Sherlock Holmes und die sieben Zwerge (1994) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
A detective in the fairytale kingdom
coyets17 January 2006
In a similar vein to "About Schmidt", the story begins with the last day at work before a well earned retirement. However, this being a film for children, instead of a boring insurance office worker, we are treated to a detective, who even arrests a criminal on his last ever journey to his place of work. The retirement celebration itself is not as cynical as in "About Schmidt", but it is also amusing.

In both films, the retiree does not really know what to do with his new situation in life. The retired detective Holms gets an unexpected visit from his two young grandchildren, and soon they descend into the fairytale kingdom, in a similar fashion to Mr.Majer's sudden visit to the fairytale world in "Arabela". This film is for younger children than that classical Czech TV series, however, and the scenes in the fairytale kingdom are kept much simpler than the complexities of Arabela's world. In both tales, the characters from different fairy stories meet each other and interact, sometimes in surprising ways. This children's film is again in this respect kept simple, at least simple enough for the younger viewers to appreciate, and the story continues to develop during the whole film, not running out of ideas, but being as ingenious as "Arabela".

Unfortunately, morals are kept on the surface in a condescending way, reminiscent of children's films from communist East Germany, instead of allowing growing personalities to draw their own conclusions from the tale as in the traditions of the classical fairy stories.

The acting is passable without being good. The story, and the subtle changes in the relationship between the children and their grandfather, are not without merit and entertainment value. On the whole, though, the film does not quite match up to the standards we have come to expect from children's films.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
All in all a good mixture
totzauermd-aifs15 July 2007
This movie presents especially for younger children up to 10 or 11 a very good mixture of adventure and fantasy, if one does not forget that it was made several years ago and therefore the effects aren't as impressive as nowadays. Thank god this movie does not follow the idea of the terribly retold fairy tales from Disney.

An old detective superintendent retires and discovers shortly after wards together with his grandchildren a secret, connected to an old chair, he got as a present for his retirement. This chair is the entrance to the world of fairy tales, introducing names as Grimm, Hauff and Bechstein to children. Now it is left to the grandfather and his grandchildren to save the king of the fairy tales - world and defeat the black magician who wants to conquer the throne.

A well written plot plus funny dialogs, which are especially appealing to and suitable for children, make this movie a nice film in opposition to the forced moralized fairytale-mutilations from Disney and Pixar.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed