Change Your Image
wrkcwnwnx
Reviews
Once I Was (2010)
Engrossing Drama and Recreates a Time That Was
This film is a success on several levels. First of all, it is an engrossing drama and coming of age story and second it recreates a time and place long gone. The coming of age story involves a 16 year old boy's contact with a warm hearted but slightly sleazy character from his father's youth. Perhaps I related to this young man because I too, at the age of 16, had a similar character in my life. And life after all, is about learning to deal with various situations, some of which have to potential to corrupt you, but all of which are learning experiences. Many films present a story, but do not give you a reason to care about the characters. This film fully develops the characters and, consequently, give you a reason to care about their outcomes. Some reviews have a criticized a sub plot involving a beautiful young women. Really, were you ever a 16 year old boy?. Is it possible to have a story about a 16 year old and not have sex in it?
I also liked the recreation of 1968 Israel, a place and time I never saw even though I was offered a summer kibbutz experience as a 16 year old in 1969. The Hebrew name of the film translates as "Once I was". The Israel of today, which I know well (I learned to speak Hebrew as an adult), is very different, in some ways better and some ways worse. I cannot speak for the authenticity of the recreation, but the film certainly captured some of the major conflicts in the society without ever devolving to into an anti-Israel film.
The original name was a good choice and is more descriptive. Overall, this film is a success as a drama and as an historical essay.
The Zionist Idea (2015)
Biased One Sided View of History
I won't repeat the excellent and thorough review above, except to state that this film is seriously defective and racist. According to the film maker, who I met this evening, he is trying to discuss the conflict from an Israeli view. However, he gives ample time to Arabs and does not balance their errors with corrective interviews, The general tone goes like this,"if the mature Jews would be nice to the Arab children, the children will be behave and we can all get along". It's all about what the Jews have done wrong. He states that there were no problems between Arabs and Jews until the Zionist arrived. Wrong. He states that the PLO/PA has recognized Israel. Wrong. He states that Israel needs to leave the west bank but does not state that the PA has rejected peace deals from three Israeli Prime Ministers. I could go on, but let me summarize like this, if you want to see a biased film which bashes Jews and never asks Arabs to take responsibility for their actions, then this is the film for you. If you want a film that examines the complexity of the Israeli-Arab conflict, or a film which looks at the complexity of internal Israeli conflicts and movements, look elsewhere.