Fantano has only given seven albums a perfect 10 so far: "The Money Store" by Death Grips, "To Be Kind" by Swans, "To Pimp a Butterfly" by Kendrick Lamar, Kids See Ghosts' self-titled album, "You Won't Get What You Want" by Daughters, "The Turning Wheel" by Spellling, and most recently, "Sinner Get Ready" by Lingua Ignota.
On June 11th 2018, Anthony gave Kid Cudi and Kanye West's collaborative a 10/10. Kid Cudi had received a 0/10 for his previous album "Speeding Bullet To Heaven" only two years prior. Kid Cudi is the only artist on Anthony Fantano's channel to receive both a 0/10 and a 10/10.
One of Anthony's most controversial episodes was when he gave Kanye West's critically lauded My Beatiful Dark Twisted Fantasy a 6/10 and when he gave Mac Miller's Swimming a 3/10, with many complaining that it is a part of the same project as his posthumous album Circles, an album which Fantano gave an 8/10.
Anthony Fantano is known for having a "thicky," and is often referred to as a "thick boy."
Fantano has given four albums a 0/10. Those albums are, Speeding Bullet 2 Heaven by Kid Cudi, The Big Day by Chance the Rapper, Father of All... by Green Day, and most recently, Welcome to the Madhouse by Tones and I.