Shoe Palace Pinkus (1916) User Reviews

A mildly fun early comedy

[I_Ailurophile · 6/10 · 22 March 2022]

Ernst Lubitsch was unquestionably a master filmmaker, and he was especially deft when it came to comedy. 1916's 'Schuchpalast Pinkus' ('Shoe Palace Pinkus') is notably one of his very first feature films, as well as one of his oldest surviving pictures. It is perhaps less notable as a comedy. There is consistent mild amusement to be found here, but at no point does the entertainment ever reach nearly the level as some of Lubitsch's other titles from even just a few short years later (e.g. 'The Oyster Princess,' 'I don't want to be a man,' or 'The doll'). Boasting situational humor, a touch of physical comedy, and exaggerated characters and performances, this is a movie that's reasonably enjoyable - but hardly essential, except perhaps as cinema history.

Make no mistake, even so early in his career, as both director and actor Lubitsch demonstrates a keen sense of timing, and how to build a scene to maximize audience engagement. So it is as well for his co-stars, including frequent collaborator Ossi Oswalda, and regular writing partners Hanns Kräly and Erich Schönfelder, to whom this screenplay is credited. In viewing 'Schuhpalast Pinkus' one can trace a line from these embryonic days of the medium to later renditions of similar characters to Lubitsch's "Sally," with actors like Peter Sellers, Steve Martin, and Rowan Atkinson coming to mind. The "fumbling fool" who somehow nonetheless climbs up in society is a reliable archetype of film.

With all the advantages 'Schuhpalast Pinkus' has going for it, however, including some especially well considered shots and scenes, somehow it just never manages to reach a level to particularly ingratiate itself with viewers. Maybe the pace and plot development, and the scene writing, is just too unbothered, or the intertitles too frequent. Maybe the light comedy herein just hasn't aged well, in contrast to Lubitsch's other works. Nothing specifically stands out in the movie as a flaw - but at the same time, I suppose the problem is that nothing specifically stands out, at all. The runtime comes and goes without making much of an impression.

For Lubitsch admirers and completionists, and for those utterly enamored of the silent era, this is worth a mere hour of one's time. For those who enjoy comedies of any timeframe, it's worth exploring the roots of the genre on film. And for that matter, anyone looking for a title to watch in passing, that neither requires nor fosters utmost active investment, will be well suited here. If you're looking for especially robust laughs, 'Schuhpalast Pinkus' will unfortunately not be the movie to supply them - but for its place in cinema history, and in the oeuvre of a great filmmaker, and for the easy air of amusement it provides, this is a fairly good time if you come across it.

Suffers from an unappealing main character

[Woodyanders · 5/10 · 3 August 2020]

Lazy and feckless ne'er-do-well Sally Pinkus (robustly played by Ernst Lubitsch, who also directed) gets thrown out of school and winds up being fired from two jobs as a shoe salesman before going on to start his own shoe store business.

While director Lubitsch keeps the enjoyable story zipping along at a quick pace and maintains an amiable lighthearted tone throughout, he nonetheless can't do much with the largely annoying and charmless character of Pinkus: Whether he's cheating on a test or playing a dumb prank on somebody, Pinkus alas comes across as a real chore to put up with. It's only towards the end when Pinkus proves himself as a shrewd businessman that he finally registers as somewhat more likable person, but by then it's too little too late. An acceptable diversion.

Lubitsch before his big breakthrough

[Horst_In_Translation · 4/10 · 29 June 2015]

This is a 42-minute movie from almost 100 years ago. i also saw that there are version that run for almost an hour. I watched the shorter one that has the same runtime like this title on IMDb. Basically, it is all a big show for Ernst Lubitsch. He is writer, director and lead actor here. It is mostly a comedy, even if there are some romance and drama references here and there. If you look at the year 1916, you will not be surprised that this is a silent movie in black-and-white. Pinkus is the name of the lead character and Sally was also still a common name for guys back then. He dreams of getting his own shoe palace. Will his dream come true? Well, at least Ernst Lubitsch's dream came true as he made it from Germany to Hollywood and received several Academy Award nominations and a Honorary Award shortly before his untimely death at 55.

One of the two writers for this short film here is Hanns Kräly who worked with Lubitsch on several projects and also won an Academy Award for writing one of Lubitsch's films. Lubitsch and Kräly were also very prolific actors. I personally believe that "Schuhpalast Pinkus" occasionally shows us already the talent of its protagonist and what he may come up with in the decades after this. Definitely very developed for a man in his early 20s. Yet as a whole, i would not recommend this film here. I believe in terms of silent black-and-white movies the Americans (Keaton, Chaplin, Lloyd, Laurel&Hardy) are still the best.

Vaudeville influences

[davidmvining · 5/10 · 24 March 2023]

Ernst Lubitsch began his feature film career with this self-driven star vehicle designed to introduce his character, Sally Pinkus, to the German speaking cinematic world. It worked, and he made several more films with the character before abandoning him when Lubitsch moved to America. Whenever I see attempts at building silent film comic characters, I always, as I'm sure most do, refer back to Charlie Chaplin's Tramp character. Chaplin understood the limits of silent comedy extraordinarily well, and here, in Lubitsch's first feature film attempt, the young German-Jewish filmmaker can't quite figure out how to actually fill the time. There are entertaining bits here and there, enough to entertain at some level at least, but without the ability to really create a strong central character or bring him into a series of gags that feed a clear central narrative, the film just mostly lurches from one event to the next.

Sally Pinkus (Lubitsch) is an errant youth who goes to school late all of the time, happy to sleep in, declaring that he's still early enough to be late to his worrying mother and stern father. He's much more concerned with attracting the attention of girls, so when he does manage to get his way to school, he delays to help a pretty girl get to her school first. His teacher (Hanns Kraly) doesn't like the misbehaving and distracted youth, giving him lectures about his lateness and trying to keep him on task, but Sally will not be bothered to work hard at his studies. When he tries to cheat on a test by pinning some notes to the jacket of the boy in front of him, he quickly gets found out and expelled.

Now, this early section is notable for some witty intertitles (the aforementioned excuse for being late) and some amusing physical comedy like when Sally tries to climb over his fellow students to get to his seat, or crawling under a pommel horse while his teacher's back is turned in order to act like he'd made it over. There are some sight gags like when Sally is at the top of the middle of three climbing poles, waving to the girls on the other side of the wall, when his teacher decides to climb the adjacent pole to try and bring him down, just for Sally to slide down just as the teacher reaches the top. It's amusing stuff and it's spaced out well enough so that we never go more than just a couple of minutes without a nice little laugh.

Then Sally leaves school, trying to find a job, and we get similar little amusements as he becomes the apprentice in one shoe shop, just to be fired because he won't work with the smelly feet of male customers and spends more time with the shop owner's daughter than at his job. His overinflated sense of self-worth is the main source of comedy here, and his personal ad in the newspaper looking for new work is a good chuckle.

He ends up working at a new shop where he gets into a small rivalry with the owner of the shop over the delivery of a pair of boots to a wealthy, pretty, female customer. It's also where Sally gets a chance to spend a lot of time around women's feet, and it makes me wonder if Lubitsch had something of a foot fetish. I mean, it's Tarantino level stuff here.

The effort to get the proper boots to the customer is tame, and I was imagining the kind of manic comedy that could have arisen from two men with identical packages trying to race each other to the doorstep of their intended conquest, but it's much tamer than that. There are some laughs, small, nice laughs for sure, but it's nothing hilarious. It also shows the limits of Lubitsch's narrative capabilities at this point because the movie just decides to jump ahead and have the customer, Melitta (Else Kentner), give Sally thirty thousand marks to start a new shoe shop because Sally was fast in delivering the shoes. I mean, okay. Sure, why not?

And it just raises the question of what Sally wanted through the whole thing. He never wanted a job, responsibility, or money. He just wanted the ladies, and suddenly he has the drive to open up a shop, market in a unique way at a dance, and put on a fashion show in his new space, all so that he can then proceed to propose to Melitta when the shop is suddenly a success? It's something of a logical leap that strikes me as "and then" type storytelling without much consideration for how events flow into each other.

Still, the saving grace is the gentle humor that pervades through the whole thing, and it is rather consistently amusing. It's not moving or hilarious, but it is gently delightful in small helpings. I've certainly seen worse openings from filmmakers before, but I've also seen better. It's pretty watchable.

I also think it's interesting to note that the film is the story of a young, poor, Jewish boy who makes good and enters high society. I wonder if there's a certain autobiography, at least inspirational autobiography, on Lubitsch's part there.