"The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel" Thank You and Good Night (TV Episode 2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Season One Review
southdavid26 January 2021
Acknowledging that it's better to show up late to a party, than never show up at all, we finally started Amazon's critical hit show "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel". (Another show that's going to bristle against my UK English spelling preferences). It is, as you might expect, "marvellous".

Miriam Maisel (Rachel Brosanhan) is a wife and mother in affluent New York in the late 1950's. She is supportive of her husband Joel's (Michael Zegan) dream, to become a stand-up comedian, despite his full-time job and lack of aptitude for it. When a slot goes badly, he packs a bag, tells her he's in love with his secretary and moves out of the family home. Drunk and miserable, Miriam ends up back at the comedy club and brings the house down with an improvised and honest routine. Susie Myerson (Alex Borstein) the club manager sees her true potential and tries to convince Miriam that she should be doing this professionally.

I really enjoyed this first season. Brosanhan is a compelling lead and I really liked the character of Miriam Maisel. Witty and charming, from the first episode she feels like a real person, privileged admittedly, but with personal flaws and who's trying to deal with a women's role in the 1950's (for example, she gets up before her husband and does her makeup, before getting back into bed to awake alongside him looking radiant). A different show might have abandoned the character of Joel after the pilot, but this doesn't, and we see the regret and disappointment pile up on him across the rest of the run. It's testament to the writing and to Zegan that despite his betrayal I never quite got to the point that I hated him. The wider family are all excellent, including both Miriam and Joel's parents, the fathers in which are the great Tony Shalhoub and Kevin Pollack. The second star role though is definately Alex Borstein's Susie Myerson, another wonderful smart and funny character, who plays off Brosanhan perfectly.

The show is funny, that's the key. Not just the standup, which generally is strong, but the interplay between the characters, which whilst definitely stylised is the real highlight. I really thought it was excellent and can't wait to crack on with season two.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Return of Joel
Hitchcoc17 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This is a wild episode. Suzie has betrayed the producer (in his opinion) and this has led to Midge having no prospects. She throws a birthday party for her little boy and, of course, Joel is there. Late that night they get together and make love. Joel is thrilled and believes they are getting back together. Suzie pulls some strings and gets Lenny to help rekindle Midge's budding career. But Joel is in for a big surprise when he stops at the record store where Midge buys comedy albums. As the first season ends, things are up in the air. By the way, every time Tony Shaloub is on the screen, things are hilarious. There is still a lot of Monk in this role. Look forward to Season 2.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Greatness!
gabrllcgs18 November 2020
Greatness of writing and directing (and acting and editing and...) Amy sherman was perfect with this season finale, you may try (and try hard) to find a mistake, but at the end everything is just perfect.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
[8.1] A badly dirty jewel
cjonesas15 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Episode 8: Good production value, nice setting, true "epoque" atmosphere, big acting and score, but not a pure comedy, not truly hilarious and dragging a bit again with nothing sensational happening.

It still doesn't quite know what it wanna do with itself, "la serie pietine enormement", moves at its own too slow pace, (only) does some bright drama semi-comical things along the way and in conclusion is not satisfying at all.

Quality and good acting don't always bring satisfaction. It lacks thrilling sensations, flow and "leaders" in its storyline.

Brosnahan does her best and shines solo as do the setting and atmosphere. The storyline plots not at all. The plots are near horrible as is the flow.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Very good in parts, not so good in others, and morally dubious
Jodro222 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
We've really enjoyed this series so far, apart from the Doink episode, which was kind of boink, but this episode left us with very mixed feelings. First of all, the entire section of Joel and Midge spending the night together was far too long, and entirely unnecessarily so.

Getting back together with Joel, if only for a night, also seemed inexplicably out of character for Midge, and gives the feeling that an on-off drama of Joel and Midge's relationship was artificially created by the script writer to create extra interest, which the series doesn't actually need.

Second, Joel beats someone to pulp towards the end. They guy had been boorish towards Midge, but nothing worse. In viciously beating him, Joel was clearly acting out his hurt over what Midge was saying on stage. But that does not make his action OK. There nonetheless appear to be no moral or legal repercussions of actions. So it's just another bit of American movie making in which the goodies can beat up or kill whomever they perceive as a baddy? It leaves a bad taste in the mouth.

Third, it seems that Midge is using her onstage act has a platform to have a go at people who annoy or upset her. First a famous fellow-comedian, then Joel, then in a later episode some other stand-ups in the room. Cue tons of jokes at the expense of others. While it is at times very funny, this also leaves a bit of bad taste in the mouth...
6 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Excruciating after 7 wonderful episodes
treyintexas26 March 2024
Wow. After thoroughly enjoying the first 7 episodes, this was painful to watch.

I thought this was a comedy.

This episode made me cringe pretty much throughout the entire episode.

One stupid scene after another.

Scenes with characters acting so completely out and of character it makes one wonder what the writer(s) were thinking. IF they were thinking.

If this is a permanent shift (from comedy to soap opera), I will be so disappointed (and won't continue watching).

The buildup of Midge's character over the first 7 episodes and we get THIS? Everything we thought about her just thrown out the window to follow some ridiculous storyline. Where is this going?

If I were watching this alone, I would have skipped to the next episode or just watched something else. Which, of course, made it even more painful because I was forced to watch the episode in it's entirety.

Please make it stop.

Please tell me this is a one-off issue.

Please do yourself a favor and skip this episode.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed