Bull's team defies going through the motions at a client's Death Sentencing Hearing for a man Bull believes is innocent and go on the offensive by re-investigating the crimes.
After Elliott Miles (Frank De Julio) is convicted of two murders and arson, he is now facing the penalty phase of his trial. Bull's team must now see if they can convince the jury not to vote for the death penalty. This is made more difficult as none of their "shadow jury" algorithms apply to the penalty phase of a trial. Will Elliott be sentenced to death?