Shifting the Blame (2012) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A gem!
kellybubble27 January 2013
Warning: Spoilers
"Shifting the blame" is a film that moves you. It is predictable, yes, because you know where it will lead most of the time...BUT...you have no idea what the journey's going to be like. This is the point of the film. It isn't about the one thing that happens but about the people that are affected by it and their reactions to it. Simply put, it's a movie about someone's life and the people around that person.

The story is intriguing because we only get a small glimpse into this person's life. We don't get a beginning nor an end, only the in-between. We get to see part of the life of juvenile delinquent Benjamin. The movie begins with the one action he carries out and then it quickly moves on. In prison Benjamin is approached by a social worker, Niklas. Because of his young age he's considered not a lost cause and that there is a chance of him being able to turn his life around. This is what the social worker offers Benjamin - a way of making amends for all of his wrongdoings and to make something of his life.

Benjamin takes the offer because he doesn't want to be in prison. He arrives at the new place and starts off as the same jackass delinquent he was before but he soon finds his place in the community Niklas has created for him and his likes. He's changing his ways and becoming a better and happier person...

Then past makes its presence known and everything is turned upside down for Benjamin. Once more he has to find his footing in the community that was once his safe haven but now only brings him feelings of guilt and regret. This emotional journey of his is one of two parts of the movie.

Benjamin soon realizes that life can't go on without a confession or without him standing up for what is right - no matter the consequences - and that him making amends is his only shot at a new life. Whether he will seek forgiveness or be granted it, you will have to see for yourselves...

The lead role is played by Edin H. It's his first feature film, his first leading role, and he really delivers. Benjamin's feelings are beautifully portrayed by Edin - be it by a small gesture, his way to breathe or by one simple look. You feel his pain as if it was your own.

The second lead is the social worker's wife Eva, a woman who is still suffering from a certain event in her past and who is trying to move on but simply can't. Her emotional journey is the other part of the movie. Their separate journeys are connected to a secret that ties them together against both of their wishes.

The actress playing Eva is amazing as well. Her emotion, her reactions to what is happening right in front of her is almost eerie in a way. But you understand her, you root for her as well, and you wish them both peace of mind and heart.

What I love about the characters is that none of them are plain evil or plain good. They are versatile and very human. They all make mistakes and their actions are colored by their pasts like with any real life person.

It's a beautiful movie with interesting characters and interactions between people. There are some beautiful portrayals. A real gem!
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Solid from start to finish
Horst_In_Translation20 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
"Shifting the Blame" is a German movie from 3 years ago that runs for slightly over 90 minutes. The director is Lars-Gunnar Lotz and writer is Anna Prassler. Both are not particularly experienced yet looking at their bodies of work, so it is definitely a positive surprise how their collaboration here turned out. This is about a young man who is in prison, but gets the chance to switch to open prison if he joins a group in which he has to work on his approach to life and people. In there, he meets a woman who was the victim of a crime he committed that has never been solved. So of course the woman does not know who she has contact with due to her work. More emotion is added with the woman losing her unborn child during the attack back then.

The biggest question about this film was if she will ever gonna find out and if so, how will she react? I thought this was only predictable to some extent and anyway, predictability does not have to be something negative necessarily in my opinion. This film scored some nominations during awards ceremonies all over the planet. The most notable may be the German Film Awards where young lead actor Edin Hasanovic did not receive the award, but made it into the field of three nominees. Prassler was also nominated there for her screenplay. All in all, the only criticism that I can think of is that I did not feel there were any really outstanding moments in terms of emotion or the story, even if they aspired to include these. Nonetheless, this is a pretty good film overall and I recommend the watch. Thumbs up.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Quite boring and predictable
tstavrakis3 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this film in the Film Festival of Thessaloniki. I like watching German Films, "Lolla Rent" and "Das Leben Der Anderen" were masterpieces. This film is not something great. One young criminal was arrested and took part in a modern project of punishment in a house in the forest. One of his victim works in this facility. That's the main story. You can predict the ending. The movie characters are flat , the directing is not something special, and the ending is disappointing. This film is about forgiveness and punishment. The main story could let in a extremely film, but in this movie, this story goes "wasted". The only interesting for me was this project of punishment, which I found very interesting and good for the society, although sometimes it does not lead to good results.
4 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed