Allison has sickening dreams revolving around a serial killer who practices necrophilia with his deceased victims. Meanwhile, Allison and Joe are invited to dine with friends where Allison foresees events as they really occurred as the wife of the other couple tells a story, testing Joe's patience when she tries to get him to believe in her special gifts. Back on the serial killer case, as Allison is in the process of gaining everyone's trust, she aids Devalos in an attempt to place the predator behind bars. With Allison's help, Devalos is able to select a jury that decides to give the serial killer the death penalty. By the end of the episode, Allison makes a shocking discovery when the man they've been searching for all along, the same man who confesses to the murders, is not the man who has been appearing in her dreams. It turns out the man Allison was seeing in her dreams as the serial killer was just a man on the cover of a menu at the restaurant Allison, Joe, and their friends had gone to earlier that week.