Sukhodol (2011) Poster

(2011)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Russian serfdom treatment in 19th century = Russian tedium BUT painterly visuals treat.
Bofsensai2 August 2022
If - as likely - unfamiliar with the nation's book on which this is based
  • (as adapted by the director, Alexsandra Srelyanaya) - might be better to
know that this is more about the 'Happenings to the servants in Dry Valley' ...

Since:

Typical in its way of Russian style of long, languid, seemingly do nothing shots and prolonged portentousness - almost photographically still in some shots of the characters involved* - yet out of which come some gorgeous painterly (sorta T. Malick) like countryside tableaux: in one mesmerising instant, involving a bride opining on her future, seemingly only natural light lit by her surrounding fellow flamelight holding women, is simply superb and reminiscent of Peter Greenaway's natural light treatments e.g.

In a similar candlelit set up in his the 'Draughtman's Contract'. Then soon after you get an astonishing dark into light effect almost a la Lynch in 'Lost Highway' which with that also being reminiscent of the well worn horror genre trope (it's behind you!), would there creepily thrill, as main actress Yana Esipovich** gently looms out of the darkness to answer her mistress. (**and being at age c. 21, yet portrays a far younger girl's naivete most believably.)

Hence, throughout what is otherwise a rather mundane story of how the Nineteenth century rich / landed ("nobility") elite (the owner is in the military) contemptuously treated their serfs, you'll be treated to some beautifully naturally lit shots, *in which some well chosen 'faces of character' - no doubt selected deliberately so by director Alexsandra, rather than for any acting - as oft seem cast to remain still and/or impassive, plus with their being also costumed pretty well too, in all their drabness.

Slow, meandering, but still, overall, visually delightful.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent modern Russian cinema.
musashi-1917 October 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Like many Russian movies from a wonderful new wave impressed by Tarkovsky, "The Dry Valley" is a visual delight. Angles making landscapes come alive, lens focuses bring colors and interest to levels of a Grand Master's painting.

The plot summary misses the movie severely. The initial dialogue establishes the whole movie as a look back on youth and coming of age by a woman well on in years. Look at her hands! Some very humorous insights to the human conditions of 19th century Russia are subtly addressed with a young woman and her uncle's observations of the fictions communities will develop to explain and endure their country existences. Respecting the various religious inclinations of many people is handled with grace and humility. The exorcism scene is truthful to the Eastern Orthodox traditions, as are the gentle acceptances of individual uniqueness. It is wonderful to see Yana Esipovich extend her quite capable acting to more extensive investigations, than certainly you saw in "The Island", also a spirituality dominant film. Watch this one several times, as you would a Tarkovsky film. Director and Writer Alexandra Strelyanaya shows impressive depth in her insights and directing.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Stunning Film!
mchenrykrm16 September 2016
Being a fan of Russian film this one really hit the mark. The beautiful scenery, believable characters, excellent acting and compelling story was outstanding.

The lead actress was excellent as the simple village girl. The story line drifts from mystical to seemingly mundane but it captures 19th century Russia just a I would envision it was.

I confess that the plot was difficult to follow at times but overall I got it and I plan to watch again to catch the things I missed. It will be a pleasure to view again.

Bravo!
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed