El rati horror show (2010) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
The most harmful form of stupidity.
rodriguez-habdia24 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
excuse the bad English, pls!

Reading a bit about this documentary I found a synopsis of it, written for the screening on the BAFICI (Buenos Aires Festival International de Cine Independietne), that ends with a phrase that roughly translates to English as "corruption is the most harmful form of stupidity".

Enrique Piñeyro, often referred as the "Argentinian Michael Moore", did a documentary on a doubtful case of a shooting a the "bonaerense" neighborhood of Nueva Pompeya. Some cops (dressed as civilians) shot (and almost killed) an innocent man, who is now in jail accused on charges of robbery, and homicide of three people. Piñeyro works on the "irregularities" of the case; the lack of convincing evidence, lack of witnesses, etc, in an (great) effort to throw some light in a very difficult case of police corruption/brutality. Some time ago I read, here in IMDb, a review of a guy complaining on a documentary done with an "political agenda" (which means nothing less than a director trying to prove something), and I thought, a documentary is like a thesis, you begin with an hypothesis, you do some research, and then, you use the research you have done to prove (or not) your initial hypothesis, that's the way this documentary is done. A lot of resources (backstage, special effects, recreation, etc), the unbreakable conviction of pursuing justice of the author, and his particular mix of humor and cynicism makes this one into a great, interesting, and very well executed documentary.

I sincerely recommend you; try to watch this movie. You will not regret. Thanks, I hope I'd been helpful!
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Discovering a whole new world
manuelvarelac2 June 2015
I've seen tons of movies and read many critics in IMDb, but this is the first time I find a film so touching that leads me to write an opinion about it. On start, "Rati" is a pun: it means "Tira" ("Shoots") written backwards; a funny name for cops, referred to their unofficial motto "shoot first, ask later". The title summaries the whole film, a journalistic documentary, well carried and with the director as protagonist. Piñeyro takes a journey through irregularities, lies and the horrific plot around the famous case of Fernando Carreras. Conclusions perfectly illustrate the reality of Argentina's police and the concept of "justice" that prevails in some state institutions, shown with both humor and indignation. Mixed with TV reports, interviews and real images of the trial, this piece of art constitutes a rarity: a political but objective film, mixed with breathtaking moments, where no artificial ingredients are needed since truth prevails by its own weight.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed