Timothy Treadwell's story has facinated me since I became aware of it via this film. I am also someone who lives with "wild" animals. I have a "pack" of unaltered Lassies, and I can tell you first-hand, that even they have a life and a social heirachy that I do not control. Simply try to manage. I have read and watched everything I could about Timothy Treadwell, from all available sources, trying to figure out, like everyone else, how and why he did what he did.
From what I have seen, it seems Timothy Treadwell had finally found his niche. In thirteen years he watched and learned and perhaps instictively understood the Grizzly social heirarchy, their body language, their motivations and how to work within these in order to convince them he wasn't prey. As he admitted himself, he had them "bufffaloed" (at least the fat, happy summer bears he knew) Timothy Treadwell was the only one brave (crazy? Desperate?) enough to spend enough time with them to learn and test this. I read that he had tried Hollywood, and other wildlife species as projects, which seemed to indicate a desire to be famous and be widely recognized for his efforts.
He had had a tough road finding this niche, yet instead of the acclaim he desired, he was met with criticism from concerned people, competitors, and copy cats trying to benefit from his fame.
Coupled with this was his dark side (which was described by his friend, Jewel) which was not part of the public personna he wanted, or felt was appropriate, to show to the children. Almost everything he recorded was done so with the intent on lecturing to children. Also, when someone tries to communicate with animals, this must be done on their level. Most have the intelligence of a small child. Most can sense our emotions and intent. It was necessary for him ro act and sound childish, for two reasons, which worked together beautifully, and his naturally high voice fit in perfectly too!
There are several hints in his recordings of a "death wish" and wanting to "be with the bears forever". I think, when he did not get the recognition he deserved, and could not control or manipulate the situation, as he was able to do with these dangerous bears, he began to tempt fate more and more. If he suceeded, that was just more proof of his amazing ability. If he failed, he would "go out with a bang" and maintain his fame. When he was killed, it was late in the season with strange, hyper-hungry bears about, he was camped on a bear trail, hidden in the woods. All very dangerous, but surely he knew that after 13 years.
Regretfully, Amie Huguenard was with him. God rest her innocent soul. She seemed to be almost physically identical to Treadwell, but did not seem to share his affection for the grizzlies. Although this is the first time we see her, it was not her first trip to the Grizzly Sanctuary with Treadwell. This was also not a continuation of a summer expedition. They had gotten all the way to the airport, where Treadwell got upset and they decided to go back out. There were rumors she was considering leaving him, so what made her go back out? I guess we will never know. :(
Even though Werner Herzog begins his documentary seeming to want to recognize Treadwell for his efforts, he quickly begins to criticize his methods throughout the film, and even tries to manipulate his story even more by squelching the death recording. I think, if for some reason it was recorded, God or Fate has a reason for that, and it's not Werner Herzog's place to squelch it. (Unless he is simply threatened by it). But then, the "I am just a filmaker" Herzog is constantly advertising his personal beliefs (which many believe "delve into the Human Psyche") that are in no way proven or groundbreaking. Herzog is not Sigmund Freud, he really is "just a filmmaker" with a similar accent. He is certainly guilty of anthropomorphing (to the detriment of his film subjects). In "Happy People: A Year in the Taiga", he lamented about a "poor, mistreated" husky who was running beside his ower who was riding on a snow mobile. Does he not know that this is what Huskies are bred for? They LIVE to run! He seems to think that his owner is cruel, yet the dog is allowed to do the very thing it is perfectly equipped and born to do. Herzog just thinks every dog should, or wants to be a lap dog! But, in reaiity, Werner Herzog obviously knows very little about dogs.
I think Mr. Herzog made this film with a bit if underlying jealousy, a bit of "sour grapes" and an effort to ride the tail of Timothy Tradwell's star of fame, to boot!
It seems that Timothy Treadwell had, and developed, some major emotional and psychological problems, which sadly led to his (and Amy Huguenard's) death. In spite of this, he left some AMAZING nature footage and an understanding of Grizzlies never before seen. Some of it can be seen, however, in the regretfully limited 2008 series "The Grizzly Man Diaries". Whether or not one agrees with Timothy Treadwell's methods and "fall from grace", one cannot deny the amazing footage and beautiful scenes he captured and brought to all of us, including our children. Was Timothy Treadwell mentally imbalanced? Certainly. But often the imbalanced are gifted in extrordinary ways. And sometimes they are driven to share this with the world. Does VanGogh's missing ear or eventual suicide make his art any less beautiful? I think not. Give that one a watch, if you can.
0 out of 0 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends