Edel & Starck (2002–2005) User Reviews

The German answer to Ally McBeal

[Mikew3001 · 7 August 2002]

This is a funny German TV series about a male and a female lawyer and their modern single lives in Berlin and their weird clients, situations and cases. It's obviously inspired by "Ally McBeal", especially by the use of dream sequences, visions and other illustrations of the lawyer's thoughts, but with more fun and less hassle about love, sex and relationships. In fact, the conversations between arrogant lawyer Felix Edel and his female colleague Sandra Starck are more influenced by the witty screwball comedies of Frank Capra or Howard Hughes, and this very funny series has got the right touch to become a small TV cult classic.

Witty, intelligent and entertaining - the best German TV series at present !

[isnogud-der-grosswesir · 9/10 · 31 July 2003]

True, the idea for this TV series may have sprung from the immense success which Ally McBeal is enjoying worldwide, even here in Germany. However, this said, Edel & Starck is very different from Ally McBeal in many ways.

The two main characters work beautifully together. Felix Edel (Felix Noble), played by well-known German actor, Christoph M. Ohrt and Sandra Starck (Sandra Strong - Noble & Strong, get it ???), played by charming Rebecca Immanuel, exchange quick romantic repartees and continually spy on each other while engaging in sitcom-like criminal cases in Berlin and surroundings. Further, they are aided by a magnificent cast of co-stars, most notably their secretary, played by Isabel Tuengerthal, who is a rare gem with GREAT comic potential. Also the shady wheeler-dealer, Otto, and the noble childhood pal of Felix, Frank, work very well, not to forget Sandra's best friend and room-mate, Patricia, played by the beautiful Barbara Demmer.

All-in-all a joy to watch on Monday nites: no wonder that the series and its stars have received several prizes. Will Felix get Sandra ?

I hope that we will have to wait for many more episodes to find out......

Unconventional and super funny

[linda67045 · 10/10 · 27 July 2006]

This series it's "something different". Sometimes European series are less accurate than the USA ones, but this time authors have hit the right target creating a mix that works in a smoothly way. Edel & Starck is great, it has all: great plot, smart, witty, always well delivered lines, an amazing theatrical timing showed by all the stars and beautiful shots of Berlin, one of the most interesting city in the world. It's entertaining to see how things works in the justice field in other countries than the USA and for once "feel" the old Europe way of dealing with life. Kudos to all the cast and crew for a well done comedy that is going to be a must to see in the years to come.Watching the series in German is super.

Germans being funny? Well, it happens.

[nggalai · 9/10 · 11 March 2010]

German private TV is ill-renowned for copying Dutch and – naturally – US formats. Well, in the case of Edel & Starck, the xeroxing only went as far as the basics: Screwball.

You can't stand screwball comedy? Don't watch Edel & Starck. Seriously. If you expect yet another lawyers' drama thingy similar to Law&Order or something, well, go somewhere else. (Or watch Law&Order as it's quite brilliant at what it does, but I digress.) E&S is funny, often addresses thought-provoking themes, is funny, romantic, funny, funny, and witty, too.

Frankly, I am quite dismayed the writers didn't get better deals after the serial's final. And my cynical nature needs to readjust itself re: private German television productions. German residents will understand what I'm talking about.

In short: Watch it. I don't have the foggiest what the English synchronisation is like, but hey, it's worth learning German just to watch them four seasons. Pseudo-happy end included.

Beautiful Screwball Stuff!

[horst-piffl · 28 March 2003]

EDEL & STARCK is the funniest, most intelligent und most beautifully made

german tv series ever. It is modern screwball at it`s best. Director Jakob

Schäuffelen, who made the pilot and two more episodes (with DP Konstantin

Kröning), has cast the perfect actors (Rebecca Immanuel and Christoph M. Ohrt) and forged a very entertaining and happy-making style. Unfortunately not every episode since the beginning has kept the high niveau.