"Doctor Who" The Mutants: Episode Three (TV Episode 1972) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Mixed Mut
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic10 October 2014
Review for all 6 episodes:

Similar in lots of ways to the previous season's Colony in Space this involves the Doctor again being sent on a mission to a human colony on an alien planet. This time the mission is to deliver a pod with unknown contents to someone on the planet. The recipient is unknown too but the pod will only open for the correct person. On arrival the Doctor is caught up in dispute and death with a megalomaniac human 'overlord' leading a campaign to gain control of the planet whilst the native people of the planet fight for independence. There are also mutants on the planet surface and dangerous gas increasingly making the atmosphere outside the base unbreathable. The similarity in story and style is not quite by its quality as this story has a few issues but it is still an OK story overall.

One criticism levelled at this is that it seems pointless for the Time Lords to send The Doctor when they could surely just send the pod to its recipient but this is unfair because The Doctor clearly says later in the story that he has been sent for the purpose of helping to return the planet to its natural state and life cycle.

The main theme is very clearly based around imperialism with Earth's treatment of the native people compared to British rule in Africa, India etc. This is well written and thoughtful in its political ideas but the script and story are mixed. There is some strong dialogue and interesting ideas but also some poor scripting and plodding storytelling as it is dragged out over 6 episodes. There are also unimpressive costumes and sets although I actually like the mutant creatures apart from their eyes, they are quite fun. The story picks up a bit more quality for the 6th and final episode after dragging on a bit with a quite tense and exciting finale.

The interesting political plot elements and ecological aspects are a plus. Geoffrey Palmer is excellent in episode 1 adding real quality as the administrator and there are good performances from Paul Whitsun-Jones as the Marshal and John Hollis (who appears later in the story) as Sondergaard well as Pertwee as The Doctor. The planet itself is well realised too. There is a lot of good in this production, particularly in episodes 1 and 6. There are some bad aspects of padding, poor costumes and some weak, repetetive scenes.

Overall a mix of good and not so good elements makes an OK but very unexceptional story.

My ratings: Part 1 - 7.5/10, Part 2 - 6.5/10, Part 3 - 7/10, Part 4 - 7.5/10, Part 5 - 7/10, Part 6 - 7.5/10. Overall - 7.17/10.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ok, but a bit repetitive.
Sleepin_Dragon31 January 2021
The Doctor escapes Sky Base with the help of Varan, but Marshal has a plan for the Mut problem.

I have been pleasantly surprised by The Mutants, parts one and two were both way better than I had expected, but Part three is the first indicator that this story is a little padded out, and perhaps lacking some real grit.

Best aspect for me, that bizarre chamber that Jo wandered in to, and that strange being that came to her assistance. On the debit side, the pacing is rather slow, and it just doesn't seem to have progressed very far, Marshal is now starting to irritate me a little, he's a bit of your stereotypical bureaucratic bully, thank goodness for Cotton and Stubbs.

It's ok, I just felt it lacked any sort of intensity, 5//10.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed