Lyle (2014) Poster

(2014)

User Reviews

Review this title
22 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Promising for periods, but doesn't live up to its creepy potential
cbarrass-evans5 August 2014
When a movie is offered free (and legally) online to stream, and is only an hour in length, it is usually worth a stab. I had previously seen the trailer, which was well put together and struck enough curiosity within me to jot down the date upon which it would become accessible online.

So, what is it about? In short, this movie is about grief, and the effects that traumatic events can have on the mind. It begins with our main character Leah (Gaby Hoffman) and her girlfriend June (Ingrid Jungermann) being shown around an impressive New York apartment, with which they are clearly pleased. They have with them a toddler, and the witting building manager Karen (Rebecca Street) guesses that Leah is pregnant with another, a feat that Karen herself is openly trying to achieve.

Leah and June seem happy with their new life in New York. June is busy at work and on the road to success, whilst Leah is at home with the toddler unpacking their lives into their new home. There is, however, an event that turns their lives around. Although it is openly available on the short Synopsis, I will refrain from mentioning the details. This event is portrayed in a very clever way, again which i refuse to disclose (although I will say that it is a very original idea, utilising modern communication methods).

With this traumatic event, we see Leah's mind begin to unravel. She becomes suspicious of those around her, notably the building manager, and her paranoia gradually escalates into a final scene that is very well composed.

However, despite the film's unusually short length, there are periods in which one wonders in which direction the film is going. This is countered, it should be noted, by a good score which retains the film's eeriness throughout these moments in which the film seems to be petering along without purpose. Another essential distraction from this flaw in the narrative is the acting of Hoffman, who at times seems very accomplished indeed. There are moments when she perhaps gets carried away with the high-emotion scenes, but nonetheless her performance is a mile apart from most of her supporting cast (notably poor are Michael Che and Kim Allen, who play a friend of the couple and a neighbour, respectively, and fail to really portray emotion at any time during the film. This is particularly so in Che's case, in the final scenes of the film).

All in all, Lyle is an optimistic venture into the grief of the human mind, ultimately let down by its lack of direction and poor supporting acting. An interesting point for debate is whether writer/director Stewart Thorndike could have added ten or twenty more pages of screenplay, to try and flesh out some of the ideas throughout the movie which do not enjoy the focus that they deserve. Nonetheless, it was an adventurous film, and it hits home just well enough to make the viewer keep an eye on whether his new film will reach its Kickstarter target.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
It was just ok
Psy-Ko13 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Didn't hate it, didn't love it. Just ok. I just felt they could have done so much more with it. The landlady, at first she thinks shes behind it all but then at the end it's shown she wasn't even a part of it as shes led away being asked you always wanted a baby of your own didn't you. Would have loved to have seen a "one year later" showing the landlady rocking a baby.

The beginning was boring and weird, then it got interesting and had a bit of tension, but the ending just lacked. A bit more in the middle about these so called deals would have been great. So would an ending where we know if she got out of there or not. I know, people say these kind of movies are so you can make up your own mind but I don't want to. When I sit down to watch a movie I want the film maker to tell me a story. One that includes a beginning a middle and an ending.

5/10 won't bother seeing it again
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fresh take on a familar theme
youngcollind30 April 2021
A well made film with an obvious plot debt to Rosemary's Baby. I can't say the RB genre is over saturated just yet, so it was still a fun watch.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Leaves you in doubt
blumdeluxe14 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Lyle" tells the story of a middle-aged lesbian couple that moves to a new apartment with their young daughter Lyle. When Lyle becomes the victim of a terrible accident, it soon becomes questionable if all just happened out of hazard or there's a more sinister plan behind it. Who can be trust anymore?

The movie is of high production value for an independent film. I didn't feel so excited about the first half of the film but I have to say that the pace picked up and the tension started to rise in the second one. In my opinion, some of the mysteries could have been extended as they happen to come a bit out of the blue, the movie is rather short, so that wouldn't have been much of a problem. Nevertheless it is a film that keeps you guessing until the very end and at a certain point you can well adopt to the otherwise rather traumatized character.

All in all this is one of the better independent movies within the genre. There is still some potential for improvement but especially the second half of the film is highly entertaining and will keep you caught in front of the screen.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Lyle
sandraslife20 July 2020
I enjoyed this movie, but I found it drew inspiration from the Original Rosemary's baby, starring Mia Farrow. Not as good, but still interesting to watch. It does meander at times, but there is some excellent acting, and the final scene is gut wrenching. I'd recommend it.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not worth the money.
zero_destiny_09 September 2014
This movie masquerades under the guise of woman-driven horror movie, but the reality, as they say, cannot be farther from the truth. This clumsily shot film centers around a main character, a pregnant lesbian woman, who loses her toddler when said toddler falls out a window. She then spirals downward into deepening insanity as she is determined to protect her unborn child from everything and everyone, and everyone, she thinks, is out to get her.

It sounds like a fair premise, but the way it is told is very poorly done. The story is dull, hold no rhythm, and makes no sense. There is no rhyme or reason to her thought process or actions; even insanity must give some kind of twisted reason, but in this movie there is none of that. It tries to go into a five minute introduction to perhaps some kind of supernatural deal with the devil, but without explanation or further study it becomes pointless and confuses the viewer.

As a horror movie, Lyle fails in a spectacular fashion. There are no scares, at all. There are no jump scares, no psychological thrill, and, perhaps worse of all, not even a single tense moment. The boring camera views and bleak colors do nothing to help this movie either.

I am sad I wasted my time viewing this during free time better spent on virtually anything else. I would not give a single dollar to their next movie if this is the best they have to show for their lazy, half-baked efforts.
12 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Slow but good effort
aratron-003913 January 2022
This film borrows elements from two films - Antichrist and Rosemary's Baby. Gaby Hoffman does a good job and her performance is strong. The actress that plays the land lady does a good job being creepy. I thought the score was pretty eerie setting the stage for the coming dread.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Well shot time waster
Leofwine_draca3 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
LYLE is a well shot time waster seemingly filmed on a micro budget in a single apartment in New York. The story is about a woman traumatised by the accidental death of her child, a trauma which leads her to become paranoid and withdrawn, convinced that her neighbours are out to get her. When she falls pregnant, events begin to spiral out of control.

If this all sounds a bit like ROSEMARY'S BABY then that's because it is very much a copy of the Polanski film, however it's a weak imitation at best. This is an indie film with nothing in the way of production values and no incident in the plot either. The main actress is pretty effective but that's not really enough to hold the viewer's attention for an hour or so. The realistic filming style is pretty decent and adds a level of dull realism to the production, but the cop out ending reinforces the impression that this is a waste of time.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Decent concept that doesn't quite produce
jmbovan-47-1601736 July 2020
Staying within its indie roots, this movie is well made (at that indie level) and decently acted. But, the concept becomes cornered within its own plot leaving the film without a fuller execution. Leah becomes unhinged after the death of her daughter Lyle while pregnant with her second. She descends into paranoia judging ever person and act as out to harm her, or her unborn baby, or caused the death of Lyle. . Gaby Hoffman plays Leah well even if at the end the role only demands her to be "crazy". The 60 or so run time feels warranted, not trying to extend a concept past its limits and at the same time it left me with some unfulfilled aspects.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Confused priorities.
shannon-bill12 January 2023
There's nothing wrong with another take on the classic Rosemary's Baby story. I know some folks get all precious about these things but it's a brilliant concept for a movie and if you get the characters right, if the building becomes a character in its own right and if you have a decent writer it could be a no-brainer. Here however the writing let us down. Too little happened and the creepy happenings were too trite and too few. The sense of dread was not sustained and the tension was lacking.

Add to this the trendy and becoming hackneyed decision to make the main couple a pair of lesbians of the non-lipstick variety and patience begins to wane. They weren't fun to look at and I'd dare call them Wal-Mart lesbians. The lead character went so far as to eschew makeup and leave her armpits au natural. This is unappealing, unappreciated and wholly unnecessary.

This was a lackluster attempt at horror. It could've and should've been better but production was more concerned with virtue signaling and getting the racial quotas correct that they neglected the end product.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
More people need to see this amazing film
Nconiendo5 July 2017
First of all, this film has a 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes which is basically unheard of and should tell you something. Also, if you read any of my reviews I live for indie horror films and I can be brutal in reviewing them but when I love something I get really excited. This is a movie to get excited about. Gaby Hoffman is so terrific and real and raw and crazy you can't take your eyes off of her. Is it like Rosemary's Baby? Sure, yes, but it's also different. And let's face it, every story is just a retelling of a story that came before it, and that's that. Nothing can be original anymore. But if they had done this film wrong, that would have been a shame. Instead this movie is wholly satisfying and entertaining.
11 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This is a very well done 1 hour and 2 minute low budget feature
kevin_robbins9 May 2022
Lyle (2015) is a movie currently available on Tubi. The storyline follows a woman who recently moved with her partner into a new apartment building. Shortly after moving in her son passes away. In her grief she does some research on the building and uncovers a trend of babies dying there. Her paranoia becomes greater and greater partially as she finds more evidence and partly because of her pregnancy hormones as she's preparing to have another baby. Could there be a satanic cult in her hotel that wanted her son and may want her next baby too or is it all in her mind?

This movie is directed by Stewart Thorndike in his directorial debut and stars Gaby Hoffmann (Field of Dreams), Ingrid Jungermann (See You Next Tuesday), Rebecca Street (Jawbreaker) and Kim Allen (Violent Tendencies).

This movie has a strong modern day Rosemary's Baby feel to it. The characters are very interesting and the circumstances are well presented. The horror elements are subtle to the very end and then exceed expectations. The acting by Hoffmann was solid and the party scene was very well executed. I enjoyed the very ending and how circumstances played out.

Overall this is a very well done 1 hour and 2 minute low budget feature. I would score this a 7/10 and strongly recommend it.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Another Rosemary's Baby
sheilacranmer9 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I don't know how this movie ever got 100 percent on Rotten Tomato. It's just another Rosemary's Baby but the original is much better. I do have to give Gaby Hoffman 100 percent for her acting. That's the only good thing to say about Lyle.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Satan wants you
BandSAboutMovies22 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Directed and written by Stewart Thorndike, this is about Leah (Gaby Hoffman) and her girlfriend June (Ingrid Jungermann) have fallen in love with a New York City apartment building and that love - just like whatever once existed between them - seems to fade after the sudden death of their young daughter Lyle (Eleanor Hopkins). Soon, Leah is nearly left to deal with her rush of paranoid feelings, particularly her belief that the landlady Karen (Rebecca Street) is behind multiple child sacrifices. Karen also pretends to be pregnant, even if she's much too old for it.

Coming after Rosemary's Baby but before the Q-Anon and Pizzagate stories of Democrats drinking the blood of babies - even if that came from a long tradition of antisemitic stories - and five years before the occult-rich The Scary of Sixty First, And hey - there's Michael Che!

This movie is 65 minutes long, a length that all movies should aim for. That doesn't mean that this isn't a slow burn that gets agonizing and shows you that Gaby Hoffman is a long way from Uncle Buck.

I have had times in my life where my belief that everyone is out to get me has been proven correct and this movie reminded me of the sheer rush of sweat and terror when people are unmasked.

Is it easier to accept that a Satanic cult is all around you than the fact that your child has died as the result of a whim of fate? Your answer to this question will tell you how much you understand the crutch that conspiracy has become.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Lo-fi effort commendable to an extent, but...
MrGKB3 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
...that's not enough to necessarily prompt a recommendation, if that makes any sense. Gaby "Field of Dreams" Hoffman, portrays her protagonist role with reasonable credibility, but truthfully she's still a pale shadow compared to obvious predecessors like Mia "Rosemary's Baby" Farrow and Lee "The Omen" Remick. The rest of the cast doesn't register terribly well, either, and I'll not comment further about that on the basis of discretion being the better part of criticism.

No, as is almost always the case, "Lyle"'s problems boil down to the script, in this instance by its tyro director. The plot is little more than a secularized retelling of the above-mentioned films cloaked in a meaningless lesbian domesticity, involving characters so sparsely sketched as to be virtual ciphers, mere placeholders. In short, there's little to make us care about them, to draw us into Leah's increasingly paranoiac situation. We've seen all this before, and "Lyle" offers nothing new to entertain us, or frighten us, or illuminate us in any way. An extra twenty minutes of backstory and/or character development might have helped; I really don't know. Conversely, twenty minutes trimmed might have produced a tighter, tauter story with some genuine tension, tension that "Lyle" lacks almost completely.

I have to look at this one as a vanity project, a learning exercise that never really shook off its developmental shackles and fully breathed, a premature birth, perhaps, in service to some greater, yet frustratingly ambiguous goal.

Unless you're a fan of one of the actors or the production crew, "Lyle" is regrettably dispensable.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
What a waste
chanin-5461627 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This movie was clearly going for a Rosemary Baby feel, poorly. At only an hour long thins movie drags. No real explanation to anything, and no real build in tension. Trying to go for an is she crazy or not only works if you give us something to work with. Which they don't. Minor things here and there that don't add up to how the main character is feeling and acting. Is there really a deal with the devil or has she just gone crazy with grief? We will never know, mostly because I think the writers don't even know. Skip this one and watch Rosemary's baby instead.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Pregnant woman is pregnant
thefabmasterbats8 December 2023
Pretty good little flick, given its runtime of 1hr 2mins. I've seen movies where I wished the opening titles were the closing credits, not the case here.

Performances were a bit uneven, however the lead, Gaby Hoffman was quite good at playing her character Leah.

I can't give much praise for actor director. Ingrid Jungermann, her performance seemed 'stiff' but am curious to see her directorial debut, Women who Kill.

Not sure if this was meant to be psychological or supernatural or if that was the point of it. Being vague. I'm leaning psychological because pregnant women can get kinda kooky lol.

I don't want to make any comparisons or give anything away, but just say that I enjoyed my hour with this flick.

4 generous stars.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
True horror is revealed
edeninvsvs29 September 2019
This is a slow burn movie...I enjoyed it. Along the lines of Rosemary's baby with a modern feel. Great acting from the lead.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Internet witchery
edgeofreality2 October 2020
Solidly made, engrossing, pleasantly short modern horror fable, updating Rosemary's Baby to our seemingly more enlightened times to show that evil doesn't change. The most chilling scenes take place online, which says a lot about the current state of humanity. Main actress is memorable, but the villains lack charisma.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A True Great Indie
namaste_u31 October 2021
I love indie films and this one delivers (no pun intended!).

Great acting from everyone: suspense, cinematography, atmosphere, editing, everything!

Just wish we we had more...!

Definitely, recommend, and happy I found it on Amazon, Halloween 2021!
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Who ARE the users on this site??
DarknessVisible2016 July 2022
The low reviews for many of the brilliant movies on this site are insane, and truly perplexing, including this one. Who is on here?? 12 year olds???? Another brilliant and underrated thriller, underrated by goofballs who wouldn't know a good movie if it clocked them in the face.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Deeply disturbing
jeffcostudent30 September 2023
The score, the acting and the filming...all incredibly dread inducing. The plot is not unpredictable, especially if you are familiar with classic horror. But that doesn't stop it from evoking profound discomfort, especially for anyone with kids.

The film starts off with the familiar discomfort of being singled out for your sexuality, by someone who you don't know particularly well and who is just a little too prodding. But it quickly ratchets up from there into a never-ending nightmare of grief, paranoia and the disintegrating relationship between two people who once loved each other. Not since watching The Descent and experiencing second-hand claustrophobia from the scenes in the caves, have I been so physically affected by a horror movie. It feels more like a fleshed out short film than a feature picture, but the concept is so simple, the exposition so concise and the tension so unbearable, that the curtailed length serves the film rather than detracts from it. I only wish more horror movies committed to a shorter, more impactful story like this one.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed