence. It's the only thing that breaks up some of the boredom that the show can tend to have.
Boredom: I have to agree with some of the others here. Like many shows that try to be serious, it can be boring. This whole series so far, really could have been done in a few episodes.
I don't really blame the show though. People are just boring now days. They don't even know what excitement is. How could they make a show about something they can't even imagine. Maybe only us oldbies, from a time before internet, when we had to go out and do crazy things for fun, can remember excitement.
Anyhow, I just finished episode 6 and the excitement level has definitely picked up. ( I rate ep. 5 and ep. 6, both very good, and exciting.
Future setting: Finally, a new series or film that isn't a f##king prequel or remake. I could rant about prequels or remakes all day. (lol) And I won't feel satisfied until every person who ever made a prequel is dead. They ruined Star Trek with Enterprise. They ruined Star Trek with Discovery. They ruined Star Trek with those films (who's names I never even bothered to learn). The whole point of sci fi is the future. Not a point in time, between now and the future.
So, I am so very glad that this isn't another prequel.
Characters: I'm liking all the characters so far. I particularly like the guy with the sword. I like his ultra-violence. But, he is also funny. He is one of the few funny things in this show. Which is saying something, since he doesn't even talk much. Just the look on his face, and the few things he does say, always make me smile. The other characters seem good too. I don't know any of their names yet (on ep. 6), or I'd mention more characters I'm liking.
Final thoughts: It may not be the best Star Trek (not even close). But it's still worth watching. I've been enjoying it, and eagerly anticipating new episodes, each week (Unlike Discovery, which I completely quit watching). I.m on episode 6 now. It could change. But as of now I'm giving it an 8. Before you say, "That's too high." In my rating system, an 8 means, fairly enjoyable for a one time viewing.
2 out of 12 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends