Vinyl (TV Series) Pilot (2016) User Reviews

"Music Alone is Worth Watching"

[mscairns58 · 8/10 · 15 February 2016]

I might have only been a young teenager in the 70's but I still remember the music and still play a lot of it to this day.

That being said it was just amazing to have a flood of good times and some not so good come rushing back, the acting was great and I found myself just getting into a character and then being rushed to another artist without really getting to know what was happening, also they had a lot of flashbacks and you had to really watch so you didn't get lost, but seeing as it was the first episode I hope they slow it down a bit so we can really get into the nity gritty.

The music was mind blowing and as I said before it made me think of what I was doing when these songs where just starting to hit the charts, and living in Australia we where behind the USA all the time but we still got a lot of the great hits.

I will be very interested to see how they continue with the next episodes and I really hope we get more of who,what,where and how these great artists came from and who was behind getting them to the top.

In closing I am looking forward to what comes next and see how they bring it all together and I would love for them to make these great people, not only the artists, but all the people behind them, make them human, I want to feel like they are real and not just something I could read about on a Fantail wrapper if you get my meaning.

I recommend watching if you are like me into the 70's and even the 80's music as there where so many great artist from that era that makes it worthwhile.

is anyone more creative in film about putting images to sound?

[Quinoa1984 · 9/10 · 3 March 2016]

What Vinyl highlights without beating around the bush is how much Martin Scorsese has it in his bones to put music to images, or images to music, however his process is. Working from material he developed with Mick Jagger (I wonder where he saw these things happening... probably everywhere), and Boardwalk Empire/Wolf of Wall Street collaborator Terence Winter, he sees material that is set in the world of the record industry and takes it by the balls. It's almost instinctual with him, along with his editor, to use pacing, every camera movement, every little cut or however BIG a cut might be, to create a dynamic and hair-raising pace. In this case the editor isn't Thelma Schoonmacher, and it shows that the flow isn't quite the same as with her, but it's still strong and propulsive in montage and how cuts overlap with music.

The story has a record exec (Cannavale) guiding us through what it takes to get things done... as kind of a loser in a lot of ways. He and his group (including a surprisingly funny Ray Romano) have to try and find a way to get Polygram - people from Germany no less - interested in their company. That's the spine for what is mostly a series of loosely connected scenes, and it jumps around a lot in time. We see how Richie (Cannavale) finds his footing (or tries to, and doesn't quite get there right away) in the early 60's with a black blues musician who he tries to groom into a pop star, and this is mixed in with the "present" day of 1973.

He's floundering in his attempts to make his position bigger, and he is interacting with real life figures (bigger than life, massively, like so much it is borderline distracting) like Robert Plant and Peter Grant of Led Zeppelin. The latter of those two, by the way, allows for one of those incredibly scenes of a screaming-horrible argument that unfolds like the best of Scorsese and Winter's scene: with wild comedic lines and such an over the top passion that it becomes part of the satire of it all (which it is, in some part I'm sure, and I think Jagger knows it as well).

It's a lot of characters to introduce, and some of them are surprises I should leave (my personal favorite, with only two scenes in this pilot only, was most surprising due to his other profession outside of acting, that's all I'll say). But Scorsese and Winter and company do a terrific job setting up the relationships for the characters - how hot and cold the marriage is between Cannavale and Olivia Wilde's character (see that scene with the bottle of booze, almost with no dialog, masterfully staged and performed) - and what the stakes are in the music industry at the time. There's this sort of crazy, almost bi-polar sense that while music is at its most creative peak here with so many different forms taking shape with punk rock, soul and funk (with the earliest inkling of hip hop), and of course the stuff that was the thing at the time (Led Zeppelin), while there's still the money people and the records to sell and everything that can (and still does) make the music industry so corrupted and abhorrent.

In other words, it's a little of the Boardwalk Empire approach of looking at history with characters who are amalgamations of other characters mixing with real people in a place of 'this is where things really change for an entire culture for people', while it displays just how immensely talented this filmmaker is with putting music to picture. How every song cuts together, whether people are performing them or it's just on the radio or backdrop, not a note is missed to get you in that mood of 1963 to 1973 in music. If nothing else, even if you don't find all the jokes work (most of them did for me), or if some of the characters are caricatures (Max Casella for one), it's hard to see the medium of film - more than TV as this works as a TV movie by itself really - used to its maximum, bloody, brutal potential.

Incredible first episode

[filmobsession94 · 9/10 · 11 November 2019]

Felt like the first part from a film series. Production values were insane. Performances, so good. My only problem was with a few of the secondary plot lines. A bit muddy, but will start making sense as the show goes on probably. I'm stoked. Can't wait to watch episode 2.

Scorsese Cranks up the Volume

[aciessi · 10/10 · 20 February 2016]

The long anticipated return of the Scorsese/Winter collaboration that gave us the genius of "Boardwalk Empire" and culminated with a new motion picture classic "The Wolf of Wall Street". They both return to tell the story of the dawn of the Punk scene in NYC, and the one record producer who saw it all. This Pilot episode recounts his fall from grace, and the moment in which his journey to redemption begins. From the early days of managing a blues singer, to the worst Led Zepplin deal of the century. Everything goes to hell by the end, only until he discovers the New York Dolls in a dingy rocker club. Just think, do you remember the time when you discovered a song that you really loved? The euphoria you felt? How you danced to it? Times that by a thousand, and you'll know how Richie Finestra felt.

This is a masterpiece of a film.. but it's not a film, it's the pilot to a new HBO series. To say that I'm hooked would be a total understatement. It just doesn't get any better than this. Scorsese and Winter are the duo of the decade. Just as we last saw them on "The Wolf of Wall Street", the editing, dialogue and storytelling is fast and loose. It's total chaos. Instead of sex and drugs, this time, it's music and drugs. It's vulgar, and proud of it. Bobby Cannavale is a damn hero. He is acting his heart out, with every last drag of his cigarette. Olivia Wilde shines as Richie's very beautiful, and very battered wife of his. Ray Romano is hysterical as Zak Yankovich, Richie's obnoxious head of promotions at American Century. The shining star of this episode, however, is Andrew Dice Clay as "Buck Rodgers", renowned radio owner and coke-binging psychopath. A climactic scene at Buck's house, which appears near the 90 minute mark of the pilot, is perhaps the funniest, craziest, musically genius scene i've seen since Dirk Diggler's drug deal in "Boogie Nights".

My praise doesn't get much higher than that. I'm ready for whatever this show is about to throw at me. Bring it on. Vinyl Rocks.

Marty as it's finest

[pablovete · 9/10 · 11 January 2020]

I've just seen the Irishman... nothing to say about that except that there's too much more of Marty on this pilot than in more than 3 hours Vibration, emotional, chaos, music, sex , drugs, violence , black humour -- let's say rock & Roll!! That's the way ( like Zeppelin's song ) Mr Martin Scorsese Great pilot !

Disappointing

[rubble-47469 · 1/10 · 12 March 2016]

I'm a very big fan of Martin Scorsese, but was very disappointed by this. I thought it was almost laughably bad. Didn't enjoy the pairing of music.

I also found the fictional stories about real musicians pretty ridiculous. I literally couldn't believe the cringe-worthy portrayal of Robert plant. One of the least commercial bands of all times (never released a single, didn't even give their first four albums titles, etc) because they believed that good music would speak for itself. To be reduced to scenes of Robert Plant almost bartering with stale characters (didn't like the Boston accent) for an additional 10%.

Either do fiction or don't. Don't do something in-between.

Pilot

[Prismark10 · 5/10 · 24 December 2016]

The pilot episode of Vinyl is an overlong affair. It is directed by Martin Scorsese who now has got to the habit of giving his movies superfluous running times.

Vinyl is also produced by Mick Jagger which explains how his son has a major role in the series, he certainly did not get the part through talent.

We are at a grungy, grainy 1970s. Part gangster, part Spinal Tap and part the fallen ruins from the hedonism of the 1960s but with a great soundtrack and some stylish scenes, especially if they involve music.

Record executive Richie Finestra (Bobby Cannavale) sits downhearted in his car, drunk, on drugs when the he sees some excited teens going to a club and he follows. He see the proto punk band The New York Dolls who certainly bring the roof down.

We have flashbacks to Finestra in the 1960s making his way to the top, trying to find acts that could make it big, he likes blues artists but they do not sell records unless they conform to pop sounding hits.

In the present he is trying to sell his record company to a big German corporation but they are only interested if Finestra signs Led Zeppelin but manager Peter Grant is having none of Finestra's crap.

Also his personal life is collapsing and there is a dead body to get lid off when an altercation gets too hot headed.

Scorsese in the pilot episode wants to unveil an epic saga, but outside of the music it was just not interesting enough. The episode mixes fact with fiction as you see Finestra talking to Zeppelin and then fake acts.

Violence, drug use, sex, corporate shenanigans (and modern vocabulary). We have the wild hedonism of the early 1970s, an interesting performance from Cannavale but it did not drag me in.