Jakyô no machi
- Episode aired Apr 19, 2009
- TV-14
- 24m
IMDb RATING
7.7/10
2.6K
YOUR RATING
Science and faith collide when the Elrics confront Father Cornello. He claims to work miracles, but the brothers suspect him of abusing a Philosopher's Stone to manipulate his flock.Science and faith collide when the Elrics confront Father Cornello. He claims to work miracles, but the brothers suspect him of abusing a Philosopher's Stone to manipulate his flock.Science and faith collide when the Elrics confront Father Cornello. He claims to work miracles, but the brothers suspect him of abusing a Philosopher's Stone to manipulate his flock.
Romi Park
- Edward Elric
- (voice)
- (as Paku Romi)
Rie Kugimiya
- Alphonse Elric
- (voice)
Laura Bailey
- Lust
- (English version)
- (voice)
Charles C. Campbell
- Cray
- (English version)
- (voice)
- (as Charles Campbell)
- …
Bruce Carey
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
Chris Cason
- Gluttony
- (English version)
- (voice)
Colleen Clinkenbeard
- Rose Thomas
- (English version)
- (voice)
Justin Cook
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
Jason Douglas
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
Hisao Egawa
- Cray
- (voice)
Scott Freeman
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
Cris George
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
Jessie James Grelle
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
- (as Josh Grelle)
Yûki Hayashi
- Older Member D
- (voice)
- (as Yuki Hayashi)
Muriel Hofmann
- Edward Elric (Animax Asia dub)
- (English version)
- (voice)
Jeremy Inman
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
Kikuko Inoue
- Lust
- (voice)
Jeff Johnson
- Additional Voices
- (English version)
- (voice)
- Directors
- Writers
- All cast & crew
- Production, box office & more at IMDbPro
Storyline
Did you know
- TriviaEnglish episode title: City of Heresy
- Quotes
Edward Elric: You'll have to decide for yourself. Walk on your own. Move forward. You've got a strong pair of legs, Rose. You should get up and use them.
Featured review
A Perfect Encapsulation of My Biggest Problems with FMAB
To be frank, this episode is a tonal mess. If the show wanted to go for a more comedy-centric episode after the beautifully dark and emotionally poignant flashback the episode prior, I would've been totally fine with it. Instead, it clumsily attempted to cram in a tragic story of a woman whose desperate faith (inspired by an event similar to the catalyst of the Elric brothers' quest) caused her to be manipulated by a corrupt religious organization. It's nearly impossible to successfully ride the line between comedy and tragedy, and due to the repetitive nature of the show's comedic style (ie. The already tired "Ed is short" and "Al isn't the Fullmetal Alchemist" jokes) it failed to do so spectacularly for me. There was absolutely no subtlety in the transitions between chibi animations/goofy scenarios and a heartbreaking tale of this woman tormented by grief and false promises. For me they broke immersion in the dramatic scenes, and just weren't funny enough on their own to merit that. As a result, none of the emotional moments felt earned or held any weight. A show that accomplishes this effectively for me is Avatar: The Last Airbender. If comedic moments are interspersed between dramatic ones, they are fleeting and don't draw the viewer out of the conflict at hand. To put it bluntly, they're also quite a bit more creative and genuinely funnier than those displayed here.
But the problems don't stop there. Half of the dialogue is just rehashing material from the previous two episodes (the Elric brothers' committing of the taboo, the properties of the philosopher's stone, etc.), and it came off as incredibly clunky. There were also several moments of logical inconsistency in the dialogue. For one, when the brothers first arrive in town, the townspeople claim to know nothing about alchemy. They're only familiar with Cornello's "miracles" and are bewildered by Alphonse's repair job of the stall owner's radio. But suddenly, after they reveal their identities everyone is familiar with the brothers and their fame in the realm of alchemy? I'm curious if this is explained better in the manga (perhaps a result of brainwashing in some fashion), but regardless it makes little sense in context. In addition, even after conversing with a seemingly omnipotent deity that stole his brother's body and a couple of his limbs (and revealed untold alchemical secrets to him), Ed is apparently still completely unwilling to give any credence to belief in religion in his conversation with Rose. In part because of this, the commentary on religious corruption, faith, and mob mentality felt ham-fisted and lacked depth. Coupled with a secondary antagonist that's cartoonishly evil and is dealt with in comedic fashion in the end, any potentially poignant commentary fell through.
I still give it a 4/10 due to the stellar animation in the fight scenes, delightful art style, intriguing conclusion, and fantastic score. But all in all this is an incredibly disappointing episode that could've been so much more with a bit of retooling. The same could be said for the show as a whole honestly, although I wouldn't go so far as to say it's incredibly disappointing. It's still a very solid show with so much going for it to make up for its flaws. I'm just not convinced that it's the absolute pinnacle of shonen, let alone anime as a whole.
But the problems don't stop there. Half of the dialogue is just rehashing material from the previous two episodes (the Elric brothers' committing of the taboo, the properties of the philosopher's stone, etc.), and it came off as incredibly clunky. There were also several moments of logical inconsistency in the dialogue. For one, when the brothers first arrive in town, the townspeople claim to know nothing about alchemy. They're only familiar with Cornello's "miracles" and are bewildered by Alphonse's repair job of the stall owner's radio. But suddenly, after they reveal their identities everyone is familiar with the brothers and their fame in the realm of alchemy? I'm curious if this is explained better in the manga (perhaps a result of brainwashing in some fashion), but regardless it makes little sense in context. In addition, even after conversing with a seemingly omnipotent deity that stole his brother's body and a couple of his limbs (and revealed untold alchemical secrets to him), Ed is apparently still completely unwilling to give any credence to belief in religion in his conversation with Rose. In part because of this, the commentary on religious corruption, faith, and mob mentality felt ham-fisted and lacked depth. Coupled with a secondary antagonist that's cartoonishly evil and is dealt with in comedic fashion in the end, any potentially poignant commentary fell through.
I still give it a 4/10 due to the stellar animation in the fight scenes, delightful art style, intriguing conclusion, and fantastic score. But all in all this is an incredibly disappointing episode that could've been so much more with a bit of retooling. The same could be said for the show as a whole honestly, although I wouldn't go so far as to say it's incredibly disappointing. It's still a very solid show with so much going for it to make up for its flaws. I'm just not convinced that it's the absolute pinnacle of shonen, let alone anime as a whole.
- liammc-73274
- Feb 7, 2022
- Permalink
Details
- Runtime24 minutes
- Color
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content