Change Your Image
cslbprosser-11930
Reviews
I Am Soldier (2014)
Unacceptably Researched, Poorly Written, and Badly Executed
Well what more can I say about this movie that hasn't been said in other reviews already. I have not read Ronnie Thompsoms book so I don't know how this compares to the original story. What I can tell you is that this low budget movie was dreadful.
Im not really sure where to start. There clearly wasn't enough research done on the SAS for starters. Considering this movie was predominantly about the SAS selection process, the scenes shot for the first three quarters of the film were unrealistic.The training teams behaviour attitude and professionalism was laughable and unbelievable. The hills phase was not portrayed well, and neither was the Escape and Evasion. The Jungle Phase, missed out completely and the jumps phase.....please!
The acting, although OK wasn't the best, I've seen. as previously mentioned by others a little more time with an acting coach might have made the Bosnian terrorists a bit more believable.Ultimately I guess the actors were just trying to make the best of the awful script. The characters felt hollow and unfinished and I never really connected with any of them. By the end of the film I didn't really care if Mickey, the lead character made it through or not
Kit and equipment used was either wrong or being used incorrectly and the weapon handling throughout, in particular the last 20 minutes of the film was, to be frank....embarrassing. The final assault would probably in reality left the entire team dead and a dirty bomb on the streets of London. This movie did absolutely nothing to show the true professionalism of the most elite soldiers in the world.
In the days of low budget movies, there is no excuse for turning out rubbish like this, particularly when you look at other British made low budget military movies recently made. Where I am Soldier gets everything wrong, the recent movie - Kajaki hits the nail on the head throughout. Don't waste your time watching this, its time you'll never get back, Go watch Kajaki instead and see how movies like this 'should' be made
Kajaki (2014)
Gritty Realism, Superb Script, Characters you can believe in.
A stunning portrayal of true events involving 3 Para at Kajaki Dam in 2006, this film is about as authentic as it can get. The gritty realism of what is unfolding on screen will have you on the edge of your seat.
As a 21 year veteran of the British Army, the script, the banter between the characters, their personalities, behaviour coupled with the actors performances immediately sent me back to my time in Sangin in 2008. There was clearly a lot of time and effort put in to the research of the film and it fully deserves any accolades that it receives. I cannot rate this film highly enough and it will take a permanent place as one of my all time favourite films.