Change Your Image
chaworth-1
Reviews
Saraband for Dead Lovers (1948)
Truly Stunning Forties Melodrama
This is one of the most beautifully made Technicolor melodramas of the 1940's which loses nothing in maintaining historical accuracy. Look out for simply stunning performances from Peter Bull as the heir presumptive to the British throne and, above all, Flora Robson as Countess Platen. Stewart Granger (Konigsmark) is in top form and Francoise Rosay as the Electress Sophia is unforgettable. Dialogue is razor sharp throughout, the costumes are splendidly authentic and the sets are magnificent. The only area of weakness is Joan Greenwood's Sophie Dorothea, but she is supposed to be playing a tragic victim and maybe that's why critics wrote her off as a wet lettuce. It is much to be regretted that Saraband is not more widely available.
Against the Crowd: Murrain (1975)
A Forgotten Classic
I saw this originally back in the 70s when it was shown as an early afternoon drama. It has been one of those plays that haunts you for life! It's probably very slow starting for today's youngsters, but is still definitely worth their viewing it. Production values may have changed but the atmosphere created is chilling and rises to a crescendo at the nailbiting end. The recreation of a Peak District village and its shop is probably more realistic than most youngsters will realise. The village oafs who are set on persecuting old Mrs Clempson are not too far off the mark either! Directors of the future should take note of the pathos injected into the scenes in the suspected witch's cottage - it would be good to have such drama on our screens today.
Kolberg (1945)
Was that it?
Kolberg's legendary status owes not a little to its unobtainability and complete absence from television. I have the distinct impression that the best of Veit Harlan's direction ended up on the cutting room floor as a panicking Dr Goebbels insisted on drastic revision before this thundering epic could be shown -should I say, inflicted on- the German public in the last days of WWII. There are some magnificent scenes of battles and the episode in the Kolberg town council chamber is brilliantly scripted and acted, but the something is very wrong about the way the final print was put together. Lead character Maria is a virtual stranger; the details of her trials and tribulations along with her affair with Schill have to be guessed at, as does much else. The sets throughout are splendid - but it's all a stage with nothing happening. Continuity is appalling. I understand that we are watching 1hr 45mins out of over 90 hours of footage taken and that all the negatives are lost. We will never know what we are missing.