Apprentice (2016) Poster

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Shadow of the Noose
shaunjmaher20 June 2016
Warning: Spoilers
When deciding to see a prison movie you have already prepared yourself for a gritty, realistic experience. When you know it's a prison movie about an apprentice executioner, you have to prepare yourself to pre-mourn the dead men walking you are about to meet. But Apprentice doesn't focus on the prisoners; it's a story about the guards and how they manage to do the worst job in the world.

Aiman (Fir Raham) is drawn to small places. As a boy he would hide in a cupboard and as an adult he leaves the army for a job in the prisons. He's there to do good, and thinks he can help to change the prisoners. But his positive intentions can't stop his fascination with the Condemned Block. His attention is caught by the gate that bars his entrance and the men that work behind it. In particular the white haired Chief Executioner (Wan Hanafi Su) catches his eye, and as Aiman volunteers, ingratiates and manipulates himself into that world, The Chief becomes his Miyagi.

But there is no repetitive car waxing here. Death Row doesn't wait for laborious life lessons. However, just like Daniel Laruso, Aiman does have to learn new skills, and his relationship with the older man is the centerpiece of the movie. The Chief sees something of himself in young Aiman. He laments modern rules and regulations, knowing that leaders don't come from following the rule book and he likes that Aiman has some rough edges. They are both single and while the movie doesn't bother itself with any forced romantic subplots, we learn The Chief was married once but his job got in the way and there has been no-one since. His business card rarely goes down well at speed dating nights.

Apprentice doesn't delve into any extraneous relationships at all. Aiman lives with his sister, Suhailia (Mastura Ahmad), who provides a Jiminy Cricketesque presence for him, but even her boyfriend exists only on the blurry fringes of the frame. Everything about Apprentice is brutally efficient as the Singapore prison system.

The word 'gallows' is too elegant a word for what it describes. The journey across the double 'l's' over the 'o' and into the curve of the 'w' doesn't do justice to the trip the inmate takes from his cell to the door in the floor. Their Lord provides them comfort, but their legs often desert them and they need to be supported down the hallway,. But once the hood is on, it's mercifully quick. The Chief pulls the lever and we hear the snap right where it should for a perfectly executed execution.

Modern societies like to think they have evolved beyond the brutality of capital punishment, but this film doesn't make it a political discussion. Instead it's a personal question for the characters. When Aiman wonders whether one of the prisoners deserves to die for 'only' drug trafficking, The Chief isn't affronted because of his political or philosophical views, he takes it as an attack on his very existence. He has prided himself on fulfilling a vital role and doing it to the best of his ability. The rights and wrongs are not for him to decide.

While the characters don't spend too much time discussing the moral question of capital punishment, it's impossible for the audience to ignore. From the angle that Director Boo gives us, we often see the guards through windows and bars making them look a lot like prisoners themselves. But while they get to leave they are still tethered, only really free for the hours between their shifts, and even then it appears that the horrible shadow of the noose has them living like prisoners anyway.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Realistic Dark Drama
SameirAli22 February 2017
There are only a few films dealing with Hangmen. "Shadow Kill (2002) is such a film.

The film do not go though the usual cliché plots. This is entirely different.

A young correctional officer, Aiman is transferred to a top prison. Capital punishment by hanging is being conducted in that prison. He meets an executioner, Rahim, who was doing this job for more than 30 years. Aiman's father was executed by Rahim. This leads to tense drama in the movie. But, there is nothing obvious. There is a high tension, but it is subtle. There are emotions of the prisoners who are going to be hanged, their relationship with the executioner.

The only support of Aiman was his sister Suhaila. His loneliness in life is clearly depicted in the movie. It is very clear when we see the only contact in his mobile was Suhaila.

A very dark emotional drama, clean from all the cliché plots. A freezing end.

Highly recommended for those who are looking for different movies. A must watch.

#KiduMovie
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Learn the Ropes
nogodnomasters15 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Aiman (Firdaus Rahman) takes a job as a guard at a Malaysian prison. He lives modestly with his sister Suhaila (Mastura Ahmad) who dates an Australian man, John. Aimen befriends "the Chief" who is also the hangman and has been for thirty years. About twenty minutes into the feature we discover the Chief (Wan Hanafi Su) was the man who hung Aiman's father. Aiman complains to Suhaila on how she uses John to get away from her life in Malaysia while Suhaila complains about how Aiman can work in the prison that hung their father. The Chief asks Aiman to be his apprentice and "learn the ropes" pun intended. We wait to see how this plays out.

The film included universal themes as what we are willing to do to get by and to what lengths we can justify what we do. The ending was interesting...the irony of fate.

Guide: F-word. No sex or nudity. Good International film. English subtitles. Film includes 3 international wins.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The hangman
searchanddestroy-14 June 2016
I don't know how many films about hangmen, and only them, were made during movie history. I remind Jack Smight's TRAVELING EXECUTIONER back in 1970. But this feature from Singapore is a real hit in the face. It draws a portrait of those men, at least in this country where the capital punishment is hanging...It would be interesting to see how the hangmen in the USA proceed with the electric chair or the gas chamber... Anyway, you deal here with a powerful piece of work, accurate, astounding movie pulled by performances that I repeat hit you in the face. The struggle of a new prison guard who becomes the hangman's assistant, long time after his own father was himself executed by the same hangman. Those schemes about forgiveness, guilt or vengeance have already been told a billion times before, but this one, in this very feature, is absolutely unforeseeable. You can't expect what will eventually happen. Impossible. No clichés here. None of them. No bad guys or good ones. No cruel prison wardens or cold executioner scheme, on the contrary, everything is so human. So true. So real.

A real must see.
23 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Malay tale of Capital Punishment
t-dooley-69-38691623 April 2017
Aiman is 28 and works as a correction office or prison guard as we normally refer to them as. Then he gets transferred to the top 'nick' in the country and this is where they carry out the executions that they are so fond of doing there. Once there he meets Rahim who is charming and World wise. He is drawn to this man who has been the executioner for a long time and knows his craft.

Now as it turns out his father was executed some years before leaving him and his sister in dire straits and affecting them both forever. However, the attraction that Aiman has for Rahim and his special service is stronger than the revulsion and hence he goes on a journey of self discovery.

This is Malay but they speak mostly English but there are sub titles that you may need from time to time which are also quite good. The production values are actually really high and the acting is all top notch too. The story is a simple one but it is compelling and has enough dramatic attention to hold your attention. Recommended for World cinema fans.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Being a hangman
bel00130 October 2017
Strong and straight forward drama in which a young prison guard is trained by an old chief to be the next 'hangman'. Both the young guard as the old chief have their inner demons and strong difficulties in coping with the job. Being a kind of legal killer is not like another day in the office. It leaves marks. This film describes in a non-sensational way that those who actually have to execute the death penalty, die also a little bit inside with each hanging the system 'asks' them to do.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dark mentor-protégé relationship drama is gripping
shakercoola28 October 2018
A Singaporean drama; A story about a Malay corrections officer who embarks on a challenging new career as apprentice to the prison hangman. This simple revenge story transforms into a film with a theme on rage, guilt and acceptance. The story is effectively told with drip-feed revelations and a mounting tension as the plot takes the character into successively grim scenarios. Thematically, it is simple, however, and the film stops short of broaching the subject of legal killings or the one pertaining to the character.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good but not superb
blumdeluxe4 September 2018
Warning: Spoilers
"Apprentice" tells the story of a young man, who begins working in a prison and soon is discovered by the director, who wants him to serve duty in the death tract. What the director doesn't know, is that the young man's father once was hanged in the very same prison. Now he is facing a decision to become who he once hated or remain his integrity.

I like the general plot of the movie, even though it is hard to believe that nobody noticed the personal connection to this very prison in advance. And that really is the weakest point of the plot already. It is well played and believable that a young man would suffer and question himself under those given circumstances, but the reasons for him to chose this path in the first place are only very basically explained. That way there's always a voice in the head asking why he even got into this situation. Otherwise it is very professionally produced, delivers a lot of emotions and can't be criticized.

All in all this is a movie above average but it lacks the the last logical motivation to really become something outstanding. Definitely a film worth watching, though.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent
harrys1221 July 2017
If you love real movies where there is no bad and good when humans interact then you have to watch this film.

Treats the same theme of "el verdugo", for many the best Spanish film ever. The dilemmas of the executioner who struggles to convince himself that this is a job like every one else and someone has to do it. Needs guts to be a legal serial killer and sleep well during the nights without doubt.

Just see it and you will feel compassion, hate and frustration at the same time. When a movie makes you feel strong feelings, is a good movie.

Nothing else, a must watch.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Actually, the so-called prison execution is not the focus.
zlx_zjlq4 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Aiman seemed to be a very careful executioner, but his conscience and his real motivation to come to prison made him gradually see the reality. In fact, the so-called prison execution is not the focus of this film at all, family ethics is actually what the film is always discussed.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An good watch
chrisgallen-0762222 March 2020
I have just watched this film on BBC 4 and really enjoyed it. It makes no judgement for or against capital punishment, the rights or wrongs of those who carry it out. It a short, un-melodramatic film which sees all sides of the argument, the executioner, the family and the perpetrator. The end was ambiguous and slightly contrived but overall it was well made and well acted. I'm glad I watched it.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Mildly enjoyable, but not particulalry revelatory (and a poor ending)
frukuk20 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
While the apprentice seems to be the protagonist, the chief executioner is a much more interesting character and is played by a much more convincing actor. I felt I understood the motivation of the chief executioner, but not of the apprentice: if he was trying to get out from under the shadow of his father's crimes, why did he want to become the apprentice of the person who had executed his father?

Reduced rating from 3 out of 10 because of the poor ending.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
delicacy
Kirpianuscus18 October 2017
a delicate theme. brilliant script. fine performances. and the most inspired manner to explore the guilt, the past, the friendship, the duty. in essence, a water drawing. touching, precise, admirable for the courage to not be prisoner of clichés. because it is one of the admirable exploration of subjects who, very easy, could be traps for many directors. and occasion of fascinating meet between Wan Hanafi Su and Firdaus Rahman.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed