User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
Poor
max mccall17 June 2002
I suffered this film last evening, as usual I stayed with it to the bitter end hoping it would improve but alas I was disappointed with the 89 minutes of my life wasted. I have enjoyed many films with little or no plot in the past as long as they were entertaining with something to grab my attention. This unfortunately lacked the following :-

Plot, Storyline, Script, Humour, Fresh ideas.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A superb comedy with a hint of the black stuff
mr_impossible25 September 2000
I was lucky enough to catch this film on a trip to Dublin. Doubly so in fact because not only is it absolutely fantastic but it is also virtually impossible to find. It is, in the South Park mould "a foreign film" from Ireland and so has, even in England, been consigned it appears to the video pit of despair.

This is an enormous shame because this is a uniquely Irish film without any of the baggage that this would usually imply. Or rather the film cheerfully acknowledges Irish cinematic stereotypes and then proceeds to hit them with a stick.

Timmy, the protagonist, is a somewhat confused young man who regularly seeks guidance from his doctor mentor played spectacularly by the wonderful Ian Richardson (why doesn't he get more film work?). He lives in (I kid you not) the Bates Motel with his mother and dreams of being a writer. His books are however too self-consciously Irish, his writing teacher tells him and thus too misery filled and angsty for popular consumption in the 90's.

Timmy is forced to rethink his own life (sort of) and the world around him and try to free himself from the grip of the strongest of all forces, that of the force of habit.

I will not apologise for essentially having had to lie a lot during that synopsis because to reveal the main element of the plot would be to ruin the entire film. Suffice to say there is an element of the Shining here, albeit far more relaxed and beautifully realised. This is essentially a comedy with a hint of the black stuff (stylistically rather than alcoholically).

The Fifth Province is a rare example of a film which does everything it sets out to do with elan, it is funny, looks gorgeous, has an excellent cast, a good soundtrack and has a premise which is unexpected and deftly handled. I would give quite a bit to see this film again. I urge you to brave the uncharted wildernesses of your video shops and seek it out and if you do - can I have a copy?
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
laughter in the rainy soul
russellcraigr13 February 2005
Warning: Spoilers
the truth is that 'Fifth Province' is a rarity: a film with its own story to tell, in its own time. though set in the present day, 5P could easily be in the nineteen fifties, or even the 19th century... the humour is self deprecating Irish, the archness is all its own, the cinematography stylish and the rain relentless

I will not spoil any of the plot elements, but you may find it useful to be prepared for the following events MINI SPOILERS: exploding cows... vengeful (ex) wives... worms turning... script doctors... roads leading to Brussels... Sligo Sleet... Mexican tulpas... true love...

it is a lovely, wicked little film
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed