I want to preface this review by saying I did not finish the final 40 minutes of this film. Take my review with a grain of credibility, but I think I saw enough warning signs to know this wasn't for me.
The Outwaters has to be one of the biggest disappointments in my life and that is not an understatement, i had been waiting to see this film since it's initial buzz and can't help but feel disconnected to cosmic and body horror, i was completely let down with the actual contents of the film despite having about 45 minutes left, i did not care. Maybe this is my fault for intentionally trying to keep the plot elements vague from finding out what happens.
The basic gist of the film is that a group of friends are going to help each other shoot some stuff in the desert because of them is an artist. I'm seeing a lot of reviews saying the initial set up is a tedious bore, but that was my favorite part of it all to be honest. Being a musician myself I just really loved seeing this group of friends DIY the hell out of a music video for their little indie singer friend. I even loved the volleying and (i'm guessing improvisational) banter, it's when we get to the third card that film completely goes in a direction I immediately lost interest.
I was intrigued for the first couple minutes of this sequence, unsettled even. The film opens strong and the third card was starting to show hints of that exact tension-building fear, and then *fart noise* ... it pooped the bed. Ultimately my interest and fear were evaporated as soon we see the leading events, I hate that I feel I could take this concept and do something better, I hate that I'm writing that in this review as if I know frick all about the hard work and ambition it took to make this, still, as a viewer I just did not vibe. I knew the mundane shots of curtains were a red flag but I kept going, my mistake.
The sound mix is also disappointing, there are several scenes where the group are spooked at night because of the sound of odd thunder, it sounds like a canon exploding. This isnt the problem, the problem is that it's supposed to be coming from outside of a tent in the middle of a desert and yet it sounds like the most flat, pasted on FX mp3 file in Post. I'm not sure how the sound was actually made, but I did not feel immersed and the atmosphere was just not there. It wasn't like the creepy baby crying in the Blair Witch Project, where it sounded so faint and coming from any direction. I just feel if half of the "scary" moments are coming from a pitch black screen and creepy noises, have those noises be the best noises ive ever heard, or at LEAST above the quality grade of a youtube video.
I guess while I'm talking bad about how cheap this feels I think one of the worst parts about the beginning of the film was showing me these earthquake scenes where the director is clearly just shaking the camera and then swinging a lamp before pressing record again to make it look like those lamps are reeling back and forth from these pesky LA tectonic plates. These types of mundane filmmaking ideas really bothered me because I don't want to feel smarter than the movie I am watching. I want to watch a movie completely puzzled and unnerved by how they pulled something off, so thank you The Outwaters for making me feel like a prick for thinking my imagination for this movie was better than what I got.
So at the beginning of the film we learn these "3 cards" were picked up and edited chronologically as raw evidence/footage for us to view right? Adding experimental shots and ominous background music does not make any sense and completely takes me out of that immersion. Like is that my fault that I wore such good headphones? Maybe this will work better for me on my busted 2014 Smart Tv? I hope one day I come around because I did see potential and that was the entire reason I had so much hype in the first place, it wasnt so much the word of mouth but how much i've been craving a found footage film that feels found.
Probably won't give this another chance even if a friend of mine absolutely insisted i watch the final 40-ish minutes, i just feel like I could see behind the curtain too many times. The weaknesses weren't hidden as well as i had hoped.
The Outwaters has to be one of the biggest disappointments in my life and that is not an understatement, i had been waiting to see this film since it's initial buzz and can't help but feel disconnected to cosmic and body horror, i was completely let down with the actual contents of the film despite having about 45 minutes left, i did not care. Maybe this is my fault for intentionally trying to keep the plot elements vague from finding out what happens.
The basic gist of the film is that a group of friends are going to help each other shoot some stuff in the desert because of them is an artist. I'm seeing a lot of reviews saying the initial set up is a tedious bore, but that was my favorite part of it all to be honest. Being a musician myself I just really loved seeing this group of friends DIY the hell out of a music video for their little indie singer friend. I even loved the volleying and (i'm guessing improvisational) banter, it's when we get to the third card that film completely goes in a direction I immediately lost interest.
I was intrigued for the first couple minutes of this sequence, unsettled even. The film opens strong and the third card was starting to show hints of that exact tension-building fear, and then *fart noise* ... it pooped the bed. Ultimately my interest and fear were evaporated as soon we see the leading events, I hate that I feel I could take this concept and do something better, I hate that I'm writing that in this review as if I know frick all about the hard work and ambition it took to make this, still, as a viewer I just did not vibe. I knew the mundane shots of curtains were a red flag but I kept going, my mistake.
The sound mix is also disappointing, there are several scenes where the group are spooked at night because of the sound of odd thunder, it sounds like a canon exploding. This isnt the problem, the problem is that it's supposed to be coming from outside of a tent in the middle of a desert and yet it sounds like the most flat, pasted on FX mp3 file in Post. I'm not sure how the sound was actually made, but I did not feel immersed and the atmosphere was just not there. It wasn't like the creepy baby crying in the Blair Witch Project, where it sounded so faint and coming from any direction. I just feel if half of the "scary" moments are coming from a pitch black screen and creepy noises, have those noises be the best noises ive ever heard, or at LEAST above the quality grade of a youtube video.
I guess while I'm talking bad about how cheap this feels I think one of the worst parts about the beginning of the film was showing me these earthquake scenes where the director is clearly just shaking the camera and then swinging a lamp before pressing record again to make it look like those lamps are reeling back and forth from these pesky LA tectonic plates. These types of mundane filmmaking ideas really bothered me because I don't want to feel smarter than the movie I am watching. I want to watch a movie completely puzzled and unnerved by how they pulled something off, so thank you The Outwaters for making me feel like a prick for thinking my imagination for this movie was better than what I got.
So at the beginning of the film we learn these "3 cards" were picked up and edited chronologically as raw evidence/footage for us to view right? Adding experimental shots and ominous background music does not make any sense and completely takes me out of that immersion. Like is that my fault that I wore such good headphones? Maybe this will work better for me on my busted 2014 Smart Tv? I hope one day I come around because I did see potential and that was the entire reason I had so much hype in the first place, it wasnt so much the word of mouth but how much i've been craving a found footage film that feels found.
Probably won't give this another chance even if a friend of mine absolutely insisted i watch the final 40-ish minutes, i just feel like I could see behind the curtain too many times. The weaknesses weren't hidden as well as i had hoped.
Tell Your Friends