The Ebony Tower (TV Movie 1984) Poster

(1984 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Miscast but still worthwhile
graffman25 November 2007
This is an early TV-version of one of John Fowles' greatest stories, the first and longest in his collection of the same name from 1974. All highly recommended reading. And perhaps it belongs to a genre better read in retreat, than seen on any screen. Though the effort to make a film of it deserves attention, if not else just because of the archetypal abyss of the story.

The main drawback is that Olivier is terribly miscast. The great ham is no ailing but still dangerously masculine and sharp old Man, as the painter Henry Breasley is supposed to be. Someone like Richard Harris might have been a more congenial choice for the role. And even Roger Rees seems somewhat too anemic here. While Greta Scacchi is pretty perfect. I'd buy it on DVD anytime, if it was available by itself and not just as a bonus in an Olivier collection..
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Watchable, but slight?
Charlot4729 July 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Nice setting of an old French manor in summer inhabited by an old dragon of a painter (Olivier) and two maidens, former art students, that he has ensnared (Scacchi and Wilcox). Into his realm to interview him comes not a knight errant but a self-satisfied example of the modern world (Rees). One of the girls, shy but gifted, wonders whether to escape with him and rejoin the world. Before the end she realises he is not worth it.

The book said a lot more but we have to be satisfied with the brief foray of this film, which is emotionally and intellectually thinner. To compensate, we get glimpses of some fine paintings and, in a re-enactment of Manet's "Déjeuner sur l'herbe", some fine bare girls. Overall it comes across as watchable but slight, the strong point being the beauty and more than that the poignancy of Greta Scacchi as a bright talented young woman unsure of her direction.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Waste of Talent
pfaul5 September 2004
Boring, puerile tale of a young writer sent to interview a successful wealthy artist (Olivier) at his country estate in France. One of Olivier's more unfortunate films - he is hammy without the fun (not a patch on "Sleuth" or "Marathon Man"). As the "great" artist he gets to pontificate about art in running undergraduate monologues, which include every cliché about artists in film. This is not Olivier's fault, I fear, but Fowles', who likes to write about callow young men who learn the meaning of life from some great older man (e.g. "The Magus"). The scenery is stunning, as is Greta Scacchi - it must have been in her contract at this time that she had to drop her gear in every role (as in "White Mischief", which at least was heaps of fun). Watch for the straight-faced, but unintentionally hilarious recreation of Manet's "Breakfast on the Grass" with 80's pop star Toyah Wilcox. Could have been good if it had even a grain of wit or some real drama. For a film that explores similar territory - but brilliantly - try Alain Resnais' film "Providence". DUD.
8 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed