Lilac Time (1928) Poster

(1928)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Jeannine, I Dream Of Lilac Time
bkoganbing12 June 2011
Lilac Time which starred Colleen Moore was a big boost to the career of Gary Cooper. He played the British flier who was stationed on a base at Colleen Moore's farm during the World War. He cuts quite a dashing figure as a British air ace and son of British General Burr McIntosh.

This film is a great example of the universality of silent films where the very American speaking Cooper and Moore could get away with playing a British and a French national respectively. In Cooper's career afterward, when playing in a foreign setting it was always explained he was Canadian, he was one of the first of Hollywood leading men to have that gambit used when sound arrived. But in the silent era the only demand was that one be photogenic and no one was more photogenic than Gary Cooper.

Lilac Time was a play written by and starring Jane Cowl on Broadway during the 1917 season. It was one of Cowl's bigger hits on Broadway and a pity she didn't do the screen version. It concerns a small base of the Royal Flying Corps established on the farm of Eugene Besserer and her daughter Colleen Moore. Moore is something of a mascot to the men, but when she spots Cooper she doesn't want to be thought of as a pet.

As for Cooper he's got a fiancé back home, one of those aristocratic arranged marriages and his fiancé is played by Kathryn McGuire. At first he and Moore do not get along, he regards her as a nuisance. But the chemistry kicks in after a while.

Lilac Time made at the tail end of the silent era was one of the first films to have a music score written for it. The copy I have is a compilation of old World War I era ballads, but with the popular standard written expressly for this film, Jeannine, I Dream Of Lilac Time. This was one of the first songs written directly for the screen, albeit for a silent film. It and the rest of the score is done on a Wurlitzer organ and the song makes this film a candidate for revivals at festivals. Gene Austin had a big selling record of this song in 1928 when the film came out.

Viewed over 80 years after it came out, Lilac Time still holds up very well, a bit melodramatic, but a nice romance.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Love at First Flight
wes-connors24 May 2008
In 1918, flighty farm girl Colleen Moore (as Jeannine Berthelot) becomes attached to seven British fliers, who are stationed near her home, in France; and, the airborne group is just as fond of the charming Ms. Moore. Sadly, one of the pilots dies, after a typically dangerous mission; quickly, he is replaced by Gary Cooper (as Phillip Blythe). Mr. Cooper has arrived to do his "bit" for his British country, and fiancée. Although they may not acknowledge the fact, it's obviously love at first flight for Moore and Cooper. Once Moore and Cooper pledge their love, he and his men are ordered out on a suicide mission...

The popularity of Moore and the aviation theme were enough to make "Lilac Time" bloom at the box office. Moore handles the comedy/drama characterization well; and, Cooper is a handsome love interest. Their overblown love story becomes too maudlin, however. Although Moore (especially) and Cooper play their romantic meeting and courtship exceedingly well; the comic set-up, and proceeding situation, makes it all quite ludicrous. The fate of the squadron, the bombing of Moore, and the Grande Finale may combine to induce feelings of nausea.

****** Lilac Time (8/3/28) George Fitzmaurice ~ Colleen Moore, Gary Cooper, Jack Stoney
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Lilac Time review
JoeytheBrit4 May 2020
Dashing young WWI pilot Gary Cooper falls for village girl Colleen Moore in this late silent. It's well-staged and the aerial fights and crashes are shot well, but I can't shake the feeling that they shied away from the tragic ending towards which the movie seems to be heading.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Colleen Moore at the Height of Her Stardom...
drednm4 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
turned from flapper and comedy roles (like "Flaming Youth" and "Ella Cinders") to a great WW I romance, Lilac Time. Moore plays a French village girl who falls in love with a British flying ace (Gary Cooper). Not much happens, but it's a sweet romance and was a big hit in its day. This film also established Cooper as a star. Some OK dog fight footage helps enliven this war film, but it's the chemistry between the stars that makes it special. Good special effects for its time, and a socko ending with Moore being told Cooper has died of his wounds.... A real tear jerker but it works. Among the co-starts are Eugenie Besserer and Arthur Lake. Colleen Moore had a great face and is very expressive, allowing her to under act, a skill that made Mary Pickford and Lillian Gish tops stars.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Chick Flick
januszlvii17 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I have seen this concept done before: A wartime romance: She thinks he is dead but spoilers ahead he survives. This is certainly not one of Gary Cooper's ( Phillip) best films, and it is dominated by Colleen Moore ( Jeannie). Now to be fair it was produced by Moore's husband John McCormick, and was done at her home studio ( First National), so you can assume quite correctly that this is a chick flick more then a Gary Cooper action film. The good news is the aviation scenes are excellent and that is the main reason to see Lilac Time. One other reason is Coleen Moore surviving pictures are rare so this is a chance to actually see her ( I saw Lilac Time on Roku). Cooper really was not at his best, but as a Cooper completist, I am happy to have seen it ( although it is the weakest of the six silents of his that I have seen). It is that number 6 that I give this movie. 6/10 stars.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Provides comedy and drama
nielshell22 July 2007
British and American pilots launch attacks during World War I from a small town in France. A caring Colleen Moore is dedicated to providing moral support to these pilots. Gary Cooper replaces a downed pilot. Antagonism between Moore and Cooper precedes romance and provides a comic beginning. As romance develops, the pilots, including Cooper, are sent on a dangerous mission. A commercially available release of this film allow interested viewers to find Cooper's fate and the end result of Moore's trials and tribulations to also find his fate. This end of the silent era movie is worth the effort to ferret out for viewing.

The theme song of the motion picture, "Jeannine, I Dream of Lilac Time," is commercially available. It was recorded by well over a hundred top artists, including Louis Armstrong, Skitch Henderson, Guy Lombardo, The London Symphony Orchestra, opera star John McCormack, Mitch Miller, The Platters, Lawrence Welk, and Paul Whiteman. Many of these recordings have been transferred to commercially available CDs. For example, a recording by the composer, Nat Shilkret, is included in the ASV CD "Dancing With Tears In My Eyes," which is available from amazon.com.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A perfect love story.
Alf-233 March 1999
How great can a film be? This is one of the answers to that. Sweet Colleen Moore and Gary Cooper are a perfect couple, and Lilac Time a perfect love story. Forget Titanic! Bring a handkerchief when you see this.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed