Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Goodbye (I) (2022)
7/10
In Defense of 'Goodbye' - A Powerful Journey of Acceptance, Remembrance, and Reverence for Traditions around Losing a Family Member
20 May 2023
Goodbye (2022) is a truly underrated gem that resonated deeply with me, evoking a range of emotions seldom experienced while watching a movie. This poignant film beautifully explores the themes of individual and familial acceptance in the aftermath of losing a loved one. It teaches us to find solace in cherishing the precious moments shared with them while still embracing happiness. Unlike many Bollywood films, Goodbye focuses on reality rather than indulging in action, plot twists, or unrealistic storylines. It delves into the profound questions of life and death, unearthing the true meaning hidden beneath.

Right from the beginning, the film captivates me with the heartfelt past scenes involving Gayatri and the puppy she brings home for Harish. Flashbacks of the past family time the parents and children had vividly depict the power of family bonding and how a mother can transform a mere house into a loving home. The movie adeptly avoids unnecessary elongation and instead encapsulates every aspect of family life through succinct sequences. Contrary to some reviewers, I found the funeral scene to be a necessary portrayal of society's varied responses to loss. It realistically portrays the different ways in which people experience grief, acknowledging that the pain felt by a husband, or a child differs from that of a friend.

In today's generation, many of us live far from our parents, engrossed in the demands of our careers, marriages, and personal lives. Like Gayatri's children, we often find ourselves living emotionally detached, fast-paced lives, often forgetting the precious time we had with our families. Goodbye refrains from attributing fault to children, husbands, or society; it rather offers a nuanced perspective, highlighting the different perceptions held by each individual. Similarly, the film encourages us to view traditions and customs from a different angle, reminding us "Not everything we don't understand is wrong".

One aspect that truly impressed me was the respectful portrayal of Hindu traditions surrounding death. The film neither coerces nor judges anyone for following these traditions; instead, it invites us to see them through a fresh lens. It recognizes that even while science validate a custom, it is the power of stories that truly strengthens and perpetuates our cultural traditions. As an atheist myself, I found it refreshing to witness the film's appreciation for customs that promote acceptance and happiness without causing harm. The journey to Haridwar serves as a beautiful metaphor for the family coming together in their shared loss, creating lasting moments of connection. It exemplifies the purity that Indians often find even amidst great sorrow, with simple elements like the street food, the presence of Pandits, the sacred Ganga river, and the Hari Krishna dance instilling a sense of tranquility and peace.

The exceptional direction in Goodbye deserves special mention. My personal favorite sequence is the animated album that beautifully depicts Harish's love life through a kite flying incident, accompanied by a heartwarming background score. The animated portrayal of a young Amitabh Bachchan deepens the emotional connection, leaving a lasting impact. No songs (except the first party song) will break the movie sequence, and there is no unusual ending. The sweet and melodious songs gracefully guide the audience towards a satisfying and happy ending.

In my opinion, Goodbye deserves a place among the illustrious films that delve into the profound exploration of life's meaning. This movie gets into my list of "Finding the Meaning of Life" and joins the league of "Tamasha", "Rang De Basanti", and "Udaan". This film's ability to touch the soul and deliver a heartfelt message is unparalleled, making it a truly remarkable directional piece.

Overall, Goodbye is an underrated gem that skillfully explores the intricacies of acceptance, family bonds, and the meaning of life. Its authentic portrayal of grief, coupled with exceptional direction and a heartfelt narrative, make it a must-watch for anyone seeking an emotional and thought-provoking cinematic journey.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Queen of Bollywood into Queen of Jhansi. Only few instances of Laxmibai portrayed. Good action sequences.
6 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Although you may find the movie going bit slow, the plot decently packed with action should be appreciated. We need more movies to boost up morale of our country women and show the world the power of an Indian women! Characters like Kali Mata and Manikarnika shows how India had always admired women. I really feel proud to be an Indian when think about the brave-hearts the country had been producing.

For those who had been saying that Kangana's character is portrayed larger than life should read the History again. Rani Lakshmibai was indeed a larger than life figure. Even after the demise of her husband, she was so strong to fight numerous wars (not even shown in the movie) and won many of them. Few scenes of jumping across horses should not be used to judge the movie. That's cinematic liberty. In fact, any movie cannot portray how powerful personality Jhansi Ki Rani was! Yes, in order not to let Britishers take her body, she accepted being burnt.

Most of the negative reviews are probably due to the movie not showing accurate and full historic moments. To name few - Ghulam Ghaus Khan played a key role in the rebellion, Kashi Bai was the commander in the army which Manikarnika formed in Vanarasi, Jhansi and Gwalior relationship and the secret tunnel between these cities, Rani's fight with British Army, Orcha and Datia, British in Kalpi, Gwalior and then finally with the British. I had always advised fellow viewers to go through history besides watching and believing in a movie. The movie has anyways did justice with Lakshmibai's character and in spite of having low historic events should not deserve a rating less than 8!

Kangana's personality do suite Lakshmibai's character but I feel the dialogue delivery and voice tone could have been better. The movie would have been perfect 10 if they had included all the major events around Lakshmibai and more research on the character.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed