7-time Tony Award nominee, once in (2005) Best Featured Actress in a Musical for "The Light in the Piazza"; and six nominations for Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical: (2006) for "The Pajama Game"; (2008)for "South Pacific"; (2012) for "Nice Work if You Can Get It"; (2014)for "The Bridges of Madison County"; (2015) for "The King and I"; and (2019) for "Kiss Me, Kate". Kelli won the Tony Award in 2015 for "The King and I".