A Broadway Romeo (1931) User Reviews

Say "uncle", Jack

[F Gwynplaine MacIntyre · 6/10 · 23 April 2003]

Jack Benny had a spectacularly successful career as a comedian, but just once in a while he showed some hints of real talent as an actor. The most obvious example is his starring role in 'To Be or Not to Be', but 'A Broadway Romeo' deserves attention too. Benny starred in this short film early in his career, when his comedic character as the egotistical tightwad (permanently age 39) was still gestating. (When he made this movie, he wasn't 39 yet!)

SLIGHT SPOILERS. 'A Broadway Romeo' takes place in the Times Square district of Manhattan, during what's clearly the Depression: everyone in the film (except ingenue Estelle Brody) is cynical and selfish. Jack uses an old confidence trick to cadge a free lunch for himself at a lunch counter: as he gets up to leave, he offers to pay for the lunch of the man sitting next to him (a total stranger), telling the man to look up and wave when Jack goes over to the cashier at the other end of the lunchroom, so that the cashier will know that this man's lunch is on Jack's tab. Of course, when Jack gets to the cashpoint, he tells the cashier that his **own** lunch is on the **other** man's tab, and sure enough the stranger looks up and waves at the cashier as if agreeing to this. Apparently, movie audiences in 1931 (hard hit by the Depression) were meant to admire Jack's resourcefulness in this scam.

Jack Benny's performance in this movie is a revelation, and much subtler than his usual comedy. After meeting small-town girl Estelle (alone in the big city after her fiancé just dumped her), Jack takes her under his wing. We can tell that he's on the make, but he also seems genuinely concerned for her welfare and sincere in his wish to protect her ... from everyone but himself.

There's a running gag that isn't funny, and has an obvious payoff. Periodically, a man walks past Jack and Estelle -- a different man each time -- waving hello, while Jack explains: 'That's one of my uncles.' The last man to do this is very effeminate, and Jack's punchline is visible from a mile off: 'My aunt.'

I'll rate this movie 6 out of 10, for an unusual look at a giant of comedy still finding his way.

Mr. Benny provides bad customer service... And gets the girl!

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 2 December 2016]

Somehow, Jack Benny ends up behind a newspaper stand, providing witticisms as he unsuccessfully tries to sell newspapers. A chance encounter with a starving stenographer leads to a date with an equally nasty counter man (who happens to be the boss), giving the young lady the sage advice that "Broadway is just all the main streets rolled into one, and you've got to do everything you can to make it work." It's more dramatic than comic, with the comedy coming from Benny's cynicism and the story from every day life. There's a brief gay reference that falls flat and seems to come out of thin air. It's more a curiosity because of Benny's presence, and it would take radio and vaudeville to get him back to the movies later on.

Jack Benny in an inauspicious beginning

[planktonrules · 3/10 · 16 July 2006]

Despite how unfunny this comedy short is, I know that Benny made some wonderful films just a decade later (particularly THE MEANEST MAN ALIVE). However, audiences who were used to hearing him on the radio must have been pretty disappointed. And, later audiences who were used to the style Jack had on THE JACK BENNY PROGRAM would no doubt be disappointed as well, as the sweetness and self-parody he later was famous for is conspicuously missing. Instead, Jack plays a bit of a "sharpie" who is trying to peddle a line here and take advantage of another person there--a NOT particularly likable fella who uses fast-talk to his advantage! No, this is a coarser and unlikable Benny--too unfunny and a few years from his better work.