I read some of the other comments prior to mine and got the impression that the movie bears little resemblence to the novel. That doesn't matter though, because I've never read the book, and from what I've read here, it seems that the book would put me to sleep if I had tried to read it. I remember having to read Pride and Prejudice for English class in 9th grade, it bored me to sleep. Everytime I picked up the book to read, I would scan through the lines which I can't seem to comprehend as they're denser than uranium, then after a few pages I would not remember anything I just read and get very sleepy. I never finished the book, and decided never to touch anything by Austen again. A few days ago, I came across Mansfield Park on the shelves at my local video rental store, since I was just browsing and happened to have my membership card and a few bucks in my pocket, I decided why not, so I rented it. When I popped it in my VCR, I was pleasantly surprised. While I'd agree that the bit about slavery is extraneous, there's no need to dwell on minor points, as they occupy a tiny fraction of screen time. I loved O'Conner's portrayal of Fanny, and for the longest time I thought she's going to marry Henry Crawford and live happily ever after. I completely missed the bit about his flirtation with Mariah and I guess it was so minor that I just automatically dismissed it as not being central to the plot. I'd have never thought the Crawfords to be such as they really are. I really enjoyed the incorporation of the bits of stories that Fanny wrote, "...their intimicy grew to such a pitch that they no longer kick each other out of the window at the slightest provocation", "...but lived beyond their means and eventually was jailed where she was partially eaten by her two young sons, but she plans to stab the prison guards..." I loved these tidbits as they really give an insight to the creative and imaginative mind of Fanny Price. What made the whole movie work is O'Conner's portrayal of Fanny, if they have made Fanny timid and shy and submissive as had been suggested, I think the movie would've been boring and turned me off Austen forever (now I'm going to find P&P and S&S to watch). This Fanny is actually exciting, to quote Edmund, [her] "entire person is entirely agreeable". There are lots of movies with hot actresses, and there's lots of movies with sappy teen romances, what set this movie apart is that it's romantic without being sappy, it's fun without being frivolous, and the heroine isn't some boy crazy school girl or butt kicking action junkie, she actually possesses wit and humor, with capabilities for invention and creativity. In other words, she actually has a brain [and a heart of course :-) ]. (and I don't mean brain as in Legally Blonde)
0 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends