Jill Cragie was one of the few women directors of the era.This though was her sole feature film.Set in a welsh mining town it has all the cliches associated with this type of film.Some nice touches cant overcome the staleness of the script.
3 Reviews
The valley ain't so green any more.
mark.waltz8 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
While this has a great atmospheric view of the lives of Welsh miners, it sadly isn't very interesting plot wise. There are some interesting technical aspects to the film, but the love story of a young singing hopeful (Gwyneth Vaughan) and mine worker Emrys Jones doesn't hold your attention. There is some humor involving some of the singing villagers (who couldn't carry a tune in a miner's coal wagon), but the film drags on for 90 minutes as a basic slice of life story for the workers that gives the viewer a docudrama feel to the story. You really do feel like you are seeing how these people lived their difficult lives, mainly because none of these actors are familiar. The direction by Jill Cragie (given prominent billing after the main credits have past and the film has moved past them into the story) is good, but it is directed like a stage play for television rather than for the big screen. Supporting characters are appropriately eccentric or temperamental, and they do provide a bit of color, but you can't get past that the leads, as sincere as they are, come off as bland and mismatched. Film students will be intrigued by how advanced it looks as far as most of the photography with some camera work that was truly inventive. Others might as well steer clear unless the subject matter interests them.
Forgotten British feature, worthy of revisiting
lor_28 March 2023
My review was written in September 1988 after a screening of an archival print at MoMA in Manhattan.
Virtually unknown in the U. S., "Blue Scar" is an unusual 1949 British picture telling the familiar story of the hardships of Welsh coal miners in a combination of militant realism and a contrasting romanticism.
Central story concerns the attempt of beautiful OIwen (Gwyneth Vaughan) to escape from the stultifying environment of her small mining village of Abergwyfni by becoming an opera singer in London. Her boyfriend Tom (Emrys Jones), like her family, is a miner, but she wants him to quit and get a "collar and the job".
Set in 1946-47, most of the first portion of the picture deals with the miners' grievances and problems under postwar nationalization of the industry, which does not live up to its promise of improving their lot. With unsafe conditions in the mine depicted as well as the tragic fate of Olwen's dad, film builds to a confrontation where the miners are ready to walk out in support of their mate who has had a run-in with a nasty new supervisor (Jack James).
Abruptly, a compromise is struck and the story backs off from its militant stand to a more typical "making do" payoff.
Olwen's rosy views of the rich life in London are humorously debunked in a blistering scene of the shallow, snooty cafe society there. Film's heart is with the rugged Welsh landscape, beautifully photographed by Jo Jago, who later worked on second unit for such major films as "The Cruel Sea".
Unusual credit card at opening states: "This film is written and directed by Jill Criagie", a documentary filmmaker who was one of the few women postwar feature directors in England, followed soon after by Muriel Box and Wendy Toye. Her work here is uneven but shows promise, apparently never realized with another fiction feature.
Welsh cast is adequate, notably including as Olwen's layabout brother Kenneth Griffith, later seen in many screen comedies.
Virtually unknown in the U. S., "Blue Scar" is an unusual 1949 British picture telling the familiar story of the hardships of Welsh coal miners in a combination of militant realism and a contrasting romanticism.
Central story concerns the attempt of beautiful OIwen (Gwyneth Vaughan) to escape from the stultifying environment of her small mining village of Abergwyfni by becoming an opera singer in London. Her boyfriend Tom (Emrys Jones), like her family, is a miner, but she wants him to quit and get a "collar and the job".
Set in 1946-47, most of the first portion of the picture deals with the miners' grievances and problems under postwar nationalization of the industry, which does not live up to its promise of improving their lot. With unsafe conditions in the mine depicted as well as the tragic fate of Olwen's dad, film builds to a confrontation where the miners are ready to walk out in support of their mate who has had a run-in with a nasty new supervisor (Jack James).
Abruptly, a compromise is struck and the story backs off from its militant stand to a more typical "making do" payoff.
Olwen's rosy views of the rich life in London are humorously debunked in a blistering scene of the shallow, snooty cafe society there. Film's heart is with the rugged Welsh landscape, beautifully photographed by Jo Jago, who later worked on second unit for such major films as "The Cruel Sea".
Unusual credit card at opening states: "This film is written and directed by Jill Criagie", a documentary filmmaker who was one of the few women postwar feature directors in England, followed soon after by Muriel Box and Wendy Toye. Her work here is uneven but shows promise, apparently never realized with another fiction feature.
Welsh cast is adequate, notably including as Olwen's layabout brother Kenneth Griffith, later seen in many screen comedies.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
